Fringe therapy may help heart patients, study finds

March 29, 2013 by Amina Khan

A treatment that removes heavy metals from the body has long been touted as an alternative therapy to combat hardening arteries. Now a 10-year, $31 million clinical trial has found that chelation therapy does help heart attack patients slightly reduce their risk of serious heart problems - but not enough for the researchers to encourage mainstream cardiologists to offer it to their patients.

The trial revealed a very modest benefit for patients who took rather than a placebo, according to results published Wednesday in the Journal of the American Medical Association.

The findings came in for harsh criticism by other experts who worried that the results might encourage patients to take up a still unproven and potentially dangerous treatment.

"It's a type of medical quackery that has been around for many decades," said Dr. Steven Nissen, chair of at the Cleveland Clinic in Ohio.

Chelation therapy was introduced around as an antidote against an arsenic-based poison gas called Lewisite. The drug tested in the JAMA study - called ethylenediamine-tetraacetic acid, or EDTA - was used to treat lead poisoning in Navy personnel who repainted ships' hulls.

About 50 years ago, it came into vogue as an apparent way to remove mineral-rich deposits of plaque that can cause arteries to harden in a condition known as atherosclerosis.

Though still on the fringe, chelation therapy has been gaining traction: A National Center for Health Statistics report estimated that 111,000 patients had the expensive, time-consuming therapy in 2007 - a 68 percent jump from 2002. Patients clearly needed more information about this unproven treatment, said Dr. Judith Hochman, a cardiologist at New York University who was not involved in the study.

"There was an imperative to study it," Hochman said.

The National Center for and the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute - two branches of the National Institutes of Health - agreed to fund it. Researchers from 134 facilities agreed to administer a cocktail comprising disodium EDTA, vitamins and electrolytes or a placebo to 1,708 patients who were at least 50 years old and had suffered a at least six weeks earlier. The 40 infusions were spread out over more than a year.

The researchers found that chelation did reduce patients' overall risk of heart problems, such as stroke and angina requiring hospitalization. Chelation patients' heart attack rate was 6 percent, compared with 8 percent for those on the placebo.

The strongest effect was seen with procedures to reopen the coronary artery: 15 percent of chelation patients needed them, compared with 18 percent of patients who got the placebo treatment. The difference was small, but it was just enough to be statistically significant, said Dr. Gervasio Lamas, the Columbia University cardiologist who led the study.

"I can't overemphasize how unexpected these results were," he said.

But the clinical trial was beset by a host of problems, said Nissen, who wrote an editorial in JAMA that was deeply critical of the study. Many of the patients dropped out of the trial, thus weakening the results, he said. What's more, some of the patients were treated in alternative medicine centers that sold unproven remedies such as aromatherapy and crystal therapy.

"How do you get good research done at places like that?" Nissen said. "I think you don't."

In addition, the Office for Human Research Protections in the Department of Health and Human Services launched an investigation, mentioning - among several other concerns - that a few researchers had been involved in insurance fraud and three were convicted felons.

Lamas said all researchers were thoroughly trained for their duties, whether they were doctors experienced in clinical trials or practitioners with expertise in chelation treatments. He also said some were bound to drop out of a study that was so time-consuming. (Each infusion lasted several hours.)

JAMA Editor in Chief Howard Bauchner said the study was put through the wringer before it was published, with the results vetted by a team of cardiologists, statisticians and other researchers. It deserved to be published regardless of negative attitudes toward the paper, he said.

But the findings are far from definitive, Hochman said: "The therapy's not ready for prime time."

Dr. Harlan Krumholz, a Yale University cardiologist who was not involved in the study, said that any apparent benefits to chelation would be hard for physicians to swallow.

"A lot of people thought this would be a good study because it would be a chance to disprove a therapy that had little support among mainstream academics," Krumholz explained. "It's a terrific group of investigators who've addressed an interesting question, who've come up with a surprising result that nobody knows what to do with."

Explore further: Study: Mega vitamins won't help after heart attack, chelation treatment might

Related Stories

Study: Mega vitamins won't help after heart attack, chelation treatment might

March 11, 2013
(HealthDay)—There's mixed news from a much-anticipated clinical trial for people who've suffered a heart attack: While a study found that daily high doses of vitamins and minerals did nothing to improve patient outcomes, ...

Chelation therapy doesn't alter quality of life in heart attack patients

November 5, 2012
Chelation therapy didn't change the ability to perform daily tasks or impact the emotional wellbeing of patients who previously suffered a heart attack, according to late-breaking clinical trial research presented at the ...

Alternative therapy produces intriguing results in some heart patients but many questions remain

November 5, 2012
Heart attack  patients given weekly infusions of chemicals used for chelation therapy had fewer cardiovascular events than those who received identical appearing placebo infusions, according to late-breaking clinical trial ...

High-dose oral vitamins, minerals do not reduce recurrent cardiac events in heart attack patients

March 12, 2013
Heart attack patients given a combination of high-dose oral vitamins and minerals do not exhibit a significant reduction in recurrent cardiac events, according to research presented today at the American College of Cardiology's ...

Chelation therapy may result in small reduction of risk of CV events

March 26, 2013
Although chelation therapy with the drug disodium EDTA has been used for many years with limited evidence of efficacy for the treatment of coronary disease, a randomized trial that included patients with a prior heart attack ...

Recommended for you

A nanoparticle inhalant for treating heart disease

January 18, 2018
A team of researchers from Italy and Germany has developed a nanoparticle inhalant for treating people suffering from heart disease. In their paper published in the journal Science Translational Medicine, the group describes ...

Starting periods before age of 12 linked to heightened risk of heart disease and stroke

January 15, 2018
Starting periods early—before the age of 12—is linked to a heightened risk of heart disease and stroke in later life, suggests an analysis of data from the UK Biobank study, published online in the journal Heart.

'Decorated' stem cells could offer targeted heart repair

January 10, 2018
Although cardiac stem cell therapy is a promising treatment for heart attack patients, directing the cells to the site of an injury - and getting them to stay there - remains challenging. In a new pilot study using an animal ...

Two simple tests could help to pinpoint cause of stroke

January 10, 2018
Detecting the cause of the deadliest form of stroke could be improved by a simple blood test added alongside a routine brain scan, research suggests.

Exercise is good for the heart, high blood pressure is bad—researchers find out why

January 10, 2018
When the heart is put under stress during exercise, it is considered healthy. Yet stress due to high blood pressure is bad for the heart. Why? And is this always the case? Researchers of the German Centre for Cardiovascular ...

Heart-muscle patches made with human cells improve heart attack recovery

January 10, 2018
Large, human cardiac-muscle patches created in the lab have been tested, for the first time, on large animals in a heart attack model. This clinically relevant approach showed that the patches significantly improved recovery ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.