Women soldiers see more combat than in prior eras, have same PTSD rate as men, study says

By Steve Tokar

(Medical Xpress) -- Women who served in the U.S. Army in Iraq and Afghanistan were involved in combat at significantly higher rates than in previous conflicts, and screened positive for post-traumatic stress disorder at the same rate as men, according to a study led by researchers at the San Francisco VA Medical Center and the University of California, San Francisco.

“While women technically are not supposed to serve in direct combat, this research demonstrates that, in reality, they are experiencing combat at a higher rate than we had assumed,” said lead author Shira Maguen, PhD, a clinical psychologist at SFVAMC and an assistant clinical professor of psychiatry at UCSF. “At the same time, it shows that men and women really don’t differ in how they react to the stresses of combat.”

Women in the U.S. military gradually have been integrated into combat roles since the early 1990s, and today comprise about 14 percent of Americans serving in uniform. Of roughly 2.2 million troops who have served in and Afghanistan, more than 255,000 have been women, according to the Pentagon. Under current U.S Army rules, women are not officially assigned to units whose primary mission is direct combat on the ground, but can be assigned to other roles in combat zones.

The study of 7,251 active-duty soldiers who served in Iraq and Afghanistan is the first study, the authors say, to include gender as a variable in examining responses to four combat-associated traumatic experiences: killing, witnessing someone being killed, exposure to death (seeing dead soldiers or civilians) and injury.

The authors found that 4 percent of women reported killing, 9 percent reported witnessing killing, 31 percent reported exposure to death and 7 percent were injured in the war zone.

In contrast, according to one study of the 1990-91 Gulf War, 1 percent of women reported killing, 14 percent reported witnessing someone dying and 2 percent suffered a combat-related injury. (Gulf War statistics on exposure to killing and death are not parallel with Iraq and statistics because the questions were asked differently in the earlier study.)  

The authors of the current study, published electronically in the Journal of Psychiatric Research on Dec. 14, 2001, found that for most categories of combat stress, the mental health effects on men and women were the same, with men and women screening positive for PTSD at the same rate – 18 percent. There was one statistically significant exception: women injured in combat were more likely to screen positive for PTSD than injured men.

Men overall were somewhat more likely to report post-deployment problem drinking, and women overall were somewhat more likely to report depression symptoms.

Twelve percent of women reported exposure to military sexual trauma (MST), defined as sexual assault or repeated sexual harassment, as opposed to 1 percent of men – a figure consistent with other research on combat-zone MST, noted Maguen. “However, there was no gender difference in the response to MST,” she said. “Whether you were a man or a woman, MST was strongly associated with PTSD and depression.”

Maguen said the study has important implications for the VA health care system. “If women are indeed being exposed to combat stressors at a higher rate than in prior eras, we have to be prepared to provide the services they need, and take into account the impact that these stressors can have on their mental health functioning,” she said. “We also need to take a closer look at physical injury and its potential impact on ’s psychological health.”

Co-authors of the study are David D. Luxton, PhD and Nancy A. Skopp, PhD of the Defense Centers of Excellence for Psychological Health and Traumatic Brain Injury, Tacoma, WA., and Erin Madden, MPH, of SFVAMC.

The study was supported by funds from the Department of Veterans Affairs.

SFVAMC has the largest medical research program in the national VA system, with more than 200 research scientists, all of whom are faculty members at UCSF.

UCSF is a leading university dedicated to promoting health worldwide through advanced biomedical research, graduate-level education in the life sciences and health professions, and excellence in patient care.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Women warriors show resilience similar to men

Jun 07, 2011

Women service members who experience combat are apparently as resilient as the men they serve alongside, according to a study published by the American Psychological Association.

Recommended for you

What is whisper therapy?

17 minutes ago

Consider the stress of modern life, with its cacophonous soundtrack of traffic, electronics and construction. It's no wonder so much of our leisure time is spent in a quest to let go of the workday and unwind. ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Corban
not rated yet Jan 16, 2012
Wait a second. If they were congruent, the PTSD rates should be proportionate to the number of bullets/shrapnel coming your way:

PTSD Elasticity = Trauma/Stimulus

Sure, women are involved in combat more (within population) but how do they extend this towards a between-population conclusion? If the women are not being shot at more often, yet experience the same trauma, this sounds like women are more sensitive to conflict.

Any cross-population comparison must be mindful of proportionality.