DNA self-tests: More hype than help?

March 20, 2009 By Maria M. Perotin

With a little spit and a few keyboard strokes, you can unlock the secrets of your DNA. At least, it seems that simple at an array of Internet sites that are pitching genetic tests directly to consumers.

The businesses claim to examine customers' genes for conditions grave or mundane - from their risk of cancer to their likelihood of baldness.

They offer a tantalizing peek at the most personal facets of health. But the tests have raised eyebrows among genetic counselors and government regulators, who are skittish about consumers tapping into their DNA without a doctor's involvement.

"Genetic counselors are very concerned about people ordering some of this predisposition testing on their own on the Internet," said Becky Althaus, a genetic counselor at Texas Health Dallas hospital. "A lot of times, this stuff is very complicated. And the results are not that easy to interpret."

Alex Wong, director of products at a California-based company named 23andMe, said consumers have a right to access their own genetic details.

"We try to make it understandable to the average person," Wong said. "We don't just say that your risk has been increased by X-number percent and that's that."

Wong's business markets do-it-yourself kits that are supposed to reveal details about buyers' genealogy and health traits. The company, which includes Google among its investors, invites customers to "get the latest on your DNA with $399 and a tube of saliva."

The 23andMe test addresses dozens of conditions, from life-threatening diseases to genetic curiosities. Among them: whether you have a genetic predisposition for , your risk of , what type of earwax you have, whether you can taste bitter flavors and whether you're resistant to malaria.

Some of the tests are well-established among scientists, while the significance of others is far less certain.

"We're actually very careful to educate our users about the relative reliability of that information," Wong said.

Among the other tests available to consumers:

Colorado-based Sciona sells "personalized genetics assessments" that purport to reveal how your genetic makeup affects metabolism, diet, nutritional processing and lifestyle.

California-based Psynomics offers a test for two genetic mutations supposedly associated with bipolar disorder.

California-based HairDX says its test, only available from certain doctors, can predict the risk of baldness.

ScientificMatch.com pitches help finding a mate with "physical chemistry" based on your immune system genes. The Florida company says this boosts your chances of having a satisfying sex life, making healthy babies and avoiding infidelity. A lifetime membership is on sale for $995.


Skepticism abounds about the tests.

The Federal Trade Commission - together with the Food and Drug Administration and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention _ issued a warning in 2006 against at-home genetic tests.

The federal Government Accountability Office also sounded caution in 2006 after the agency investigated four DNA-testing Web sites _ including one that sold "personalized" dietary supplements and another that said its pills could repair damaged DNA.

Its findings: The businesses made misleading, medically unproven predictions. And they offered ambiguous recommendations based on consumers' lifestyles - not any unique genetic profile.

Last year, regulators in California and New York stepped up their scrutiny of the industry. And in April, a federal advisory committee concluded that there's insufficient oversight of the labs that market genetic tests to consumers and raised concern about potentially "adverse patient outcomes."

Jame Restau, a clinical nurse specialist at Baylor Medical Center at Irving, Texas, said patients are often curious about new research and which genetic tests may become available.

She tells them that many potentially meaningful tests are in the pipeline but warns that some businesses are promoting unproven tests.

"I think you have to be one of those cautious consumers," Restau said. "If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is."

Althaus, of Texas Health Dallas, said gets a lot of hype but holds a lot of promise. "Right now, we're just starting with tests for some pretty specific cancer genes. And now, there's a test for Alzheimer's, and there's a test for a predisposition for heart disease. So we really are getting some new information that can help people," she said. "Every day, they're discovering new things that can be valuable in helping us in treatment and in prevention."



Know that at-home tests aren't a substitute for a traditional health evaluation with conventional lab tests.

Realize that genetic tests provide only one piece of information about your susceptibility to a disease. Other factors, such as family background, medical history and environment, are also important.

Keep in mind that finding a particular gene doesn't necessarily mean a disease will develop.

Be wary of claims that you can protect against serious disease with nutritional supplements. The same goes for predictions about your ability to withstand environmental exposures, such as cigarette smoke.

Talk to your doctor beforehand about whether a genetic test might provide useful information and which test would be best for you.

Ask your doctor or a genetic counselor to help you understand your test results. Do that before making any dietary or other health-related decisions.

Check the testing company's privacy policy to see how it may use your personal information, including sharing it with marketers, and whether it posts results online.

Source: Federal Trade Commission


(c) 2009, Fort Worth Star-Telegram.
Visit the Star-Telegram on the World Wide Web at www.star-telegram.com
Distributed by McClatchy-Tribune Information Services.

Related Stories

Recommended for you

Association found between abnormal cerebral connectivity and variability in the PPARG gene in developing preterm infants

December 12, 2017
(Medical Xpress)—A team of researchers with King's College London and the National Institute for Health Research Biomedical Research Centre, both in the U.K., has found what they describe as a strong association between ...

Large genetic study links tendency to undervalue future rewards with ADHD, obesity

December 11, 2017
Researchers at University of California San Diego School of Medicine have found a genetic signature for delay discounting—the tendency to undervalue future rewards—that overlaps with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder ...

Gene variants identified that may influence sexual orientation in men and boys

December 8, 2017
(Medical Xpress)—A large team of researchers from several institutions in the U.S. and one each from Australia and the U.K. has found two gene variants that appear to be more prevalent in gay men than straight men, adding ...

Disease caused by reduction of most abundant cellular protein identified

December 8, 2017
An international team of scientists and doctors has identified a new disease that results in low levels of a common protein found inside our cells.

Study finds genetic mutation causes 'vicious cycle' in most common form of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

December 8, 2017
University of Michigan-led research brings scientists one step closer to understanding the development of neurodegenerative disorders such as ALS.

Mutations in neurons accumulate as we age: The process may explain normal cognitive decline and neurodegeneration

December 7, 2017
Scientists have wondered whether somatic (non-inherited) mutations play a role in aging and brain degeneration, but until recently there was no good technology to test this idea. A study published online today in Science, ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.