The only experiment in the country to predict outcome of Obama health care reform was not successful

June 27, 2012 by Leslie Cranford

(Medical Xpress) -- With the U.S. Supreme Court decision looming on the fate of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) – informally known as Obamacare – two Texas Tech University researchers and a former colleague have published research that shows a similar plan implemented by Mitt Romney in Massachusetts did not work well for hospital productivity in the short term.

“Mandatory Insurance Coverage and Productivity in Massachusetts: Bending the Curve?” co-authored by Mark Thompson, associate professor; Timothy Huerta, assistant professor and director of the Center for Health Innovation, Education, and Research; and Eric Ford, Forsythe Medical Center Distinguished Professor of Health Care, at the University of North Carolina at Greensboro, is now available here, published ahead of print as a PDF in Health Care Management Review.

Several years ago it was decided the state of Massachusetts was going to provide insurance for every citizen. Huerta said the basic idea of both Romneycare and Obamacare is to get people out of emergency rooms, and into primary care. Their health can be better managed, there would be lower total in the health care system, and that will stem the increased cost in health care.

“What we found was that in the years immediately after implementation – we looked at 2005-2008 – was that hospitals became much less efficient for years in Massachusetts,” Huerta said.

“There are lots of ways of looking at the results, but the productivity of hospitals – in other words, the numbers of patients they see for the resources they put into the system (outputs divided by inputs) – what those figures told us was that, relative to the rest of the U.S., Massachusetts hospitals saw a decline in productivity.”

Huerta said the point of the research was to assess if mandatory health insurance in Massachusetts led to increases in its hospitals’ productivity, compared to the rest of the U.S.

“It’s really the only experiment we have to look at to see what would happen if everyone in the U.S. had health insurance.”

Huerta explains.

“It’s believed that having everyone in a common pool means that the total cost per person will be lower. That’s spreading the cost among a larger group of people. When more people have insurance, they’re more likely to see the doctor. So you would expect that preventative care would prevail and that you’d be able to catch things before they become costly. The theory about having a health care system where everybody is covered is that you’re ‘bending the cost curve.’”

That bent curve, Huerta said, makes reference to the fact that the cost of health care grows faster than the growth of the economy. Last year health care cost grew at 6 percent.

“If that’s the assumption, then we have an experiment in Massachusetts,” Huerta said, “so our idea was to see how Massachusetts fared when they started this program, against all the other hospitals in the U.S.”

For the study researchers used the American Hospital Association’s annual survey and the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ case mix index for fiscal years 2005 through 2008. That formula included 2,967 hospitals for the U.S. minus 51 hospitals from Massachusetts, for a total of 2,916 hospitals.

In 2005, Massachusetts had 69 general medicine facilities and the U.S. had 4,856. Therefore 73 percent of eligible hospitals in Massachusetts provided complete data compared to 59 percent in the rest of the U.S.

At least in the early stages, the numbers showed Massachusetts coverage mandates led to a significant drop in hospitals’ productivity relative to comparable facilities in other states. In 2008, Massachusetts functioned 3.53 percent below its 2005 level, whereas facilities across the U.S. saw a 4.06 percent increase over the same time period.

Researchers concluded that if the individual mandate is implemented nationwide, the Massachusetts experience indicates that in a near term, a decrease in overall will occur. As such, current cost estimates of the PPACA legislation’s impact on overall health spending are potentially understated.

“So our argument is, not that it’s the end of the world, but that the reorganization of the system has a productivity cost,” Huerta said. “If what happened in Massachusetts happens on a national scale, we should expect hospitals to be less productive in the near term. And we don’t know what’s going to happen in the long term. We have no idea because the data doesn’t go out that far.

“It’s this idea that when this is put into place, people immediately expect results. And it’s worse because the instant results they’ll see are negative results. Of course you’re going to hear all sorts of negative things. But we don’t know if it’s a short-term cost for a long- term gain.”

Explore further: Diagnosis on state health care

Related Stories

Diagnosis on state health care

May 2, 2011

Massachusetts Gov. Deval Patrick defended the state’s five-year-old health care reform Thursday (April 28), saying it has resulted in 98 percent of residents and 99.8 percent of children being covered by health insurance, ...

Recommended for you

Bright lighting encourages healthy food choices

May 26, 2016

Dining in dimly lit restaurants has been linked to eating slowly and ultimately eating less than in brighter restaurants, but does lighting also impact how healthfully we order?

Big Data can save lives, says leading cancer expert

May 16, 2016

The sharing of genetic information from millions of cancer patients around the world could be key to revolutionising cancer prevention and care, according to a leading cancer expert from Queen's University Belfast.

New soap to ward off malaria carrying mosquitoes

May 13, 2016

(Medical Xpress)—Gérard Niyondiko along with colleagues Frank Langevin and Lisa Barutel has posted a project on the crowd source funding site ulule for a product called Faso Soap. They claim the soap can cut in half the ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.