No evidence to support removing impacted wisdom teeth

June 15, 2012 By Christen Brownlee, Health Behavior News Service

Little evidence exists to support removing impacted wisdom teeth that are not causing pain and swelling, aren’t negatively affecting other teeth, and are disease-free, finds a new review in The Cochrane Library.

According to the review authors, led by Theodorus (Dirk) G. Mettes of the Radboud University Nijmegen Medical Center in the Netherlands, wisdom teeth—third molars that typically make an appearance when individuals are between age 17 and 24—often fail to break the gum line, or do so only partially. These so-called impacted wisdom teeth have the potential to cause a host of problems, including swelling or ulceration of the gums around these teeth, cysts or tumors, and damage, decay, or disease in the second molars. However, many people can go their entire lives without these teeth causing any problems.

Though the general consensus among most dentists and oral surgeons is that troublesome impacted wisdom teeth should be removed, Mettes says, there’s a range of opinions on what to do with asymptomatic ones. Some dental care professionals advise patients to have these teeth removed as a matter of course to prevent future problems.

Though such prophylactic removal can avoid problems caused by these teeth, extraction surgery isn’t without risks. At the very least, patients who elect for surgery will have some pain and swelling that requires time off of work, school, and other pursuits and will incur the cost of the procedure. More serious risks include permanent nerve damage, a broken jaw or infections in the bone and surrounding tissues.

As a result, Mettes explains, some care providers prefer a “wait and see” approach, removing impacted wisdom teeth only when problems arise. This approach can have its own disadvantages, such as allowing problems to advance if patients or their dentists aren’t vigilant, or requiring time off and expense for monitoring visits.

To help develop a consensus, Mettes and his colleagues combed medical databases for studies that compared those who had asymptomatic wisdom teeth removed to those who retained them. Their extensive search turned up only a single study. Even this research, meant to determine whether removing these teeth in adolescents prevents future crowding of front teeth, was inconclusive.

Though care providers’ and patients’ decisions on whether to remove asymptomatic impacted wisdom teeth “should be based on the best available evidence and combined with extensive clinical experience,” little evidence exists for or against this procedure at the moment, Mettes says.

Thomas Dodson, D.M.D., M.P.H., an oral and maxillofacial surgeon at Massachusetts General Hospital and a member of the American Association of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgeons (AAOMS), emphasizes that the decision to remove is clear-cut if there’s disease or dysfunction in impacted . However, he says, it can be a tough call for people in whom these teeth are asymptomatic and disease-free.

“Those tend to be the longer conversations,” he says. “I rely on patients to tell me what they prefer to do.”

He notes that the study designs necessary to help care providers and their patients make better decisions—randomizing large groups of patients into two groups, one which has these teeth removed and one which has teeth retained—are costly and time-consuming.

“In systematic review after systematic review, each says that more research is necessary,” Dodson says. “But so far, no one has had the interest to fund the necessary research.”

Explore further: From one generation to the next, dental care changes

More information: Mettes TDIRKG, et al. Surgical removal versus retention for the management of asymptomatic impacted wisdom teeth. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews 2012, Issue 6. Art. No.: CD003879. DOI: 10.1002/14651858.CD003879.pub3

Related Stories

From one generation to the next, dental care changes

May 18, 2012
(HealthDay) -- Stephanie Crowe, a mother of three from Croton-on-Hudson, N.Y., still remembers dreading a visit to the dentist as a young girl. It was often a painful experience, and her family's dentist showed little empathy ...

Stem cells grow fully functional new teeth

July 13, 2011
(Medical Xpress) -- Researchers from Japan recently published a paper in PLoS One describing their successful growth and transplantation of new teeth created from the stem cells of mice.

Tiny tots in the dentist's chair among changes in pediatric dentistry

May 18, 2012
(HealthDay) -- If you've been to the dentist with your children recently, you may have noticed that things have changed since you were a kid.

Tooth loss three times higher in people with serious mental illness

September 1, 2011
People with severe mental illnesses are over three times more likely to lose their teeth because of poor oral health than the general population, University of Queensland researchers have found.

Leading dentists question widespread use of porcelain crowns and veneers

July 5, 2011
Some dental patients are having unnecessary, expensive and aggressive restorative treatment for minor cosmetic problems because porcelain crowns and veneers are being overused, warns a leading dentist in July’s edition ...

Recommended for you

Painless dental lasers can render teeth cavity-resistant

November 21, 2017
Almost as soon as lasers were invented in the 1960s, curious dentists wondered if these powerful forms of light could be used on teeth, though those early lasers were much too crude for any useful dental work.

Nanodiamonds show promise for aiding recovery from root canal

October 23, 2017
People who undergo root canals may soon have a tiny but powerful ally that could prevent infection after treatment.

Research shows aspirin could repair tooth decay

September 8, 2017
Researchers at Queen's University Belfast have discovered that aspirin could reverse the effects of tooth decay resulting in a reduction in the need for fillings. Currently about 7 million fillings are provided by the NHS ...

New dental imaging method uses squid ink to fish for gum disease

September 7, 2017
Squid ink might be a great ingredient to make black pasta, but it could also one day make getting checked for gum disease at the dentist less tedious and even painless. By combining squid ink with light and ultrasound, a ...

A new dental restoration composite proves more durable than the conventional material

August 21, 2017
Fewer trips to the dentist may be in your future, and you have mussels to thank.

Small molecule inhibitor prevents or impedes tooth cavities in a preclinical model

August 10, 2017
University of Alabama at Birmingham researchers have created a small molecule that prevents or impedes tooth cavities in a preclinical model. The inhibitor blocks the function of a key virulence enzyme in an oral bacterium, ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.