Bioethicists use theatrical narratives to bridge the gap between society and science

April 23, 2014, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine

A pair of bioethics experts have added "playwright" to their resumes in an effort to aid the genomics community in grappling with an onslaught of ethical issues as genomic science transitions to bedside healthcare, a decade after the human genome was first sequenced.

Until now the plays of Karen H. Rothenberg and Lynn W. Bush have been performed for, and by, their peers and others in the genomics community at global conferences, meetings and in classrooms. With Oxford University Press' publication of the book The Drama of DNA: Narrative Genomics, excerpts from the plays, along with analysis and discussion of the ethical and cultural issues surrounding genomic science and medicine, are available to a wider audience. A companion website to the book provides links to Bush and Rothenberg's plays in their entirety.

"Drama and the fictionalization of societal issues have always aided us in grappling with the issues of the day, and the discord that can arise where a new technology and culture first meet," says Rothenberg, a faculty member at the Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics and the Marjorie Cook Professor of Law at the University of Maryland Francis King Carey School of Law. Rothenberg also currently serves as Senior Advisor to the Director on Genomics and Society, National Human Genome Research Institute, National Institutes of Health (NHGRI/NIH).

In the first chapter, titled "Why Genomics, Why Narratives, Why Now?" Rothenberg and Bush write, "Many challenges surround the promise of genomic technology and the power of genomic information, as they alter conceptions of identity and dynamics within personal, familial, and professional relationships. Controversial issues abound—such as determining whether, what, to whom, when, and how genomic information should be disclosed to individuals and their families—and whose voices matter in making these determinations."

Eric D. Green, Director of NHGRI and an experienced "actor" in Rothenberg and Bush's plays, writes in the book's foreword, "Effectively examining the implications of genomic advances requires interdisciplinary collaborations. Toward that end, narrative genomics developed by Karen Rothenberg and Lynn Bush offers a novel path to enhance the understanding and dialogue among clinical geneticists, genetic counselors, bench scientists, primary care physicians, bioethicists, policy makers, other researchers and healthcare professionals, patients, and patient advocates."

Professor Nancy E. Kass has also had the opportunity to take on an acting role in Rothenberg and Bush's plays, and agrees with Green on the value of the dramatic approach to educating on . "Professionals always appreciate a more creative way to communicate ideas than being 'talked at'. These plays and scripts allow fun and interactive discussion of tough ideas in ways that appeal to patients and professionals alike," says Kass, the Phoebe R. Berman Professor of Bioethics and Public Health at the Berman Institute.

Rothenberg first began writing with Bush, a faculty member in Pediatric Clinical Genetics and faculty associate at the Center for Bioethics at Columbia University Medical Center, after the two attended an interdisciplinary seminar on narrative medicine at Columbia. Both wanted to enhance dialogue and understanding about the complex societal challenges raised by generating and sharing vast amounts of genomic information.

In addition to original plays, Rothenberg and Bush have collaborated on historical research on plays exploring bioethics issues; in 2012 the scholars published an article in the Houston Journal of Health Law & Policy surveying 46 plays spanning three centuries—including Frankenstein and Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?—all highlighting the ethical and social impact of medical technology on society.

Expanding on the themes of interdisciplinary dialogue, this spring Rothenberg organized a workshop at NIH that brought playwrights and NHGRI scientists together to discuss both fictional and real-life drama in the world of science, followed by a public event at the Smithsonian National Museum of Natural History, in which playwrights shared how genomics has influenced their work.

Next, Rothenberg and Bush's work will be shared in an interactive format with the staff of the Presidential Commission for the Study of Bioethical Issues and at Harvard Medical School. Rothenberg says she looks forward to expanding the workshop format and enhancing dialogue between playwrights, scientists, bioethicists and others in the genomics community in this novel context.

Explore further: New study launched investigating the impacts of personal genomic testing

More information: The Drama of DNA: Narrative Genomics, Amazon.com: www.amazon.com/Drama-DNA-Narra … eywords=drama+of+dna

Karen H. Rothenberg www.bioethicsinstitute.org/peo … e/karen-h-rothenberg

Lynn W. Bush: www.cumc.columbia.edu/dept/bec/staff/LynnBush.html

Related Stories

New study launched investigating the impacts of personal genomic testing

March 5, 2012
As genetic risk information plays an increasingly important role in the diagnosis and treatment of many diseases, private companies have made personal genomic testing for these risk factors widely available to the public. ...

Nurses at forefront of genomics in healthcare

February 1, 2013
On April 14, 2003 a map of the human genome was completed, ushering in a new era of genetics in medicine with applications that include genetic testing; newborn screening; susceptibility to diseases such as cancer, cardiovascular ...

Bioethicists contribute to consensus opinion on the responsibility of biobanks

March 21, 2012
Bioethicists at the Johns Hopkins Berman Institute of Bioethics are co-authors on a consensus article placing "significant responsibility" on biobanks to report individual research results (IRRs) and incidental findings (IFs) ...

Mayo Clinic shares lessons learned from genomics clinic for sequencing-based cancer care and diagnostics

April 9, 2014
It has been 1.5 years since Mayo Clinic opened the world's first integrated multidisciplinary genomics service, the Individualized Medicine Clinic, which uses genomics and next-generation sequencing technologies to personalize ...

Ethical research with minorities

November 5, 2013
Remarkable improvements in the quality of life, prevention and treatment of disease have been made possible through advancements in biomedical research, including clinical trials involving human subjects. Future progress ...

Recommended for you

Scientists cut main heart disease risk locus out of DNA by genome editing

December 6, 2018
Over the past decade we've learned that billions of people carry a mysterious specter in their DNA that strongly increases their risk for life threatening cardiovascular diseases, such as heart attacks, aneurysms or strokes, ...

What can a snowflake teach us about how cancer spreads in the body?

December 6, 2018
What can seashells, lightning and the coastline of Britain teach us about new drugs for cancer?

New genetic insight could help treat rare debilitating heart and lung condition

December 6, 2018
The largest study of genetic variation in patients with pulmonary arterial hypertension has associated two important genes with the disease.

Are scientists studying the wrong kind of mice?

December 5, 2018
Mice represent well over half of the non-human subjects of biomedical research, and the vast majority of those mice are inbred. Formed by generation after generation of mating between brothers and sisters, inbred mice are ...

Researchers find evidence of prenatal environment tuning genomic imprinting

December 5, 2018
A team of researchers from the U.S., Australia and Denmark has found evidence of the prenatal environment tuning genomic imprinting. In their paper published in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, the group describes ...

Gene that lets you eat as much as you want holds promise against obesity

December 4, 2018
It sounds too good to be true, but a novel approach that might allow you to eat as much food as you want without gaining weight could be a reality in the near future.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.