Examiners tend to grade relative to work already seen, research finds

(Medical Xpress)—How well you fare on a subjective evaluation – whether it's of you treating a patient, auditioning for a play or even interviewing for a job – may depend largely on the person who was examined just before you. And the worse the person before you did, the better for you.

That sobering conclusion by University of British Columbia professor Kevin Eva resulted from a that examined whether physician-educators' grading of younger doctors could be influenced by the quality of those they had previously evaluated.

The study was one of two articles by Eva, to be published Dec. 5 in (The ).

Conducted with researchers at the University of Manchester, it asked physician educators in England and Wales to grade videos of young doctors in their first year of post-graduate training. The doctors portrayed in the videos followed scripts to represent three levels of performances – good, poor, and borderline – as they examined patients.

Some physician-educators were primed by first viewing the good performances while others viewed the poor performances. Then both groups were compared on their grading of the borderline performances.

Educators who had been primed by poor performances consistently gave better grades than those who had just watched the good performances – depending on the patient case, the grades were 30 to 100 per cent better.

"This experiment shows that judging someone's performance – whether it's clinical skills, essay-writing, or figure skating – is likely to be relative," says Eva, Director of and Scholarship in the Department of Medicine and a Senior Scientist at UBC's Centre for Scholarship.

"While such assessments are unavoidable in determining whether a student has mastered the required competencies in a field like medicine, we need to take steps to minimize contrast bias," Eva says. "It is important to ensure that there are a sufficient number of evaluations – the more data points, the more reliable the aggregate score will be."

In the second study published in the same edition of JAMA, Eva and collaborators examined the validity of multiple mini-interviews (MMIs) – a dozen, brief encounters in which applicants are asked to solve a problem through discussion with an interviewer, or through interaction with an actor or another applicant. MMIs have come to replace longer, more traditional interviews at most Canadian medical schools (including UBC's Faculty of Medicine).

The researchers found that students accepted to McMaster University, the first Canadian medical school to adopt MMIs, performed better years later on licensing examinations than students whom McMaster rejected but who were accepted at other, non-MMI schools.

Eva is an expert in the education of health professionals but he has also demonstrated how seemingly unrelated factors can affect judgment in a very different domain – men's physical attractiveness.

In 1999, he and a fellow graduate student at McMaster University asked women to view photographs and brief descriptions of men, and to rate their attractiveness on a 7-point scale. Men labeled as married had a mean attractiveness score that was 23 per cent higher than when the same men were labeled as single. As he and his collaborator wrote in CMAJ (Canadian Medical Association Journal): "Our findings do support the notion that being 'taken' influences perceptions of 'goodness."

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Bias may exist in rating of medical trainees

Dec 04, 2012

Peter Yeates, M.B.B.S., M.Clin.Ed., of the University of Manchester, United Kingdom, and colleagues conducted a study to examine whether observations of the performance of postgraduate year 1 physicians influence raters' ...

Study supports students not repeating a school year

Oct 14, 2011

(PhysOrg.com) -- A study by the University of Sydney's Professor Andrew Martin, published in this month's issue of the British Educational Research Journal, makes new findings of better outcomes for students who do not re ...

Medical student gender and self-confidence

Oct 03, 2008

Despite performing equally to their male peers in the classroom and the clinic, female medical students consistently report decreased self-confidence and increased anxiety, particularly over issues related to their competency. ...

Recommended for you

With kids in school, parents can work out

22 hours ago

(HealthDay)—Back-to-school time provides an opportunity for parents to develop an exercise plan that fits into the family schedules, an expert suggests.

Obama offers new accommodations on birth control

Aug 22, 2014

The Obama administration will offer a new accommodation to religious nonprofits that object to covering birth control for their employees. The measure allows those groups to notify the government, rather than their insurance ...

Use a rule of thumb to control how much you drink

Aug 22, 2014

Sticking to a general rule of pouring just a half glass of wine limits the likelihood of overconsumption, even for men with a higher body mass index. That's the finding of a new Iowa State and Cornell University ...

User comments