Just messy or is it hoarding? Sorting out darker reality hidden inside clutter

By Molly McElroy
A living room of a hoarder, similar to the photo shown to UW students. Credit: Shadwwulf at en.wikipedia

It was a living room, but barely looked like one. The lecture-hall audience grew quiet seeing a photo of a room cluttered with mail, bills, and boxes projected onto the screen. The couch had only one empty spot – a butt-size space that faced the TV.

The scene changed to the “after” photo, and a collective “Whoa!” reverberated throughout Kane 120 as 400 Psychology 101 students took in the de-cluttered room: beige carpeting with a beige couch and chairs, a coffee table, some lamps and the TV.

We joke about being pack rats or collectors. But an overflowing garage or extensive collection of whosiewhatsits does not signal hoarding. What separates hoarders is that their extreme clutter causes shame, takes over their lives and prevents use of the home. It’s a prevalent mental health problem that currently has no formal diagnostic criteria and is extremely hard to treat.

“If you watch hoarding reality shows, the producers often bring in a professional organizer, rather than a psychotherapist, under the assumption that these folks are just disorganized,” said Kevin King, UW assistant psychology professor. “The research on hoarding is behind that on obsessive-compulsive disorder, and the popular culture reflects this.”

Hoarding is classified as a type of obsessive-compulsive disorder, but emerging evidence suggests that it’s a much different condition. King chose hoarding for his class to highlight a real-world psychological problem and discuss a scientifically-sound treatment. He invited Travis Osborne, a Seattle psychologist who treats hoarding and has made appearances on The Learning Channel’s “Hoarding: Buried Alive,” to give a guest lecture.

Osborne believes there is a spectrum of how people deal with stuff.  There are the minimalists – “think IKEA catalog,” he said – and then in ascending levels of disarray, there are normal consumers, collectors, disorganized types and then finally hoarders.

“Many hoarders like to think of themselves as collectors,” said Osborne, who is also a clinical instructor in the UW department of psychology and has worked with hoarders for about five years. “But collectors take pride in their possessions, whereas hoarders feel shame when other people see all of the stuff that they have in their homes.”

Hoarding is a common psychiatric issue, with between 2.5 - 5 percent of the population afflicted. According to the 5 percent estimate, as many as 96,000 King County residents could have trouble with hoarding. But few hoarders come in for treatment, Osborne said.  He also said that studies suggest that more men than women hoard, and hoarding may be more prevalent in older adults, though that’s probably just due to years of not throwing stuff away.

“Hoarding almost always starts in childhood, where they have a really hard time getting rid of things,” he said. But youngsters’ hoarding tendencies can take a while to become apparent. “If there are parents or other people in the house getting rid of things, stuff doesn’t build up as much until they live on their own.”

Some hoarders are so embarrassed by their mess that they will live without heat or water rather than have a handyman come in. In one hoarding case that Osborne treated, a kitchen was rendered unusable for 10 years, and the occupants prepared their food with a microwave and mini-fridge.

Medications don’t really put a dent in hoarding, and Osborne said that there are tremendous obstacles to treating it through behavioral interventions.

Few studies have examined treatments for hoarding, but cognitive-behavioral therapy shows promise. It involves a mix of 26 home and office visits and takes many patients about a year to complete. Once completed, studies have shown that about 70 percent of patients are rated as improved by their therapists.

Osborne uses this therapy with his hoarding patients. He coaches them through their problems and accompanies them on shopping excursions or where they get free stuff to help them practice walking away from items. If they protest, he tells them to think about the item for 24 hours and then see how strongly they feel about it.

“What people usually find is that the feeling to acquire something is usually gone within minutes or hours,” Osborne said. This is usually surprising to patients, because they think that the urge to get an item will “torture them forever.”

He also helps hoarders practice getting rid of things, by having them prioritize what they can throw out first. “The more that they practice this, the easier it gets,” Osborne said.

But even when the house is clear, many people who hoard have deficits in various information processing skills that make maintaining tidiness a struggle. “We teach them problem solving and organizational skills to hopefully help them keep up the progress they’ve made,” Osborne said.

Patients need to continue to practice the skills they learned in treatment and catch their lapses as they happen. And those folks, "really can make significant improvements in their quality of life,” he said.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Is there a hidden bias against creativity?

Nov 18, 2011

CEOs, teachers, and leaders claim they want creative ideas to solve problems. But creative ideas are rejected all the time. A new study, which will be published in an upcoming issue of Psychological Science, a journal of the ...

Kids born with HIV growing up well

Apr 21, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- Once facing an almost certain death sentence, most children born with HIV are now faring well into adolescence and adulthood, according to a newly published study co-authored by Tulane infectious diseases ...

Recommended for you

Updating memory for fact and fiction

1 hour ago

Sunlight can make people sneeze. Sounds ludicrous? But it's true - it's called a photic sneeze reflex, and can occur in about one out of four people. Did you believe that fingerprints are unique to each individual? That, ...

Wide-faced men negotiate nearly $2,200 larger signing bonus

1 hour ago

Having a wider face helps men when they negotiate for themselves but hurts them when they are negotiating in a situation that requires compromise. Additionally, men who are more attractive are better collaborators compared ...

Can you be addicted to the internet?

1 hour ago

A McMaster researcher is trying to understand how much time people spend online – and whether their habits pose a danger to their physical or mental health.

Controlling childbirth pain tied to lower depression risk

10 hours ago

Controlling pain during childbirth and post delivery may reduce the risk of postpartum depression, writes Katherine Wisner, M.D., a Northwestern Medicine® perinatal psychiatrist, in a July 23 editorial in Anesthesia & An ...

How children categorize living things

19 hours ago

How would a child respond to this question? Would his or her list be full of relatives, animals from movies and books, or perhaps neighborhood pets? Would the poppies blooming on the front steps make the list or the oak tree ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Cave_Man
not rated yet Dec 23, 2011
It's probably just instinct. I'm always throwing away consumer crap and then later in the course of my work i think back to some useless thing i've thrown out and thought, "Oh darn that little odd shaped piece of plastic or metal would have been just what i need"

I personally have started to horde glass and plastic bottles so that one day I can construct a comfy home or workshop studio from them. I'm not a hoarder though, at least I dont think so.

Really, if you step back and look, the entire world throws out billions of tons of raw materials and resources calling it "trash". This causes so many problems I would be able to list them all in my lifetime. Apart from old computers leaching heavy metals into the water table and strange new bacteria being found exclusively in landfills we are also wasting resources that are finite. How much rare earth metals are in landfills nowadays? Idiot kids and their Iphones are to blame, they always are.