New approach to prostate cancer screening needed, expert says

March 7, 2014 by Alison Barbuti

(Medical Xpress)—The UK needs to invest in testing for those men most at risk of prostate cancer rather than follow a cast-the-net-wide approach targeting the whole population, a leading scientist from The University of Manchester has argued at an international conference this week.

Men in the UK are currently entitled to PSA blood test for prostate cancer once they reach the age of 50 and will be recommended to have a prostate biopsy if their PSA level is greater than their age-specific threshold. This practice leaves around 50,000 men in the UK having an unnecessary prostate biopsy every year which is painful, can cause bleeding and infection and rarely even death.

Professor Ken Muir, from The University of Manchester, is proposing the UK moves to a risk-based approach in the community – a move backed by Tackle Prostate Cancer – formerly the Prostate Cancer Support Federation.

The new approach is a computer generated risk assessment, which will be based on an extension of the Canadian Sunnybrook Risk Calculator (SRC) which utilises a combination of indicators including PSA, PSA free to total (both simple blood based tests), urine symptoms, age, family history, ethnicity and physical examination (DRE: Digital Rectal Exam). Men will only be put forward for if their is calculated to be greater than that of the normal male population. The calculator will also find more high-grade cancers, the ones that kill 10,000 men per annum, earlier so that they are treatable.

Manchester researchers surveyed more than 1,000 men and over 100 GPs about whether they would be happy with a risk-based approach to screening. The findings show over 80% of men expressed strong support and 77% of GPs were supportive.

The researchers now aim to further identify and include more risk markers and personalise the approach by also using predisposing genetic markers.

Professor Muir said that these markers would potentially replace the digital rectal examination, which in a primary care environment has proved a weak point and a social obstacle in some communities. This would make the calculator more efficient.

Individual personalised risk-calculators have been used in routine practice in many other countries across Europe, Canada and the USA, for some time but their use in the NHS Primary Care has not been investigated.

Professor Muir said: "There is a growing acceptance of using a combination of markers of risk to reduce the over-referral of patients for invasive further assessment and that this assessment should be made in Primary Care."

The European Randomised Screening for Prostate Cancer (ERSPC) trial highlighted limitations of using a PSA threshold in a trial on over 182,000 men across Europe and organisers estimate a risk-based approach to screening would save between a quarter and a third of unnecessary biopsies to detect the same number of cancers.

The Manchester team now hopes to run a trial with General Practices allocated to assess men at risk aged 50-75 but also aged 40-75 who are Afro-Caribbean or who have first degree relatives with prostate or breast cancer using two different approaches. The trial would allocate some of the participants through the risk calculator and the others would just have a PSA test. The results would be compared to ascertain the effectiveness of the risk profiling.

David Smith, Secretary of Tackle and the Patient Expert on the trial said: "Tackle, whose members have invested significant sums in the trial, are confident that the trial team under Professor Muir will produce a that is non-inferior. The detection of cancers of definite clinical significance will be increased while significantly reducing the number of needing to undergo biopsy."

Explore further: New early detection test for prostate cancer: Mi-Prostate Score test improves on PSA for predicting cancer

Related Stories

New early detection test for prostate cancer: Mi-Prostate Score test improves on PSA for predicting cancer

September 26, 2013
More than 1 million men will undergo a prostate biopsy this year, but only about one-fifth of those biopsies will result in a cancer diagnosis.

Alternative PSA screening strategies could reduce harm

February 5, 2013
(HealthDay)—Compared with standard screening, alternative prostate-specific antigen (PSA) screening strategies could maintain good prostate cancer detection rates while reducing overdiagnoses and unnecessary biopsies, according ...

Digital rectal exam remains important part of prostate screening

March 18, 2013
(Medical Xpress)—The digital rectal exam is an important screening test that can discover prostate cancer that a prostate-specific antigen or PSA test may not, despite the higher sensitivity of the PSA test, according to ...

Organized screening for prostate cancer does more harm than good

September 30, 2013
Prostate cancer screening using the prostate-specific antigen (PSA) test is widely used in France despite a lack of evidence showing that it reduces cancer deaths. Now, researchers have shown that men experience more harm ...

Personalised prostate cancer screening may save thousands from unnecessary treatment

November 5, 2012
Targeting prostate cancer screening based on a man's age and genes could potentially save thousands of men from unnecessary treatment and save the NHS millions of pounds. The research is presented at the NCRI Cancer Conference ...

Recommended for you

Study uncovers potential 'silver bullet' for preventing and treating colon cancer

July 26, 2017
In preclinical experiments, researchers at VCU Massey Cancer Center have uncovered a new way in which colon cancer develops, as well as a potential "silver bullet" for preventing and treating it. The findings may extend to ...

Compound shows promise in treating melanoma

July 26, 2017
While past attempts to treat melanoma failed to meet expectations, an international team of researchers are hopeful that a compound they tested on both mice and on human cells in a petri dish takes a positive step toward ...

Understanding cell segregation mechanisms that help prevent cancer spread

July 26, 2017
Scientists have uncovered how cells are kept in the right place as the body develops, which may shed light on what causes invasive cancer cells to migrate.

Study may explain failure of retinoic acid trials against breast cancer

July 25, 2017
Estrogen-positive breast cancers are often treated with anti-estrogen therapies. But about half of these cancers contain a subpopulation of cells marked by the protein cytokeratin 5 (CK5), which resists treatment—and breast ...

Breaking the genetic resistance of lung cancer and melanoma

July 25, 2017
Researchers from Monash University and the Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center (MSKCC, New York) have discovered why some cancers – particularly lung cancer and melanoma – are able to quickly develop deadly resistance ...

Physical activity could combat fatigue, cognitive decline in cancer survivors

July 25, 2017
A new study indicates that cancer patients and survivors have a ready weapon against fatigue and "chemo brain": a brisk walk.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.