Different treatments for acute kidney failure appear to often have similar outcomes

February 19, 2008

An analysis of studies examining treatments for acute kidney failure indicates that intermittent hemodialysis and continuous kidney replacement therapy appear to lead to similar clinical outcomes, including a similar risk of death, according to an article in the February 20 issue of JAMA.

Acute renal (kidney) failure (ARF) is increasingly common and is associated with high costs and adverse outcomes, including a higher risk of death, increased length of hospital stay and the requirement for chronic dialysis.

A variety of options are currently available for prescribing acute renal replacement (procedures which temporarily or permanently remedy insufficient cleansing of body fluids by the kidneys), including intermittent, continuous, and extended-duration hemodialysis and hemofiltration (similar to hemodialysis, a slow, continuous therapy in which sessions, usually daily, last between 12 to 24 hours), and a combinations of these. “Despite advances in dialysis technology, many questions remain about how best to provide renal replacement to patients with ARF,” the authors write.

Neesh Pannu, M.D., S.M., of the University of Alberta, Edmonton, Canada, and colleagues conducted a review and evaluation of current evidence for the optimal dialytic management of ARF. They searched databases for studies examining dialytic support in adults with acute renal failure that reported the incidence of clinical outcomes such as mortality, length of hospital stay, need for chronic dialysis, or development of hypotension (abnormally low blood pressure). From 173 retrieved articles, 30 randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and eight prospective cohort studies were eligible for inclusion.

An analysis of the data from the studies indicated that no conclusions could be drawn about optimal indications for or timing of renal replacement. Data comparing continuous renal replacement therapy (CRRT) with intermittent hemodialysis demonstrated no clinically relevant difference in outcomes between methods, including the risk of death, or for the requirement for chronic dialysis treatment in survivors. There was also no evidence that either CRRT or intermittent hemodialysis was superior for reducing resource use or the risk of chronic dialysis dependence in patients with ARF.

Regarding the recommended management strategy for patients with severe ARF, the authors write: “The decision to initiate renal replacement therapy (RRT) in patients with severe ARF requires consideration of multiple factors, including assessment of intravascular volume, electrolyte and acid-base status, uremia [retention in the bloodstream of waste products normally excreted in the urine], nutritional requirements, urine output, hemodynamic status, and the evolving clinical course of each patient. Potential advantages of earlier RRT initiation must be set against the hypothetical risks of treatment-induced renal injury, bleeding due to anticoagulation, and mechanical and infectious complications associated with central venous access.”

“Given the significantly higher cost of CRRT, intermittent hemodialysis may be preferable for patients with ARF who require RRT. In otherwise stable patients, alternate-day dialysis treatments of 4 or more hours using blood flows of 250 mL/min or greater are usually sufficient in patients with or without concomitant critical illness. More frequent hemodialysis may be required in highly catabolic [a destructive metabolic process] patients or to achieve treatment targets for fluid, electrolyte, or acid-base management, although data identifying how such targets should be set are limited. Despite the lack of data supporting its superiority and its higher cost, some clinicians may prefer to use CRRT in critically ill patients with ARF and severe hemodynamic instability. If CRRT is used, the target dose should be 35 mL/kg per hour [3 L/h in a 154 lb. person],” the researchers write.

Source: JAMA and Archives Journals

Explore further: Researchers examine racial and gender disparities in dialysis patients

Related Stories

Researchers examine racial and gender disparities in dialysis patients

November 3, 2017
University of Cincinnati (UC) researchers are examining racial and gender disparities in dialysis patients as well as the impact of poor functional status and pre-dialysis hospitalizations on elderly dialysis patients. Silvi ...

Reproducing higher-order embryonic kidney structures using pluripotent stem cells

December 19, 2017
In the embryonic kidney, three types of precursor cells interact to form three-dimensional structures of the kidney: nephron progenitor cells, ureteric buds, and interstitial progenitor cells. Methods to induce nephron structures ...

High burden, high cost and low awareness of kidney disease in the United States

October 30, 2017
According to an annual data report from the United State Renal Data System, the overall burden of kidney disease remains high in U.S. with the rates of kidney failure requiring dialysis or kidney transplantation ranking among ...

Low-intensity exercise improves efficiency of dialysis, study finds

December 15, 2017
Exercise isn't very appealing when you have extreme fatigue and nausea from a chronic illness such as kidney failure. So, when you find out lower-intensity exercise can make a difference, it can be a big relief, says Paul ...

ACP and CDC issue recommendations for hepatitis B screening, vaccination, and care

November 20, 2017
Reducing chronic hepatitis B infections by screening at-risk adults, increasing hepatitis B vaccination rates, and linking infected persons to care is a public health priority, the American College of Physicians (ACP) and ...

New tissue-engineered blood vessel replacements one step closer to human trials

November 1, 2017
Researchers at the University of Minnesota have created a new lab-grown blood vessel replacement that is composed completely of biological materials, but surprisingly doesn't contain any living cells at implantation. The ...

Recommended for you

More surprises about blood development—and a possible lead for making lymphocytes

January 22, 2018
Hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) have long been regarded as the granddaddy of all blood cells. After we are born, these multipotent cells give rise to all our cell lineages: lymphoid, myeloid and erythroid cells. Hematologists ...

How metal scaffolds enhance the bone healing process

January 22, 2018
A new study shows how mechanically optimized constructs known as titanium-mesh scaffolds can optimize bone regeneration. The induction of bone regeneration is of importance when treating large bone defects. As demonstrated ...

Bioengineered soft microfibers improve T-cell production

January 18, 2018
T cells play a key role in the body's immune response against pathogens. As a new class of therapeutic approaches, T cells are being harnessed to fight cancer, promising more precise, longer-lasting mitigation than traditional, ...

Weight flux alters molecular profile, study finds

January 17, 2018
The human body undergoes dramatic changes during even short periods of weight gain and loss, according to a study led by researchers at the Stanford University School of Medicine.

Secrets of longevity protein revealed in new study

January 17, 2018
Named after the Greek goddess who spun the thread of life, Klotho proteins play an important role in the regulation of longevity and metabolism. In a recent Yale-led study, researchers revealed the three-dimensional structure ...

The HLF gene protects blood stem cells by maintaining them in a resting state

January 17, 2018
The HLF gene is necessary for maintaining blood stem cells in a resting state, which is crucial for ensuring normal blood production. This has been shown by a new research study from Lund University in Sweden published in ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.