Clerical training fostered a predisposition to perpetrate child sexual abuse, study shows

(Medical Xpress)—Clerical training fostered a predisposition to perpetrate child sexual abuse, study shows

The emotional and issues which likely predisposed some men who entered the seminary in Ireland to perpetrate were exacerbated by the clerical training and culture they experienced, according to study findings published in the International Journal of & Neglect.

The research highlights that the prohibition of friendship, and the promotion of sexuality as sinful served to compound and amplify psychological conflicts that had developed during the offender's early life.

"What our research shows is a culture within the training of Irish Catholic priests that militated against the integration of emotional and sexual development and hindered psychological maturation, resulting in some men with very serious intimacy and relationship difficulties," says the first author of the report, Dr Paul D'Alton, UCD School of Psychology, University College Dublin, and St Vincent's University Hospital.

The study involved nine clergy who had perpetrated child and were attending professional psychotherapy. The interview schedules with the offenders were taken from a thematic analysis of a random selection of 'life stories' (autobiographical accounts of participants' life histories completed as part of group therapy).

All of the participants displayed significant difficulties forming friendships and close relationships, a condition common among perpetrators of child sexual abuse.

"What appears among our study participants, and therefore is likely for other clerical offenders, is the experience of a culture and system that failed to re-balance or correct any early problems they may have had but rather acted to compound them through the strict imposition of certain beliefs and ideology," adds Dr D'Alton.

The findings published in The International Journal of Child Abuse and Neglect point to a prevailing ideology that compounded psychosexual and psychosocial vulnerabilities during the participants' clerical training, and thus fostered any predisposition to perpetrate sexual abuse.

According to Dr D'Alton, the findings support other studies suggesting several unique factors associated with sexual abuse within the clerical environment. Thus a multifactoral model of the development child sex offenders in indicated.

The study shows a failure of the culture and practices within clerical training to re-balance or resolve any psychological conflicts that had already developed during the offender's early life.

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

New study challenges stereotypes of adolescent sex offenders

Jul 19, 2010

Adolescent sex offenders are often stereotyped and treated as socially inept, but new research negates this image, finding that they are more likely to be characterized by atypical sexual interests -- such as desire for prepubescent ...

Recommended for you

HPV vaccine knowledge doesn't predict vaccination

Sep 16, 2014

(HealthDay)—Neither parents' nor adolescents' knowledge about human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccines predicts vaccination compliance, according to a study published online Sept. 15 in Pediatrics.

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

baudrunner
not rated yet Feb 18, 2013
In other words, the motivation for entering the clergy remains unaddressed. Obviously, better screening of those who intend to enter the priesthood or sisterhood stands foremost in the effort to restore the church's integrity. Historically speaking, the church has routinely sheltered those who might have been persecuted, even prosecuted, for being "different". Many sons and daughters from families with means were shuttled off "to answer their calling", along with a monetary gift to the abbot or mother superior. About 10% of people are born without clearly identifiable gender characteristics. Acceptance of "difference" in modern society can only enhance the quality of clergy over the long term, as there will be no reason but the genuine one to enter into the service of God.
dan_murray_7169
not rated yet Feb 27, 2013
Abel Screening, Inc. develops psychological tests to protect children from sexual abuse. The Diana Screen® is used by religious & secular organizations to reduce the risk of placing men and women who present sexual risks to children and teenagers into positions of trust. The Abel Assessment for sexual interest-3™ (AASI-3) is used by clinicians to objectively measure a client's sexual interests and obtain information regarding involvement in a number of abusive or problematic sexual behaviors.
baudrunner
not rated yet Feb 28, 2013
Obviously these screening methods are sorely lacking in effectiveness, or they are simply not being used. Furthermore, people are very prepared to jump on the bandwagon to vilify the clergy, whereas in reality, the behavior in question is a fundamental one common to most of the population. It's well known that sexual abuse begins in the home. Sexual mores and standards as practiced by the public in private can be quite disturbing, and yet justified, because those behaviors are being practiced in the family.