Women still in grip of idealized love and sex, purveyed by romantic fiction

Modern women are still heavily influenced by the idealised love and sex, purveyed by romantic fiction, says broadcaster and agony aunt Susan Quilliam in this month's Journal of Family Planning and Reproductive Health Care.

In some parts of the developed world, romance accounts for nearly half of all fiction titles purchased.

And while there is clearly a place for the genre, which can be enjoyable and fun, this rose-tinted view of relationships is not necessarily doing women any favours, argues Ms Quilliam.

"I would argue that a huge number of the issues we see in our clinics and therapy rooms are influenced by romantic fiction," she writes. "What we see ... is more likely to be influenced by Mills and Boon than by the Family Planning Association."

The genre has come a long way in terms of depicting a more realistic view of the world, says Ms Quilliam, "still a deep strand of escapism, perfectionism and idealisation runs through the genre," she writes.

"Clearly those messages run totally counter to those we try to promote," she says, referring to portrayals of non-consensual sex; female characters who are "awakened" by a man rather than being in charge of their own desires.

The genre also promotes unreal expectations, she says, with heroines always achieving a life of multiple orgasms and trouble free pregnancies.

"Above all we teach that sex may be wonderful and relationships loving, but neither are ever perfect and that idealising them is the short way to heartbreak," she writes.

"And while romance may be the wonderful foundation for a novel, it's not in itself a sufficiently strong foundation for running a lifelong relationship," she says.

And there's another more "worrying difference" between sexual health professionals and the producers of romantic fiction, says Ms Quilliam. "To be blunt, we like condoms - for protection and for contraception - and they don't."

She points to a recent survey of romantic fiction titles in which only one in 10 mentioned condom use, with most scenarios depicting the heroine typically rejecting their use on the grounds that she wanted "no barrier" between her and the hero.

The romance readers who responded to the survey understood that they were reading fictional accounts and that spontaneous sexual encounters were never risk free, but there was a clear correlation between the frequency of romance reading and negative attitudes to condom use, she says.

"I'm not arguing that all romantic fiction is misguided, wrong or evil - to do so would be to negate my teenage self as well as the many millions of readers who innocently enjoy romances," Ms Quilliam writes.

But she concludes: "Sometimes the kindest and wisest thing we can do for our clients is to encourage them to put down the books - and pick up reality."

Related Stories

Office romance? Not a problem most of time: study

Feb 09, 2010

(PhysOrg.com) -- Pam and Jim on The Office. Meredith and McDreamy on Grey's Anatomy. Television shows depict many workplace romances, but in the real world how do co-workers view love on the job? According ...

Teens in Love Do Less Crime

Jan 21, 2009

(PhysOrg.com) -- Teenagers in love may be less likely to get mixed up in crime and substance abuse, according to new UC Davis research. But while romantic love seems to help keep teens law-abiding, casual sex can mean trouble.

Recommended for you

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

dogbert
not rated yet Jul 07, 2011
Susan Quilliam seems to have a very poor opinion of women in general.

Women can enjoy fiction and still live in the real world the same as men.
Sabine
5 / 5 (1) Jul 07, 2011
I'd say compulsive reading of Mills and Boons novel (NOT merely reading them) is a symptom of something other and deeper. There may be a correlation between reading Mills&Boons and engaging in risky behaviour but that doesn't mean it's a cause.
Vendicar_Decarian
1 / 5 (1) Jul 08, 2011
Womens is nuts.

I partly blame God, but mostly blame a culture that fosters these idealized relationships when nature evolved man for a 30 year lifespan and a roving eye.
lightofreason
not rated yet Jul 15, 2011
I think it's true that many women yearn and respond to the romantic. I am finding that it is possible to feel those glorious romantic feelings and listen repeatedly to, say, Mad About the Boy (Greta Keller version) and enjoy myself tremendously exploring and responding to a romantic scenario and yet at the same time be aware that the romance is only one tiny little slice of a very large pie. Romance quickly dies when you find the light of your life picking his spots or engaging in other unappealing activities, aye?