No evidence that higher regional health care costs indicate inappropriate care, study shows

There is no solid evidence to support the widely held belief that regions of the United States that spend more on health care and have higher rates of health care use deliver more unnecessary care to patients, or that low-cost areas deliver higher quality and more efficient care, according to a study led by Salomeh Keyhani, MD, a physician at the San Francisco VA Medical Center and an assistant professor of medicine at the University of California, San Francisco.

The study authors called for policies designed to discourage inappropriate care, regardless of region.

"Geographic variations in have captured the attention of researchers for the past 30 years, especially during the recent debate," said Keyhani. "The assumption is that areas that spend more are delivering more inappropriate care in the form of unnecessary tests and procedures." In turn, she said, "this has led policy makers to hold up low-cost areas as models of high-quality health care, and to propose policies that cap spending."

That assumption is unwarranted, according to Keyhani and her co-authors. "The literature is so limited that you cannot either support or refute such an assertion. There is just not enough data," said Keyhani.

In their study, the scientists reviewed 114,830 peer-reviewed articles, published between January 1, 1978 and January 1, 2009. They found only five that analyzed detailed clinical data in relation to geographic region, and concluded that the results of those papers "did not lend support" to the idea that higher cost regions deliver more inappropriate care. Their literature review was published in the March issue of the journal .

"Do we have any evidence to say that the differences in cost of care in different localities are actually related to inappropriate care? No," asserted Keyhani.

She concluded that "instead of focusing on geographic variations, more of our efforts should be directed at designing policies that will reduce inappropriate care in general, regardless of region."

However, said Keyhani, "you need good scientific evidence to design such policies, and right now, that evidence is lacking." In a related literature review based on the same 30-year data base, published on January 23 in the Archives of Internal Medicine, Keyhani and her colleagues found only 172 peer-reviewed articles that addressed the general topic of health care overuse.

One reason for the dearth of such literature, Keyhani said, is an overall lack of patient care guidelines by which researchers might judge overuse of tests and procedures: "There are not enough guidelines, and most of those that do exist don't address inappropriate care. Guidelines state when you should give a diagnostic test, for example, but they don't say when you shouldn't. And if you have no standards, how can you say when care is inappropriate?"

Creating guidelines is "expensive and very labor intensive," acknowledged Keyhani. "And it's not something one health system can do by itself. There needs to be a national investment."

Nonetheless, she said, the long-term benefits of such guidelines for the U.S. health care system would be considerable. "Overuse isn't just a matter of unnecessary expense, but of patient safety," she noted. "People assume that more care is better. In fact, we know that unwarranted procedures can add to health risks and lead to poor outcomes."

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Study examines research on overuse of health care services

Jan 23, 2012

The overuse of health care services in the United States appears to be an understudied problem with research literature limited to a few services and rates of overuse varying widely, according to an article published in the ...

Quality health care delivery key election issue, says CMAJ

Apr 06, 2011

Delivering quality health care rather than health care sustainability is a key issue for Canada's federal election, and Canadians need a vision from federal leaders to radically transform our health care system, states an ...

Recommended for you

How can we help manage eating disorders?

5 hours ago

These guidelines are for the clinical management of eating disorders They are intended to provide current evidence based guidance on the assessment and treatment of people with eating disorders by psychiatrists and other ...

User comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.