Coffee, other stimulant drugs may cause high achievers to slack off: research

March 28, 2012
coffee

(Medical Xpress) -- While stimulants may improve unengaged workers’ performance, a new University of British Columbia study suggests that for others, caffeine and amphetamines can have the opposite effect, causing workers with higher motivation levels to slack off.

The study – published online today by Nature’s – explored the impacts of on “slacker” rats and “worker” rats, and sheds important light on why stimulants might affect people differently, a question that has long been unclear. It also suggests that patients being treated with stimulants for a range of illnesses may benefit from more personalized treatment programs.

“Every day, millions of people use stimulants to wake up, stay alert and increase their productivity – from truckers driving all night to students cramming for exams,” says Jay Hosking, a PhD candidate in UBC’s Dept. of Psychology, who led the study. “These findings suggest that some stimulants may actually have an opposite effect for people who naturally favour the difficult tasks of life that come with greater rewards.”

Hosking says some individuals are more willing to concentrate and exert effort to achieve their goals than others. However, little is known about the brain mechanisms determining how much cognitive effort one will expend in decision-making for accomplishing tasks.

Hosking and study co-author Catharine Winstanley, a professor in UBC’s Dept. of Psychology, found that rats – like humans – show varying levels of willingness to expend high or low degrees of mental effort to obtain food rewards. When presented with stimulants, the “slacker” rats that typically avoided challenges worked significantly harder when given amphetamines, while “worker” rats that typically embraced challenges were less motivated by caffeine or amphetamine.

While more research is needed to understand the brain mechanisms at work, the study suggests that the amount of mental attention people devote to achieving their goals may play a role in determining how stimulants drugs affect them, Hosking says.

Winstanley, a Michael Smith Foundation for Health Research scholar, says people with psychiatric illnesses, brain injuries and Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) may benefit from treatment programs with greater personalization, noting that patients often use stimulants to counter drowsiness and fatigue from their conditions and treatments, with mixed results.

“This study suggests there may be important benefits to taking greater account of baseline cognitive differences among individuals when considering treatment programs,” says Winstanley, who is a member of the Brain Research Centre at UBC and Vancouver Coastal Health.

Explore further: Study shows medication improves performance in college students with ADHD

More information: DOI: 10.1038/ NPP.2012.30

Related Stories

Study shows medication improves performance in college students with ADHD

December 1, 2011
College students with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) who take a prostimulant medication can improve attention and organization and planning skills, according to results of the first study to look at the medical ...

Drug use tied to fatal car crashes

June 23, 2011
It's well known that drunk driving can have fatal consequences, but a new study suggests that alcohol is not the only drug that’s a danger on the road.

Patients' brains may adapt to ADHD medication

February 2, 2012
(Medical Xpress) -- New research reveals how the brain appears to adapt to compensate for the effects of long-term ADHD medication, suggesting why ADHD medication is more effective short-term than it is long-term. The study, ...

Does caffeine enhance exercise performance? The debate continues

December 14, 2011
Caffeine is regarded by some as being a potent stimulant, but the debate continues as to whether it enhances exercise performance. A range of expert opinions capture the scope of this ongoing debate in an informative roundtable ...

Chronic consumption of antipsychotic drugs incites further drug use

April 6, 2011
(PhysOrg.com) -- Almost half of all schizophrenics consume narcotics, nicotine or alcohol. The reason for this addiction could be the very treatments these patients are undergoing, according to a new preclinical study published ...

Increased risk of Parkinson's disease in methamphetamine users, study finds

July 26, 2011
People who abused methamphetamine or other amphetamine-like stimulants were more likely to develop Parkinson's disease than those who did not, in a new study from the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH).

Recommended for you

Study suggests serotonin may worsen tinnitus

August 22, 2017
Millions of people suffer from the constant sensation of ringing or buzzing in the ears known as tinnitus, creating constant irritation for some and severe anxiety for others. Research by scientists at OHSU shows why a common ...

Activating brain region creates intense desire to use cocaine

August 22, 2017
Researchers have identified a portion of the brain that intensifies one's desire for certain rewards—in this case, mimicking addiction to cocaine.

Brain region mediates pleasure of eating

August 22, 2017
Providing the body with food is essential for survival. But even when full, we can still take pleasure in eating. Researchers at the Max Planck Institute of Neurobiology in Martinsried and the Friedrich Miescher Institute ...

Chronic stress induces fatal organ dysfunctions via a new neural circuit

August 22, 2017
Hokkaido University researchers revealed that fatal gut failure in a multiple sclerosis (MS) mouse model under chronic stress is caused by a newly discovered nerve pathway. The findings could provide a new therapeutic strategy ...

Contact in sports may lead to differences in the brains of young, healthy athletes

August 22, 2017
People who play contact sports show changes to their brain structure and function, with sports that have greater risk of body contact showing greater effects on the brain, a new study has found.

Afternoon slump in reward response

August 21, 2017
Activation of a reward-processing brain region peaks in the morning and evening and dips at 2 p.m., finds a study of healthy young men published in The Journal of Neuroscience. This finding may parallel the drop in alertness ...

5 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

dogbert
not rated yet Mar 28, 2012
How surprising or useful is this study?

Poor performing rats who lack the energy to efficiently seek food receive energy from stimulants.

Efficient food seekers lose appetite from the stimulants.

This is the expected result.
Mike_Massen
1 / 5 (2) Mar 29, 2012
dogbert proclaimed:-
How surprising or useful is this study?
The surprising thing for me was "causing workers with higher motivation levels to slack off."

This was not expected from my personal experience or (initially) from the observations made of co-workers when circumstances required we stay up for 28 - 36 hrs repeatedly over a ~6 day period and then repeated 5 or so times a year in our design endeavours. However, upon reflection, it does tally with some odd behaviours all of us stumbled across.

As the article is published in Neuropsychopharmacology, it may prompt others in the field to consider variants to caffeine or complementary (hopefully natural) substances that may reduce the tendency to slack off, if at least, if we really can at the time our conscience allows.

Its possible publishing details of the study may lead to methods to moderate these consequences and improve understanding either directly or tangentially to various stimulant interactions.
Rakkasan
not rated yet Mar 29, 2012
This study is about rats. I personally know many high achievers (humans) who drink a lot of coffee.
gmurphy
not rated yet Mar 29, 2012
"worker rats that typically embraced challenges were less motivated by caffeine or amphetamine", does this mean that the *increase* in motivation was less or that the *absolute* measure of motivation was less?
dogbert
not rated yet Mar 29, 2012
gmurphy,
"worker rats that typically embraced challenges were less motivated by caffeine or amphetamine", does this mean that the *increase* in motivation was less or that the *absolute* measure of motivation was less?


Neither need be the answer. The rats' motivation was food seeking. Since amphetamine depresses hunger, administering it need not have changed the rats' motivation at all, just their hunger level.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.