Experts challenge FDA over approval for new dose of Alzheimer's drug

March 22, 2012

Approval for a new dose of a best-selling Alzheimer's drug "breached the FDA's own regulatory standard" and has led to "incomplete and distorted messages" about the drug, warn experts in the British Medical Journal today.

In the first of a new occasional series, "not so", highlighting the exaggerations, , and selective reporting that mark some news stories, advertising, and medical journal articles, Lisa M. Schwartx and Steven Woloshin challenge the claims made for the new 23 mg dose of donepezil.

Professors Lisa Schwartz and Steven Woloshin of the Center for Medicine and the Media at The Dartmouth Institute for and Clinical Practice argue that the new dose was approved "only over the objections of the FDA's medical and statistical reviewers" and that it offers "no meaningful added benefit, just more harm."

Donepezil was a for Alzheimer's disease, with over $2bn in annual sales in the United States alone. Just before its patent expired, the (FDA) approved a new 23 mg dose for moderate to severe Alzheimer's disease, thereby extending its patent for three more years. Previously, the drug was only available in 5 mg and 10 mg doses.

The FDA and the manufacturer agreed that the 23 mg dose would be approved only if it was shown to be superior to the 10 mg dose on both a and a global functioning measure.

Although the drug improved , it did not improve overall functioning, which suggests that the cognitive difference was not meaningful. Furthermore, the new dose caused more side effects, including nausea and vomiting.

Yet Schwartz and Woloshin point to "a stunningly erroneous statement" in an advertisement aimed at doctors which claims that patients on the 23 mg dose "experienced important on both measures [cognition and overall functioning]."

"Nowhere – not in the direct to consumer or the physician advertisements, nor even in the FDA approved label – are the great uncertainties about this drug acknowledged, uncertainties that led the FDA's own medical and statistical reviewers to recommend against approval of the 23 mg dose," they argue.

Despite this, the drug was approved over the objections of the FDA's medical and statistical reviewers and government and private insurance programmes now cover the drug. It is now, or will soon be under consideration for approval in 16 countries in Asia and South America.

Alzheimer's is an awful disease, say the authors. "Sadly, the available drugs don't work well. But that is no excuse for manipulating vulnerable patients, desperate family members, and their doctors to use a product that is most likely to cause net harm."

They conclude: "To make good decisions about drugs, doctors and patients need the evidence. The FDA should not forget to give it to them."

New material recently obtained by the authors from the FDA acknowledge that they made an error in relation to the previous label, stating: "The offending phrase was in the original label, and we don't recall how it slipped by, but we contacted the company as soon as it was brought to our attention, and they readily agreed to remove it. We are always inter­ested in improving the content and clarity of our labeling, and appreciate being informed of any misleading or inaccurate statements that anyone may notice."

Explore further: FDA announces new limits on high-dose simvastatin (Zocor)

Related Stories

FDA announces new limits on high-dose simvastatin (Zocor)

June 9, 2011
The United States Food and Drug Administration (FDA) today announced new limitations to the use of high-dose simvastatin, due to the increased risk of muscle pain and weakness (myopathy) and in rare cases, kidney damage and ...

US approves drug for middle-of-the-night insomniacs

November 23, 2011
The US Food and Drug Administration, for the first time, approved Wednesday medication specifically designed for those who wake up in the middle of the night and cannot fall back to sleep.

Recommended for you

Lifestyle changes to stave off Alzheimer's? Hints, no proof

July 20, 2017
There are no proven ways to stave off Alzheimer's, but a new report raises the prospect that avoiding nine key risks starting in childhood just might delay or even prevent about a third of dementia cases around the world.

Blood test identifies key Alzheimer's marker

July 19, 2017
A new study led by researchers at Washington University School of Medicine in St. Louis suggests that measures of amyloid beta in the blood have the potential to help identify people with altered levels of amyloid in their ...

Steering an enzyme's 'scissors' shows potential for stopping Alzheimer's disease

July 19, 2017
The old real estate adage about "location, location, location" might also apply to the biochemical genesis of Alzheimer's disease, according to new research from the University of British Columbia.

Brain scans may change care for some people with memory loss

July 19, 2017
Does it really take an expensive brain scan to diagnose Alzheimer's? Not everybody needs one but new research suggests that for a surprising number of patients whose memory problems are hard to pin down, PET scans may lead ...

Can poor sleep boost odds for Alzheimer's?

July 18, 2017
(HealthDay)— Breathing problems during sleep may signal an increased risk for Alzheimer's disease, a trio of studies suggests.

Hearing is believing: Speech may be a clue to mental decline

July 17, 2017
Your speech may, um, help reveal if you're uh ... developing thinking problems. More pauses, filler words and other verbal changes might be an early sign of mental decline, which can lead to Alzheimer's disease, a study suggests.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.