Advice urges wider sharing of heart care decisions

March 5, 2012 By MARILYNN MARCHIONE , AP Chief Medical Writer
In this Sept. 20, 2011 file photo, former Vice President Dick Cheney shows his heart pump while discussing his newly published book, “In My Time - A Personal and Political Memoir,” which is co-authored by his daughter Liz Cheney, at the Ronald Reagan Presidential Library and Museum in Simi Valley, Calif. The American Heart Association is urging doctors to talk more honestly with people who have very weak hearts and are considering pumps, pacemakers, new valves or procedures to open clogged arteries. Too often, patients with advanced heart failure don't realize what they are getting into when they agree to a treatment, and doctors assume they want everything possible done to keep them alive, says the new advice, published Monday, March 5, 2012, by the American Heart Association and endorsed by other medical groups. (AP Photo/David McNew, File)

(AP) -- A heart device might save your life but leave you miserable. That awful possibility is the reason for new advice urging doctors to talk more honestly with people who have very weak hearts and are considering pumps, pacemakers, new valves or procedures to open clogged arteries.

Too often, patients with advanced heart failure don't realize what they are getting into when they agree to a treatment, and doctors assume they want everything possible done to keep them alive, says the new advice, published Monday by the and endorsed by other medical groups.

It calls for shared decision making when patients face a that often proves fatal and they need to figure out what they really want for their remaining days. If they also have or failing kidneys, the answer may not be a heart device to prolong their lives.

"Patients may feel that the treatment was worse than the disease," said Dr. Larry Allen of the University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Center, who helped draft the new advice.

One of his former patients is an example: a 74-year-old man too weak to go shopping or walk around his neighborhood. He was so miserable that doctors thought he would feel better with a "mini " - a $100,000 left ventricular assist device to make his heart pump better.

"Even if it goes well, people are left with an electrical cord coming out of their belly" and a higher risk of stroke and bleeding from the nose or throat, Allen said.

The man suffered bleeding problems, needed a and spent 10 weeks in the hospital. He and his wife hated that his device kept him tethered to a or gave him only a few hours of freedom on . Some models last longer.

"They came to us a couple months after he went home and said his was not what he wished" and asked to have the pump turned off, Allen said. The man died about a year ago.

By contrast, former Vice President Dick Cheney, 71, has been living with a heart assist device since the summer of 2010 and reports "doing well for now" in his recent memoir. Cheney, who had the first of five heart attacks at age 37, proudly shows off the long-life batteries he wears in a vest.

"I've gotten used to the various contraptions that are always with me, and I'm working and traveling, I've hunted a time or two, and I have some fishing planned," he wrote in his memoir released last year.

More than 5 million Americans have heart failure, and the number is growing as the population ages. It occurs when a heart becomes too weak - because of a heart attack, high blood pressure or other condition - to pump enough blood. Fluid can back up into the lungs, causing shortness of breath, weight gain, fatigue and swollen ankles.

Many high-tech treatments are available to treat advanced disease. But they usually don't slow its progression, they just keep people from dying. And that means living longer with steadily worsening symptoms. Patients don't often understand that when they agree to gadgets like a $30,000 to $50,000 implanted defibrillator, which shocks a quivering heart back into normal rhythm.

"Defibrillators don't actually make people feel better - it doesn't treat the underlying heart failure. All it does is abort sudden death," Allen said.

More than 100,000 defibrillators are implanted each year in the United States, and one quarter of them are replacement operations because a battery has worn out (they last three to five years). That often is done without reconsidering whether a patient's health has deteriorated so much that the device isn't a good idea, three Harvard Medical School doctors wrote recently in the New England Journal of Medicine.

The new heart association advice takes aim at this problem. It urges:

-An annual talk between heart failure patients and doctors to set treatment goals for the present and for possible emergencies such as cardiac arrest.

-"Milestone" reviews after any big change such as hospitalization, a defibrillator shock, worsening kidney problems or dementia.

-Discussing not just survival gains but also potential problems from devices or treatments, such as side effects, loss of independence, quality of life and obligations on families and caregivers.

-Considering palliative care, which does not mean stopping treatment.

The goal is "not only living long, it's living well. People often make decisions about the `long' without even considering the `well,'" said Jessie Gruman, president of the Center for Advancing Health, a patient advocacy group. The heart association asked Gruman, who has had several cancers and a heart problem, to review the advice from a patient's perspective.

The worst thing is to have no plan or clear goals when an emergency occurs, she said.

"The person who's ill may not have particular cognitive clarity and the caregivers may be upset and exhausted. They just haven't thought it through - they haven't had a chance to think it through. They've never done this before," Gruman said.

Mary Jane Eaton has thought it through. She's 80 and lives in Aurora, Colo., just east of Denver. Twenty years ago, she had a new valve put in that is leaking now. She has and chest pains, probably from . After talks with her cardiologist, Dr. Jennifer Dorosz, she has decided to treat her fluid buildup with higher doses of water pills and not have any more tests or surgery.

"I can't see that I could go through that," she said. "At my age, I just figure you know what, when the Lord's ready for me, he's going to take me. And I don't want to be taken on the operating table."

Explore further: Artificial heart implants approved in U.S.

More information: Heart Association:
Heart failure info:


Related Stories

Artificial heart implants approved in U.S.

September 6, 2006

The use of fully implanted artificial hearts for patients with advanced heart failure was approved for use Wednesday by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.

New heart failure device is tested

October 17, 2006

Physicians at 50 U.S. medical facilities are taking part in a multinational clinical trial of a device designed to help heart failure victims.

Heart pumps save lives

June 14, 2010

Heart failure is a very common condition: around 200,000 people in Sweden have been diagnosed with the disease. Some patients with life-threatening heart failure can be helped by mechanical heart pumps, reveals a thesis from ...

Tiny heart pump helps heart attack, heart failure patients

March 25, 2011

In 2008, physicians at the West Virginia University Heart Institute became the first in the state to use the Impella left ventricular assist device. Now, they are among the first in the nation to use it in heart attack and ...

A pulse no longer necessary for life

June 15, 2011

( -- While most people connect a pulse and a heartbeat to life, Dr. Billy Cohn and Dr. Bud Frazier from the Texas Heart Institute have found a way to keep the blood circulating and extend the life of patients ...

Recommended for you

Amyloid-related heart failure now detectable with imaging test

August 24, 2016

A type of heart failure caused by a build-up of amyloid can be accurately diagnosed and prognosticated with an imaging technique, eliminating the need for a biopsy, according to a multicenter study led by researchers at Columbia ...

Biomarkers may help better predict who will have a stroke

August 24, 2016

People with high levels of four biomarkers in the blood may be more likely to develop a stroke than people with low levels of the biomarkers, according to a study published in the August 24, 2016, online issue of Neurology, ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.