Finally, an E. coli answer: It was the sprouts

June 10, 2011 By KIRSTEN GRIESHABER and DAVID RISING , Associated Press
In this June 5, 2011 file picture greenhouses at an organic farm that grows bean sprouts are photographed in the Uelzen district, northern Germany, Sunday, June 5, 2011. Investigators have determined that German-grown vegetable sprouts are the cause of the E. coli outbreak that has killed 29 people and sickened nearly 3,000, the head of Germany's national disease control center said Friday, June 10, 2011. Reinhard Burger, president of the Robert Koch Institute, said even though no tests of the sprouts from an organic farm in Lower Saxony had come back positive for the E. coli strain behind the outbreak, an investigation into the pattern of the outbreak had produced enough evidence to draw the conclusion. (AP Photo/dapd, Axel Heimken,File)

Specialists in high-tech labs tested thousands of vegetables as they hunted for the source of world's deadliest E. coli outbreak, but in the end it was old-fashioned detective work that provided the answer: German-grown sprouts.

After more than a month of searching, health officials announced Friday they had determined that sprouts from an organic farm in the northern German village of Bienenbuettel were the source of the outbreak that has killed 31 people, sickened nearly 3,100 and prompted much of Europe to shun vegetables.

"It was like a crime thriller where you have to find the bad guy," said Helmut Tschiersky-Schoeneburg, head of Germany's consumer protection agency.

It's little surprise that sprouts were the culprit - they have been implicated in many previous food-borne outbreaks: ones in Michigan and Virginia in 2005, and large outbreak in Japan in 1996 that killed 11 people and sickened more than 9,000.

While sprouts are full of protein and vitamins, their ability to transmit disease makes some public health officials nervous. Sprouts have abundant surface area for bacteria to cling to, and if their seeds are contaminated, washing won't help.

"E. coli can stick tightly to the surface of seeds needed to make sprouts and they can lay dormant on the seeds for months," said Stephen Smith, a microbiologist at Trinity College in Dublin.

Once water is added to make them grow, the number of bacteria carried within the seeds can reproduce up to 100,000 times.

German investigators tracked the path of the bacteria step by step, from hospital patients struggling with diarrhea and kidney failure, to restaurants where they may have gotten sick, to specific meals and ingredients, to industrial food suppliers and the farms that grew the produce.

And they still have more questions to answer, such as what contaminated the sprouts in the first place? Bad seeds, contaminated water, nearby animals, the answer is still elusive.

Interviews with thousands of patients - mostly women between ages 20 to 50 with healthy lifestyles - led investigators to conclude initially that salads could be the problem.

Health officials immediately warned consumers to avoid cucumbers, tomatoes and lettuce - causing huge losses to European farmers as demand plummeted for their produce - but the seemingly ubiquitous alfalfa, radish and other sprouts weren't yet on anyone's radar.

"You get this stuff in every cafeteria," said Gert Hahne, spokesman for the agriculture ministry in Lower Saxony, the state where the contaminated sprouts were found. "But after two weeks of diarrhea, most people don't remember if they had a few sprouts on top of a ham sandwich or mixed into a salad."

Inspectors visited more than 400 farms in Lower Saxony alone looking for evidence and the state put 1,000 people on the case, including health authorities, food inspectors and veterinarians.

Experts conducted microbiologic tests - a total of 4,645 nationwide - but also visited the farms and checked their hygienic conditions, especially looking to see whether manure was used and could have contaminated produce.

Then on May 26, some pieces began to fit: patients mentioned they had eaten sprouts and inspectors visited a small organic farm near Bienenbuettel that grows many kinds of sprouts, including alfalfa, radish, onion, broccoli, garlic, linseed, wheat and sunflower varieties.

Although tests on those sprouts turned up negative - a common result in E. coli investigations, when the offending food is usually consumed before the probe begins - authorities started looking into the farm's delivery records.


That took them to a golf club in Lueneburg, a restaurant in Luebeck, another one in Rothenburg/Wuemme and cafeterias in Frankfurt, Darmstadt and Bochum - all places where customers had fallen ill.

The Robert Koch Institute, Germany's disease control center, also had a special team examine five groups in detail - a total of 112 people who had eaten in restaurants and of whom 19 had fallen ill. All of the sick people could be traced back to produce from the suspected farm.

"They even studied the menus, the ingredients, looked at bills and took pictures of the different meals, which they then showed to those who had fallen ill," said Andreas Hensel, head of Germany's risk assessment agency.

The Koch institute identified 26 clusters of sickened people - and are still looking into some 30 more - all connected with the farm.

Then, on Wednesday, the nearly-smoking gun: it was confirmed that three employees of the farm had fallen ill from E. coli bacteria in early May, when the outbreak first started.

On Thursday night, German medical and agriculture officials held a conference call.

"That's when we were told: 'your sprout lead is waterproof,'" Hahne said.

Reinhard Burger, the president of the Robert Koch Institute, said the epidemiological investigation produced enough evidence to pinpoint the sprouts as the source though no laboratory tests on them had come back positive.

"It was possible to narrow down epidemiologically the cause of the outbreak of the illness to the consumption of sprouts," Burger said Friday at a press conference. "It is the sprouts."

Burger still warned the crisis was not yet over and people should not eat sprouts. While the Bienenbuettel farm was shut down last week and all of its produce recalled, some tainted sprouts could still be in circulation.

Investigators were still testing seeds and other samples from the farm. Officials in North Rhine-Westphalia state also reported Friday that a new test had confirmed the deadly E. coli strain on a bag of sprouts from the farm that was in the garbage of a family near Cologne where two people had been sickened.

The outbreak has sickened nearly 3,000 people in Germany, with 759 of them suffering from a serious complication that can cause kidney failure. Twelve other European countries have 97 cases and the United States has three.

Authorities lifted the warning against eating cucumbers, tomatoes and lettuce, Russia agreed to lift its ban on European vegetable imports and European farmers who were forced to dump tons of unwanted produce breathed a sigh of relief.

But consumers were not yet fully convinced.

"It is a relief to finally get some definite information," said Heinz Schirnig, a 74-year-old resident of Uelzen, near the contaminated farm. "But I don't know if we can trust this."

Angelika Peilert, 59, from Berlin, was visiting Bienenbuettel on Friday.

"I will not eat any fruit or vegetables until they have an ultimate proof," she said. "Only fruit like bananas which you can peel. The risk is still too big. I have a small grandson and I want to see him grow up."

Explore further: Fewer people being referred to fall prevention programs, new study says


Related Stories

Fewer people being referred to fall prevention programs, new study says

February 12, 2018
More than half of older West Australians who reported falling over in the past year did not seek medical assistance, new Curtin University-led research has found, with a significant decline in the number of people being referred ...

People with learning disabilities suffer from a far greater number of illnesses than previously known

February 12, 2018
People with learning disabilities are suffering from a far greater number of illnesses than had been previously understood, adding to concerns that life-threatening conditions are being routinely missed.

Better tools needed to diagnose depression in people with autism

February 16, 2018
Autistic adults are not being effectively diagnosed with depression due to a lack of asessment tools, a new study has found.

People find comfort listening to the same songs over and over, study finds

February 16, 2018
With the frequency that some people play their favorite song, it's a good thing vinyl records aren't used often because they might wear out.

Understanding a fly's body temperature may help people sleep better

February 13, 2018
In findings that one day may help people sleep better, scientists have uncovered the first molecular evidence that two anciently conserved proteins in the brains of insects and mammals share a common biological ancestry as ...

Study finds that a surprise stimulus helps people stop an action

February 14, 2018
Imagine reaching to pet your cat, and it hisses at you. How does your brain take stock of the sound and communicate with your body to pull back your hand?

Recommended for you

Past encounters with the flu shape vaccine response

February 20, 2018
New research on why the influenza vaccine was only modestly effective in recent years shows that immune history with the flu influences a person's response to the vaccine.

Building better tiny kidneys to test drugs and help people avoid dialysis

February 16, 2018
A free online kidney atlas built by USC researchers empowers stem cell scientists everywhere to generate more human-like tiny kidneys for testing new drugs and creating renal replacement therapies.

Expanding Hepatitis C testing to all adults is cost-effective and improves outcomes

February 16, 2018
According to a new study, screening all adults for hepatitis C (HCV) is a cost-effective way to improve clinical outcomes of HCV and identify more infected people compared to current recommendations. Using a simulation model, ...

Study suggests expanded range for emerging tick-borne disease

February 16, 2018
Human cases of Borrelia miyamotoi, a tick-borne infection with some similarities to Lyme disease, were discovered in the eastern United States less than a decade ago. Now new research led by the Yale School of Public Health ...

Flu shot only 36 percent effective, making bad year worse (Update)

February 15, 2018
The flu vaccine is doing a poor job protecting older Americans and others against the bug that's causing most illnesses.

IFN-mediated immunity to influenza A virus infection influenced by RIPK3 protein

February 15, 2018
Each year, influenza kills half a million people globally with the elderly and very young most often the victims. In fact, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reported 37 children have died in the United States ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Jun 10, 2011
Hm... losses up to $611M/wk and they are to be compensated for half a week's worth of losses. A week can be a goodly portion of a farmer's entire crop. I understand the need to be cautious, but some bad calls have really hurt some farmers and the vegetable supply chain here.

When they eventually do figure this out I'd be interested in knowing if there are any specific farming techniques that these farms were or were not using that may have led to this outbreak.
2.8 / 5 (4) Jun 10, 2011
One German organic farm has killed twice as many people as the Fukushima nuclear disaster and the Gulf Oil spill combined.
1 / 5 (1) Jun 10, 2011
Yes there is a specific farming technique being used that allows human gut specific E. Coli to contaminate a field crop.

not rated yet Jun 11, 2011
Yes there is a specific farming technique being used that allows human gut specific E. Coli to contaminate a field crop.

You really think sprouts of any kind are a field crop? Obviously you have no experience in any area of agriculture, and even less actual knowledge.

Blind fanatic, pushing a narrow agenda.
not rated yet Jun 11, 2011
Will Germany shut down all organic farms now? Evidently they pose a much greater risk to public health than nuclear power does.
not rated yet Jun 11, 2011
Yes there is a specific farming technique being used that allows human gut specific E. Coli to contaminate a field crop.


Sprouts are not a field crop.
1 / 5 (1) Jun 11, 2011
Ah the gruesome legacy of Rachel Carson and her ilk, however perhaps real science will out: http://www.seattl...#photo-2
1 / 5 (1) Jun 12, 2011
Yes there is a specific farming technique being used that allows human gut specific E. Coli to contaminate a field crop.


Sprouts are not a field crop.
Where do YOU get your sprouts? From the organic food store? Seeds from mature plants are gathered, packaged and processed. The mature plants are field crops.
not rated yet Jun 13, 2011
The germans were quick to accuse the spanish for their problems. What a bunch of sissies. In these cases the first reaction is usually wrong. It just shows that "advanced" nations are arrogant and blame others first for their problems.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.