Fate of new genes cannot be predicted

September 13, 2013
Fate of new genes cannot be predicted
These are the two lines of the roundworm C. elegans used in this research. Credit: Ivo Chelo, IGC.

New versions of genes, called alleles, can appear by mutation in populations. Even when these new alleles turn the individuals carrying them more fit to survive and reproduce, the most likely outcome is that they will get lost from the populations. The theory that explains these probabilities has been postulated by the scientist J.B.S. Haldane almost 90 years ago. This theory has become the cornerstone of modern population genetics, with studies on adaptation to novel environments and conservation of species, for example, being based on it. However, until now there were no explicit experimental tests of this theory.

The research team led by Henrique Teotónio, at the Instituto Gulbenkian de Ciência (IGC, Portugal), in collaboration with Isabel Gordo, also from the IGC, has now experimentally tested Haldane's theory. By performing competition tests in roundworms, they have confirmed this theory for the introduction of a new beneficial allele in a population. However, the researchers found that this theory cannot predict the ultimate fate of the allele. This study, published in the latest issue of the scientific journal Nature Communications, contributes to a better comprehension of how a population can evolve, with implications for studies on how species adapt to changing environments or species conservation.

Haldane's theory could be experimentally tested because the researchers set up the ideal conditions with the Caenorhabditis elegans (C. elegans). These tiny organisms primarily reproduce by self-fertilization, which assures that is maintained. Also, these organisms reproduce in a short timeframe, making possible the study of several generations. Taking advantage of C. elegans' characteristics, Ivo Chelo and Judit Nédli used two lines of C. elegans to establish competition assays and see which individuals could survive and reproduce better.

Chelo and colleagues started by verifying Haldane's theory at the stage of introducing a new allele in the population. They introduced 2 or 5 individuals from one line in a population of 1000 individuals from another line, and tested how those individuals invaded the population. They found out that when the invaders were more fit the introduction in the population of more individuals would lower their probability of extinction. They also confirmed that the probability of extinction is higher for deleterious alleles than for beneficial alleles. Nonetheless, less fit individuals could be kept in the population for a few generations at high frequencies, the more so if population sizes were small. The validity of Haldane's theory had been proved for the initial phases of invasion.

Then, the research team addressed the probability of fixation of a beneficial allele in the population, i.e., to have all individuals of the population carrying the new allele. They repeated the competition experiments between the two same lines of C. elegans, but this time used an initial higher number of invading individuals, to mimic a population in which the beneficial allele was already established. The researchers observed that the adaptive value of each allele, i.e., whether it behaves as beneficial or deleterious, depended on its frequency in the population. If its frequency was higher than 5% (when more than five different individuals in a population of 100 individuals), the allele was perceived as deleterious and it started to be eliminated by natural selection. But when the frequency was less than 5%, the allele was beneficial. The result of these complex dynamics is that genetic diversity could be maintained indefinitely, without one allele or the other ever being fixed in the population.

Ivo Chelo explains: "Our data suggests that the value a new allele brings to the individuals is not fixed. Populations are dynamic and complex with plenty of interactions between individuals and between these and the environment. Initial stages when the new alleles appear cannot tell us what the effects of the alleles will be a few generations later, when the population has already changed."

Henrique Teotónio adds: "To our knowledge, this is the first time anyone was able to directly test Haldane's theory. We have proved it correct for the initial stages, when a new allele appears in a population. But our results show that further empirical work and more theoretical models are required to accurately predict the fate of that allele over long time spans".

Explore further: Gene variants linked to obesity

More information: Nature Communications 4:2417 DOI: 10.1038/ncommsS3417

Related Stories

Gene variants linked to obesity

August 9, 2013
(HealthDay)—Variants of a gene are associated with overweight and obesity in psychiatric patients taking drugs that induce weight gain, as well in the general population, according to a study published online Aug. 7 in ...

Genetic risk score linked to increased risk of diabetes

July 30, 2013
(HealthDay)—A genetic risk score based on 46 gene variants linked to type 2 diabetes is associated with increases in the risk of type 2 diabetes and declines in glucose control and beta-cell function, according to a study ...

Active lifestyle associated with less Alzheimer disease-related brain change among persons with APOE epsilon4 genotype

January 16, 2012
A sedentary lifestyle is associated with greater cerebral amyloid deposition, which is characteristic of Alzheimer’s disease (AD), among cognitively normal individuals with the ε4 allele of the apolipoprotein E ...

Gene variants link to insulin resistance based on diet

April 28, 2013
(HealthDay)—Variants of insulin receptor substrate 1 (IRS1) are associated with insulin resistance and metabolic syndrome, but only under particular dietary conditions, according to a study published online April 17 in ...

Recommended for you

Scientists provide insight into genetic basis of neuropsychiatric disorders

July 21, 2017
A study by scientists at the Children's Medical Center Research Institute at UT Southwestern (CRI) is providing insight into the genetic basis of neuropsychiatric disorders. In this research, the first mouse model of a mutation ...

Scientists identify new way cells turn off genes

July 19, 2017
Cells have more than one trick up their sleeve for controlling certain genes that regulate fetal growth and development.

South Asian genomes could be boon for disease research, scientists say

July 18, 2017
The Indian subcontinent's massive population is nearing 1.5 billion according to recent accounts. But that population is far from monolithic; it's made up of nearly 5,000 well-defined sub-groups, making the region one of ...

Mutant yeast reveals details of the aberrant genomic machinery of children's high-grade gliomas

July 18, 2017
St. Jude Children's Research Hospital biologists have used engineered yeast cells to discover how a mutation that is frequently found in pediatric brain tumor high-grade glioma triggers a cascade of genomic malfunctions.

Late-breaking mutations may play an important role in autism

July 17, 2017
A study of nearly 6,000 families, combining three genetic sequencing technologies, finds that mutations that occur after conception play an important role in autism. A team led by investigators at Boston Children's Hospital ...

Newly discovered gene variants link innate immunity and Alzheimer's disease

July 17, 2017
Three new gene variants, found in a genome wide association study of Alzheimer's disease (AD), point to the brain's immune cells in the onset of the disorder. These genes encode three proteins that are found in microglia, ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1.8 / 5 (4) Sep 13, 2013
Synopsis: Mutation-driven alleles do nothing; they are lost from populations. There is no model for mutation-driven evolution.
From the journal article: "...natural selection might not be of invariable magnitude and sign." Interpretation: We're looking for a needle in a haystack.
For comparison we have my model of nutrient-dependent pheromone-controlled adaptive evolution. Nutrient uptake epigenetically alters intercellular signaling, intranuclear interactions, and stochastic gene expression via alternative splicings. The alternative splicings (and new alleles) are controlled by the metabolism of nutrients to species-specific pheromones, which control reproduction. Nutrient-dependent reproduction fixes the beneficial alleles via the epigenetic effects of pheromones.
From the abstract: "...the nature of adaptation can be complex." Indeed, it requires epigenetic effects from the bottom-up and top-down. http://www.socioa...53/27989

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.