All work and no play makes for troubling trend in early education

February 12, 2009,
Anne Haas Dyson, University of Illinois
Anne Haas Dyson, a professor of curriculum and instruction at Illinois, says playtime for children is a "fundamental avenue" for learning. Credit: L. Brian Stauffer

Parents and educators who favor traditional classroom-style learning over free, unstructured playtime in preschool and kindergarten may actually be stunting a child's development instead of enhancing it, according to a University of Illinois professor who studies childhood learning and literacy development.

Anne Haas Dyson, a professor of curriculum and instruction in the U. of I. College of Education, says playtime for children is a "fundamental avenue" for learning, and attempts by parents and educators to create gifted children by bombarding them with information is well-intentioned but ultimately counterproductive.

"That approach doesn't appreciate the role of play and imagination in a child's intellectual development," Dyson said. "Play is where children discover ideas, experiences and concepts and think about them and their consequences. This is where literacy and learning really begins."

What Dyson calls the "banning of the imagination" in schools may be influenced by what some critics have called the "Baby Genius Edutainment Complex," a cottage industry of mind-enrichment products developed specifically for infants and toddlers and marketed to anxious parents eager to give their children's cognitive abilities an early boost.

"I see this 'Einstein in the crib' trend as a societal reduction of children to the means for fulfilling parents' desires for intellectual distinction," Dyson said.

"Children learn the way we all learn: through engagement, and through construction. They have to make sense of the world, and that's what play or any other symbolic activity does for children."

While Dyson does see some value in teaching the ABCs to children in pre-kindergarten, she thinks that trying to accelerate learning actually works against a child's development. Kindergarten and preschool, she said, should be a place for children to experience play as intellectual inquiry, before they get taken over by the tyranny of high-stakes testing.

"I'm certainly not opposed to literacy in the early grades," Dyson said, "but the idea that we can eliminate play from the curriculum doesn't make sense. Kids don't respond well to sitting still in their desks and listening at that age. They need stimulation."

Dyson said that having an early-childhood curriculum reduced to isolated test scores or other measurable pieces of information doesn't take into account a child's interests or an ability to imagine, problem solve or negotiate with other children, all of which are important social and intellectual qualities.

"All tests tell us is how many letters and how many sounds children know," she said. "I think there should be this grand societal conversation about what's intellectually motivating and exciting for our children."

Dyson doesn't believe there should be any sort of compromise in the amount of learning by rote and play that children experience, especially in preschool and kindergarten.

"We have to intellectually engage kids," she said. "We have to give them a sense of their own agency, their own capacity, and an ability to ask questions and solve problems. So we have to give them more open-ended activities that allow them the space they need to make sense of things."

So what can parents and educators do to stimulate children?

"I think parents ought to engage with their children," Dyson said.

"Follow the child's interests in people, objects, places, and activities, and talk with them. It's social interaction that creates a link between the child and an ongoing activity. Help them learn how to articulate themselves and participate in the world."

One thing that parents may worry too much about is the television shows their children watch. She said that parents should be attentive to what their children watch and make judgments about the appropriateness of the material, but more important, they need to talk with their children about what they see.

"I think we want children to grow up media-literate," Dyson said, "but we don't want to dismiss the sources of their pleasure only because it doesn't appeal to our adult sensibilities. Contemporary childhoods are mediated in large part by the media, and it can be very informative for kids."

Dyson said that the media inform children's play and even their early writing efforts. For example, a 5-year-old Dyson knows who is just learning about written language and the alphabet can already spell "Hannah," thanks to Hannah Montana, the popular Disney show character.

"Knowledge of media gets kids a lot of social cachet because their peers watch it, too," Dyson said. "And a lot of social bonding between children who normally wouldn't have much in common occurs when they watch the same shows."

Dyson is a co-author of the forthcoming book "Children, Language, and Literacy: Diverse Children in Diverse Times," which discusses the nature of contemporary early-childhood programs and children's language learning.

Source: University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign

Explore further: Three strategies to promote empathy in children

Related Stories

Three strategies to promote empathy in children

February 20, 2018
Johnny is five years old. He watches his friend Mark being teased by other kids, and then he sees Mark start to cry. As a parent, or caregiver, what do you hope Johnny will do?

Parents, stop nagging kids not to forget – set visual cues instead

February 22, 2018
Every day, we have to remember intentions to perform specific tasks in the future. We may need to remember to buy milk on the way home from work, to return a book to the library next week, or take a certain pill at 8am every ...

Younger and older siblings contribute positively to each other's developing empathy

February 20, 2018
Older siblings play an important role in the lives of their younger siblings. Like parents, older brothers and sisters act as role models and teachers, helping their younger siblings learn about the world. This positive influence ...

Here's how witnessing violence harms children's mental health

February 16, 2018
When children learn about news like the deadly school shooting that claimed more than a dozen lives on Feb. 14, 2018 in Broward County, Florida, a logical question for them to ask is: Will the same thing happen to me?

10 ways schools, parents and communities can prevent school shootings now

February 16, 2018
After a shooter killed 17 people at a Florida high school, many have expressed frustration at the political hand-wringing over gun control and calls for prayer.

How to 'bridge minds' with a child to stimulate brain development

February 15, 2018
A three-year-old boy struggles to thread beads on a string while his older sister watches. She could ignore him or take over the task to get it done quickly. But if she observes him closely, and realizes that he is struggling ...

Recommended for you

Young children use physics, not previous rewards, to learn about tools

February 23, 2018
Children as young as seven apply basic laws of physics to problem-solving, rather than learning from what has previously been rewarded, suggests new research from the University of Cambridge.

Study: Tinder loving cheaters—dating app facilitates infidelity

February 23, 2018
The popular dating app Tinder is all about helping people form new relationships. But for many college-aged people, it's also helping those in relationships cheat on their romantic partners.

Looking for the origins of schizophrenia

February 23, 2018
Schizophrenia may be related to neurodevelopmental changes, including brain's inability to generate an appropriate vascular system, according to new study resulted from a partnership between the D"Or Institute for Research ...

Color of judo uniform has no effect on winning

February 22, 2018
New research on competitive judo data finds a winning bias for the athlete who is first called, regardless of the colour of their uniform. This unique study, published in Frontiers in Psychology, puts to rest the debate on ...

Antidepressants are more effective than placebo at treating acute depression in adults, concludes study

February 22, 2018
Meta-analysis of 522 trials includes the largest amount of unpublished data to date, and finds that antidepressants are more effective than placebo for short-term treatment of acute depression in adults.

Infants are able to learn abstract rules visually

February 22, 2018
Three-month-old babies cannot sit up or roll over, yet they are already capable of learning patterns from simply looking at the world around them, according to a recent Northwestern University study published in PLOS One.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

4 / 5 (1) Feb 12, 2009
No kidding (pun intended) kids need to play to learn. Heck, if provided with the right environment and stimulus, many, particularly the gifted and those who are nontraditional learners like dyslexics and kinetics, would play their way into becoming experts at the work that would be their play for the rest of their lives. But force them into doing stuff they hate or that they aren't any good at no matter how hard they try, and they start to hate learning and begin to choose their livelihood based on the wrong criteria. How is this a surprise?

Raise your hand if, when you were growing up, you experienced "education as a form of torture" or look back and realize that the course of your education "guided" you into a field that is unfulfilling.

I'll bet there are lots of hands up. ;o)
1 / 5 (1) Mar 03, 2009
raised hand here hoping my son won't have to raise his hand next time the question's asked.

most of the current school system, private/public/charter has little for anyone who doesn't thrive in a parrot training setting with perfect parents, preferably well to do & with a traditional style homemaker at home.

god help any kid who can't sit still all day long w/o any recess, or who doesn't fit the audio/rote learning mode, or who is bored silly waiting on the rest of the class, or needs more 1 on 1.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.