'Sex-testing' regulations flawed and should be withdrawn: experts

July 9, 2012
'Sex-testing' regulations flawed and should be withdrawn

Researchers at King’s College London say ‘sex-testing’ policies introduced for athletes in time for the London Olympic Games this summer are significantly flawed and should be withdrawn. They say singling out hyperandrogenism in women from all other biological anomalies could discriminate against women who may not meet traditional notions of femininity and distort the scientific evidence on the relationship between testosterone, sex and athletic performance.

In a paper published today in the American Journal of Bioethics, experts say new regulations introduced by the International Association of Athletics Federation (IAAF) and the International Olympics Committee (IOC), stipulating that high levels of endogenous (naturally occurring) in women (hyperandrogenism) create an unfair advantage, are based on disputable scientific assumptions and are ‘unfair’.

Hyperandrogenism is a condition in which women produce androgens in excess of the range typical for females. Although both males and females have androgens, women typically have about one tenth the level of males. The IAAF and IOC policies around sex-testing have been re-introduced following the case of elite athlete Caster Semenya, whose sex was challenged in 2009 after her spectacular win and powerful physique, leading to questions around the legitimacy of her competing as a female.

However, Dr. Camporesi from the Centre for the Humanities and Health at King’s and co-author of the report, says that hyperandrogenism in women should be viewed no differently from other biological advantages that are frequently found in groups of and that, in fact, higher levels of testosterone do not automatically confer athletic advantage.

The paper draws on other examples of biological advantages in athletes derived from atypical conditions, such as runners and cyclists with rare mitochondrial variations that give them extraordinary aerobic capacity and exceptional resistance against fatigue; basketball players who have acromegaly, a hormonal condition that results in exceptionally large hands and feet, and the speculation that Michael Phelps, the record-breaking Olympic swimmer, has Marfan’s Syndrome - a rare genetic mutation that results in unusually long limbs and flexible joints.

The new policies rest on the notion that the difference in athletic performance between males and females is predominantly due to ‘higher levels of androgenic hormones in males resulting in increased strength and muscle development’. One of the biggest gaps in the current data is that nearly all research has been conducted in men.  Dr. Camporesi said: ‘Surprising as it may be, the link between athleticism and androgens in general, or testosterone in particular, has not been proven’.  

The report authors say that there is no persuasive evidence that successful athletes have higher testosterone levels than less successful ones. Levels of endogenous testosterone vary in women by day, time of the month, time of life and are also affected by interactions with the environment, for example winning or losing a competition can stimulate a rise or drop in testosterone.

Dr. Camporesi added: ‘Even if it were proved - and it is not, as we show in the report - that there is an athletic advantage derived from higher levels of endogenous testosterone, it would not be an unfair one. Elite athletes already display many types of biological and genetic advantages, why single out testosterone? Hyperandrogenism is a naturally occurring phenomenon and therefore no different to any other exceptional biological variation in the human body’.

Furthermore, the authors say, there is insufficient data to set a benchmark for normal testosterone levels in elite athletes and that isolating testosterone levels alone as a marker of eligibility to compete is problematic. Dr Camporesi said: ‘There is no one indicator in the body to specify that a person is male or female. In particular, despite a general framework around the levels of testosterone in men and women, there are no hard and fast numerical guidelines. The new policies introduced by the IAAF and the IOC try to get around the complexity of what determines athletic excellence by singling out testosterone levels as the most important aspect of athletic advantage. But athletic advantage is the product of a complex entanglement of biological and material factors and cannot be reduced to .’

The researchers warn that the new policies are particularly worrisome as they could lead to female athletes being coerced into unnecessary and potentially harmful medical treatment in order to continue competing.

Dr. Camporesi said: ‘Unlike doping, women with hyperandrogenism have not introduced any foreign matter into their bodies. Yet, under the new policies, if a woman with hyperandrogenism wants to compete, she must undergo ‘treatment’. In doing so the new policies deprive female athletes with hyperandrogenism of competing as elite athletes in their own right and the opportunity to test their capabilities and limits on the track-field, which is the very essence of sport and competition. Not only do the new policies fail to achieve the fairness they claim to be constructed on, but they end up achieving quite the opposite, and this is why they should be withdrawn.’

Explore further: Proposed testosterone testing of some female olympians challenged by scientists

Related Stories

Proposed testosterone testing of some female olympians challenged by scientists

June 13, 2012
Proposed Olympic policies for testing the testosterone levels of select female athletes could discriminate against women who may not meet traditional notions of femininity and distort the scientific evidence on the relationship ...

Older men with higher testosterone levels lose less muscle mass as they age

October 27, 2011
A recent study accepted for publication in The Endocrine Society's Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism (JCEM) found that higher levels of testosterone were associated with reduced loss of lean muscle mass in older ...

Recommended for you

Drug therapy from lethal bacteria could reduce kidney transplant rejection

August 3, 2017
An experimental treatment derived from a potentially deadly microorganism may provide lifesaving help for kidney transplant patients, according to an international study led by investigators at Cedars-Sinai.

Exploring the potential of human echolocation

June 25, 2017
People who are visually impaired will often use a cane to feel out their surroundings. With training and practice, people can learn to use the pitch, loudness and timbre of echoes from the cane or other sounds to navigate ...

Team eradicates hepatitis C in 10 patients following lifesaving transplants from infected donors

April 30, 2017
Ten patients at Penn Medicine have been cured of the Hepatitis C virus (HCV) following lifesaving kidney transplants from deceased donors who were infected with the disease. The findings point to new strategies for increasing ...

'bench to bedside to bench': Scientists call for closer basic-clinical collaborations

March 24, 2017
In the era of genome sequencing, it's time to update the old "bench-to-bedside" shorthand for how basic research discoveries inform clinical practice, researchers from The Jackson Laboratory (JAX), National Human Genome Research ...

The ethics of tracking athletes' biometric data

January 18, 2017
(Medical Xpress)—Whether it is a FitBit or a heart rate monitor, biometric technologies have become household devices. Professional sports leagues use some of the most technologically advanced biodata tracking systems to ...

Financial ties between researchers and drug industry linked to positive trial results

January 18, 2017
Financial ties between researchers and companies that make the drugs they are studying are independently associated with positive trial results, suggesting bias in the evidence base, concludes a study published by The BMJ ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.