Mammography is 'imperfect' test

October 14, 2011 By Liz Szabo

For women today, turning 40 often brings birthday cake and candles. But it also brings a question: Should I get a mammogram?

Until two years ago, medical groups largely agreed should get annual mammograms beginning at age 40. In 2009, the U.S. Task Force, a group of doctors who evaluate , broke ranks by encouraging women to talk to their doctors and make up their own minds.

Yet the debate continues. While few dispute the facts about mammograms, they often disagree on how women should act on results, says Otis Brawley, chief medical officer at the .

For women in their 40s, mammograms reduce the risk of dying from breast cancer by about 15 percent, he says. But mammograms miss some cancers and raise false alarms about others, causing women to go through unnecessary follow-up tests, he says. ''We're saying, 'Mammography is a terribly imperfect test, but we're recommending women get it,''' Brawley says. ''The task force was saying, 'Mammography is a terribly imperfect test, and women have to make a decision about whether to get it in their 40s.' "

Barbara Monsees of the American College of Radiology still believes all women 40 and older need mammograms. That's because 75 percent of women with breast cancer have no known risk factors, she says.

But mammograms offer very different benefits, depending on a woman's age, says surgeon Susan Love, author of "Dr. Susan Love's Breast Book." In young women, breast cancers often grow too fast for mammograms to catch, appearing in between annual screenings, Love says.

Most women sharply overestimate both their risk of breast cancer and the benefits of mammograms, says Lisa Schwartz, a physician and researcher at the VA Outcomes Research Center in White River Junction, Vt. In a population of 10,000 women who are 40 years old, about 35 will die of within 10 years. Getting a mammogram helps trim those odds, but only a little, saving five lives per 10,000. ''It's not like we want to deprive young women of their God-given right to be radiated,'' Love says. ''It just doesn't work that well for them.''

Schwartz says mammograms' benefits must be balanced against their risks. In a group of 10,000 women screened with mammograms, up to 2,000 will undergo an unnecessary biopsy, and up to 50 will get unnecessary treatment because a mammogram detects a slow-growing tumor of a type that would never prove life-threatening, she says. ''The cancers that screening is really best at finding are the 'good' ones that are never going to kill you anyway,'' Love says.

An estimated 1 percent to 10 percent of breast cancers are likely non-life-threatening, according to an analysis by oncologist Ellen Warner published in September in the New England Journal of Medicine.

Because doctors can't tell which breast tumors are destined to be life-threatening, they advise removing all of them, Love says. Yet therapies such as surgery, radiation, chemo and long-term hormone pills can mean serious, long-term side effects, says Warner.

Many women feel pressure to get ; it's seen as the ''responsible'' thing to do, Schwartz says. ''Women don't want to (skip screening, then) feel like, 'Now I have this terrible cancer and it's all my fault.' ''

Explore further: New national poll: 89 percent of women said mammograms vital to their health

Related Stories

New national poll: 89 percent of women said mammograms vital to their health

September 27, 2011
According to a recent poll of 1,000 American voters conducted for the American College of Radiology, nearly 9-in-10 women reported that having a regular mammogram gave them a feeling of control over their own health care. ...

Doctors, women should spend more time discussing mammograms

August 9, 2011
Due to changing guidelines concerning when and how often they should first be screened for breast cancer with mammograms, many women are confused. The American Cancer Society recommends women 40 years and older get a mammogram ...

ACR, SBI support updated ACOG recommendations that women begin annual mammograms at age 40

July 20, 2011
The American College of Radiology (ACR) and Society of Breast Imaging applaud and support updated American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists' (ACOG) recommendations that women begin getting annual mammograms at age ...

Recommended for you

T-cells engineered to outsmart tumors induce clinical responses in relapsed Hodgkin lymphoma

January 16, 2018
WASHINGTON-(Jan. 16, 2018)-Tumors have come up with ingenious strategies that enable them to evade detection and destruction by the immune system. So, a research team that includes Children's National Health System clinician-researchers ...

Researchers identify new treatment target for melanoma

January 16, 2018
Researchers in the Perelman School of Medicine at the University of Pennsylvania have identified a new therapeutic target for the treatment of melanoma. For decades, research has associated female sex and a history of previous ...

More evidence of link between severe gum disease and cancer risk

January 16, 2018
Data collected during a long-term health study provides additional evidence for a link between increased risk of cancer in individuals with advanced gum disease, according to a new collaborative study led by epidemiologists ...

Researchers develop a remote-controlled cancer immunotherapy system

January 15, 2018
A team of researchers has developed an ultrasound-based system that can non-invasively and remotely control genetic processes in live immune T cells so that they recognize and kill cancer cells.

Dietary fat, changes in fat metabolism may promote prostate cancer metastasis

January 15, 2018
Prostate tumors tend to be what scientists call "indolent" - so slow-growing and self-contained that many affected men die with prostate cancer, not of it. But for the percentage of men whose prostate tumors metastasize, ...

Pancreatic tumors may require a one-two-three punch

January 15, 2018
One of the many difficult things about pancreatic cancer is that tumors are resistant to most treatments because of their unique density and cell composition. However, in a new Wilmot Cancer Institute study, scientists discovered ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Oct 16, 2011
This article is a red herring. There is NO question that mammography should be given up, ESPECIALLY so for women under 50. Want women to get tested? Use thermography or develop better tests. Why on earth is mammography still around, considering it gives rise to so many false positive tests and also misses some cases of cancer. I am guessing this has something to do with profits for the cancer industry...

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.