Genetic testing may help select women with ER+ breast cancer for extended hormone therapy

March 19, 2014

Genetic analyses of results from 1125 postmenopausal women being treated for oestrogen responsive breast cancer have shown that some of them are more likely than others to have a late recurrence of their cancer and might benefit from ten years of hormone therapy rather than five.

Prof Mitch Dowsett told the opening press conference at the European Breast Cancer Conference (EBCC-9) that his research had shown that women who had tumours that were negative for the human epidermal growth factor protein (HER2-) but which were very sensitive to the oestrogen hormone, had more than double the risk of their cancer recurring between five and ten years after surgery and five years of adjuvant hormone therapy.

"Our data suggest that these patients, who are those that appear to benefit most from the current standard five years of endocrine treatment, may also benefit from adjuvant hormone treatment that extends beyond that five years," said Prof Dowsett, who is Professor of Biochemical Endocrinology at The Institute of Cancer Research, London, UK, and Head of Biochemistry at The Royal Marsden NHS Foundation Trust, London. The work is a collaboration between his team and that of Professor Jack Cuzick at the Wolfson Institute of Preventive Medicine, Queen Mary University of London, UK.

The findings are the latest to come from the ATAC trial (Arimidex, Tamoxifen Alone or in Combination), a double-blinded phase III clinical trial that randomly assigned with early, oestrogen receptor positive (ER+) breast cancer to receive the hormone therapies anastrozole or tamoxifen, or a combination of the two.

Prof Dowsett and his colleagues at The Royal Marsden, The Institute of Cancer Research and Queen Mary University of London used data from the OncotypeDx® 21-gene Recurrence Score that are not usually available from this test in order to analyse the genetic make-up and to predict the likelihood of cancer recurring within ten years in these women.

"The OncotypeDx result is reported as a single score but it is made up of 16 informative genes and five control or "housekeeper" genes that we have studied in detail. Some of the 16 are considered as groups rather than individual genes, and one of these is the E-module, which consists of four genes that are related to oestrogen signalling, including the oestrogen receptor itself," he explained.

OncotypeDX has been used for over 350,000 tests and the ATAC team had previously shown that its prediction of recurrence was poorer in the second five years after a patient's diagnosis than in the first five years. The researchers wanted to find out the reason for this, and to do so they determined the relationship between the expression of the individual genes and gene modules and early (up to five years) and late (between five and ten years) recurrence rates in women with ER+ HER2- breast cancer.

They assessed the gene expression and recurrence rates in 1125 women in the ATAC trial, who had an average of ten years of follow-up. Nearly 90% of the women were HER2- and there were 215 recurrences during the ten years.

They found that recurrence rates were highest in the first five years for women with HER2+ breast cancer, compared with the subsequent five years, but for women with HER2- cancer, the recurrence rates were higher between five and ten years.

"When we looked at the women with HER2- breast cancer and defined them according to their E-module score, which indicated how sensitive to oestrogen their tumours were, we found that there was a striking difference," said Prof Dowsett. "Among women with tumours most sensitive to oestrogen, with a high E-module score, the recurrence rate more than doubled from 5.7% in the first five years to 13.6% in the subsequent five years. However, if they had a low E-module score, there was little difference in recurrence rates between the first five years and the next five years: 10.3% versus 12.3%."

The researchers say that their results show that, despite similar overall recurrence rates for patients with ER+ tumours between the first five years and the next five to ten years, there were important differences between groups of tumours with different genetic expression profiles.

"Importantly, HER2- tumours that are very sensitive to oestrogen are usually considered to be relatively low risk, yet these were the tumours that showed an increase in recurrence after five years, which coincided with the cessation of adjuvant hormonal therapy," said Prof Dowsett. "It is commonly thought that the reduction in recurrence achieved by five years of endocrine therapy 'carries-over' into the next five years. Our results suggest this effect may differ markedly between different groups of ER+ tumours. We need to do more detailed analyses on large numbers of tumours to find out if this is the case."

He said the results also suggested a way in which methods of predicting recurrence using genetic signatures may be improved. "Better predictors of recurrence than the OncotypeDX and others currently being used should be possible based on the different recurrence rates of different groups of tumours and their different sensitivity to endocrine therapy." He and his colleagues are already working to see if they achieve this.

"We are already testing over 900 tumours from the ATAC trial to see if we can identify the oestrogen-sensitive tumours better than by the genes in the Oncotype test. This will allow us to see whether, using the knowledge from this work, we can indeed create better predictors of recurrence both for the first five years and subsequent years after diagnosis," he said.

The findings could change clinical practice: women with HER2-, high oestrogen signalling breast cancer might be considered for adjuvant hormone therapy that is extended to ten years. However, the results need to be confirmed in other sets of tumours first. "This should be done by testing the tumours of patients that are participating in ongoing trials of extended versus no extended adjuvant therapy," said Prof Dowsett.

Prof Cuzick added: "It has long been known that women with ER+ cancers have a higher late recurrence rate than those with ER-negative tumours. This work makes clear that even within ER+ cancers the level of expression is important. Further work is needed to see if genetic expression profiles are better at doing this than more conventional quantitative immunohistochemistry. We are about to start a trial called IBIS-3 of extended therapy with aromatase inhibitors in long-term survivors with ER+ breast cancer with other unfavourable characteristics, and also adding new drugs used in other conditions that show promise in preventing breast cancer recurrence – a bisphosphonate (bone sparing drug) and metformin (diabetes drug). Hopefully, this biomarker work will help to pinpoint more accurately which patients need additional treatment."

Professor Giuseppe Viale, chair of EBCC-9 and Head of the Department of Pathology at the University of Milan, commented: ""Late recurrence for patients with hormone receptor-positive after five years of endocrine treatment unfortunately is a sizeable risk, with devastating effects on the quality of life of affected patients. Clinical trials have already documented the possible benefit of extending endocrine therapy beyond five years in unselected populations of post-menopausal patients, but we do not have the means to identify the subgroup of patients actually benefitting from this extended treatment. These latest findings from the ATAC trial may pave the way for a better tailoring of hormone therapy beyond the first five years. Certainly, confirmatory studies are needed, and it remains to be assessed whether the same prognostic parameters may also hold for pre-menopausal patients."

Explore further: Genetic and clinical factors best to predict late recurrence in estrogen receptor POS breast cancer

More information: O-216, "Oestrogen module of 21-gene recurrence score predict increased late recurrence for ER+HERT2- breast cancer". Thursday 20 March at 15.30-17.00 hrs. "Relapse After Systemic Treatment – Can We Predict it?" session, Clyde Auditorium.

Related Stories

Genetic and clinical factors best to predict late recurrence in estrogen receptor POS breast cancer

May 2, 2013
A new analysis has provided a comprehensive comparison of scores designed to predict which women with oestrogen-receptor positive breast cancer are at high risk of recurrence beyond five years after diagnosis, and may benefit ...

Breast cancer recurrence defined by hormone receptor status

October 1, 2012
Human epidermal growth factor (HER2) positive breast cancers are often treated with the same therapy regardless of hormone receptor status. New research published in BioMed Central's open access journal Breast Cancer Research ...

Avoiding radiotherapy is an option for some older patients with breast cancer

December 11, 2013
Omission of radiotherapy is a reasonable option for women age 65 or older who receive hormone therapy after breast-conserving surgery for hormone receptor-positive, axillary node-negative breast cancer, according to results ...

Gene-expression-based biomarker predicts long-term risk of breast cancer recurrence

September 11, 2013
A comparison of three methods of predicting the risk of recurrence in women treated for estrogen-receptor (ER)-positive breast cancer finds that only the breast cancer index (BCI) – a biomarker based on the expression levels ...

Combined therapy linked to lower chance of recurrence in women with small, HER2+ breast cancers

December 11, 2013
In a new study, women with relatively small, HER2-positive breast tumors who received a combination of lower-intensity chemotherapy and a targeted therapy following surgery or radiation therapy were very unlikely to have ...

Study confirms long term benefits of tamoxifen are relevant to all women who take it for five years

October 1, 2013
Taking tamoxifen for an extra five years benefits women with breast cancer that has not spread to the lymph glands (node negative disease), as well as women where lymph node spread was found at operation, updated research ...

Recommended for you

Zebrafish larvae could be used as 'avatars' to optimize personalized treatment of cancer

August 21, 2017
Portuguese scientists have for the first time shown that the larvae of a tiny fish could one day become the preferred model for predicting, in advance, the response of human malignant tumors to the various therapeutic drugs ...

Searching for the 'signature' causes of BRCAness in breast cancer

August 21, 2017
Breast cancer cells with defects in the DNA damage repair-genes BRCA1 and BRCA2 have a mutational signature (a pattern of base swaps—e.g., Ts for Gs, Cs for As—throughout a genome) known in cancer genomics as "Signature ...

Scientists discover vitamin C regulates stem cell function, curbs leukemia development

August 21, 2017
Not much is known about stem cell metabolism, but a new study from the Children's Medical Center Research Institute at UT Southwestern (CRI) has found that stem cells take up unusually high levels of vitamin C, which then ...

How a non-coding RNA encourages cancer growth and metastasis

August 21, 2017
A mechanism that pushes a certain gene to produce a non-coding form of RNA instead of its protein-coding alternative can promote the growth of cancer, report researchers at the Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC) ...

Spaser can detect, kill circulating tumor cells to prevent cancer metastases, study finds

August 21, 2017
A nanolaser known as the spaser can serve as a super-bright, water-soluble, biocompatible probe capable of finding metastasized cancer cells in the blood stream and then killing these cells, according to a new research study.

Comprehensive genomic analysis offers insights into causes of Wilms tumor development

August 21, 2017
A comprehensive genomic analysis of Wilms tumor - the most common kidney cancer in children - found genetic mutations involving a large number of genes that fall into two major categories. These categories involve cellular ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.