Spanking may be more common than parents admit

April 30, 2014 by Barbara Bronson Gray, Healthday Reporter
Spanking may be more common than parents admit
Small study 'eavesdropped' on family interactions with preschoolers.

(HealthDay)—Ask any busy parent of preschool children: Early evening can be a stressful time. Now a small new study that audiotaped families soon after they returned home from work and day care suggests that spanking is surprisingly common.

Among 33 families, the researchers discovered 41 incidents of or hitting in 15 different families over a six-night period. What's more, the spanking didn't seem to resolve problems. After being hit, children were misbehaving again within 10 minutes in about 75 percent of the incidents.

The study was published online recently in the Journal of Family Psychology.

The research was originally designed to study the impact of yelling and to test the value of using audio recorders to do research on families, said lead study author George Holden, a professor of psychology at the Southern Methodist University in Dallas. He expanded the scope of the research after studying the tapes.

Holden found that parents who yell are more likely to spank their children. He also discovered that audiotaping is more accurate than are self-reports, when parents estimate how much yelling and spanking occur in their homes. "We did show that it's a very rich way to capture a wide assortment of information that is often ignored," he said.

"Parents are hitting their children over trivial misdeeds and some of the moms are doing it a lot more than the self-report data has ever identified," Holden said. "Recordings give us real-time information, which self-reports cannot."

Holden designed the study to focus on evening behavior because he has often heard mothers refer to early evening as the "hell hour" or the "suicide hour."

"It's a very difficult time, trying to pull dinner together and deal with the kids, and I thought it would be likely to elicit anger," Holden said. "It's stacked up against harmonious interactions."

Although a cause-and-effect relationship between spanking and behavioral problems was not shown, the study suggests that hitting children is not a good way to teach them or promote parent-child relationships, Holden said.

"It doesn't work. But more than that, it can result in like aggression, or anxiety and depression," he said.

Nationwide, 70 percent to 90 percent of parents hit or slap their children, Holden said. Yet spanking is not recommended by most experts in child psychology.

Another expert said that evidence does not support spanking.

"Based on 20 years of research on physical punishment, it is recommended that it should not be used on children of any age," said Tracie Afifi, an associate professor in the department of community health sciences at the University of Manitoba, in Winnipeg, Canada.

In a study published in Pediatrics in 2012, Afifi found that spanking or slapping children may increase the odds they will develop into adulthood.

For the new study by Holden's team, participants were recruited using fliers distributed to English-speaking mothers of 2- to 5-year-old children at day care and Head Start centers in Dallas. Only 35 mothers who reported in a screening phone interview that they yelled in anger at least twice a week were included in the study.

Among parents, 79 percent of mothers worked, either full time (61 percent) or part time (18 percent), while 91 percent of fathers worked full time outside the home.

The mothers were given a digital voice recorder to wear on their upper arm. They were told to turn on the recorder when they returned home from work or at 5 p.m. and to turn it off when their child fell asleep. The recordings were taken for four to six consecutive days.

The rate of corporal punishment, such as spanking and slapping, exceeded estimates found in other studies that relied on parents reporting their behavior. While other studies discovered that American parents of 2-year-olds typically reported they spanked or slapped their child 18 times a year, Holden's research based on the audiotapes discovered such behavior occurred 18 times a week.

The study also showed that some of the children were punished for doing extremely minor things, such as turning pages in a book or sucking on their fingers.

Afifi noted that the study had limitations. Recruiting mothers with fliers means the participants were not representative of the general population (because they were self-selected), the number of families participating was small and the time frame of observation averaged only 13 hours per family.

What can parents do to discipline their children effectively? Afifi recommended that parents take a "time out" when they feel their anger escalating, and try to notice if their response to their child's misbehavior is making the situation worse. She also suggested that consider the child's age and developmental stage when making decisions about discipline and parenting.

Holden agreed. "There is no magic bullet, except for time, letting kids' prefrontal cortex [the judgment and decision-making area of the brain] develop. Children don't have the self-regulation ability adults have," he said. "They cannot control themselves. They cannot keep it together when they are fatigued."

Explore further: Real-time audio of corporal punishment shows kids misbehave within 10 minutes of spanking

More information: Visit the American Academy of Pediatrics for more on disciplining kids.

Related Stories

Real-time audio of corporal punishment shows kids misbehave within 10 minutes of spanking

April 15, 2014
A new study based on real-time audio recordings of parents practicing corporal punishment discovered that spanking was far more common than parents admit, that children were hit for trivial misdeeds and that children then ...

Use of spanking exacerbates aggressive child behavior

December 10, 2013
A mother's affection after she spanks her child does little to diminish the negative impact of the act, a new University of Michigan study finds.

Parents less likely to spank after reading briefly about its links to problems in children

January 22, 2014
(Medical Xpress)—Parents who spank their children believe it's an effective form of discipline. But decades of research studies have found that spanking is linked to short- and long-term child behavior problems.

Spanking babies is surprisingly common

March 11, 2014
The same hands that parents use to lovingly feed, clothe and bathe their babies are also commonly used to spank their bundles of joy.

Mothers' self-recorded audio gives unique real-time view of spanking in context of day-to-day life

June 22, 2011
In one recording, a mom spanks her 3-year-old 11 times for fighting with his sister. In another, a mom slaps her son for turning the page of a book while she reads to him. In still another, a mom spanks her 5-year-old when ...

Kids still spanked, to their detriment, study finds

October 21, 2013
(HealthDay)—Spanking can affect a child's behavior and learning ability for years, with the impact of physical discipline reverberating even as kids near adolescence, a new study suggests.

Recommended for you

Depression changes structure of the brain, study suggests

July 21, 2017
Changes in the brain's structure that could be the result of depression have been identified in a major scanning study.

Many kinds of happiness promote better health, study finds

July 21, 2017
A new study links the capacity to feel a variety of upbeat emotions to better health.

Study examines effects of stopping psychiatric medication

July 20, 2017
Despite numerous obstacles and severe withdrawal effects, long-term users of psychiatric drugs can stop taking them if they choose, and mental health care professionals could be more helpful to such individuals, according ...

Study finds gene variant increases risk for depression

July 20, 2017
A University of Central Florida study has found that a gene variant, thought to be carried by nearly 25 percent of the population, increases the odds of developing depression.

In making decisions, are you an ant or a grasshopper?

July 20, 2017
In one of Aesop's famous fables, we are introduced to the grasshopper and the ant, whose decisions about how to spend their time affect their lives and future. The jovial grasshopper has a blast all summer singing and playing, ...

Perceiving oneself as less physically active than peers is linked to a shorter lifespan

July 20, 2017
Would you say that you are physically more active, less active, or about equally active as other people your age?


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) May 01, 2014
As a person raised in a family which practiced spanking, I guess I can give personal insight.

Spanking produces confusion and resentment. Your parents supposedly "love" you, but when they spank it does not feel like love, and they often spank for stupid shit that has no moral basis: bad school grades in foreign language, going outside or to a neighbor's house when you were told not to do so for some trivial reason, getting suspended or in a fight at school, etc. This one truly makes no sense, as you get in a fight, not necessarily even your own fault, and the punishment for hitting another person, or even being attacked by another person, is to...get another beating by a parent or school principal.

None of that made any sense in most cases, and the only thing it did in most cases is make a person angry or resentful to the person doing the corporal punishment.

While the Bible says, "He who spares the rod hates his child," I don't believe it was referring to such unimportant mistakes.
1 / 5 (1) May 01, 2014
Essentially something I've noticed about spanking is that it is often used simply as a lazy excuse for the parent's own bad parenting/grand-parenting skills.

Something I noticed my mother do with my nephew was her fault as follows.

1, Ask him if he was thirsty, and yes, and give him drink out of her glass.

2, Later (30 minutes, an hour,) he goes to grab the glass on his own, and she gets mad and says, "leave my stuff alone, etc," and swats at his hand...

3, Like repeat this scenario on other occasions.

4, Finally I got pissed at her and said, "It's your fault, you're confusing him. You give him drink from the glass when YOU want to do so, but when he wants it on his own you then punish him. If you don't want him drinking from your glass don't give it to him in the first place, and give him his own cup."

5, She gets mad at me and says, "Who made you a parenting expert," lol.

That's how stupid people can be, and spank a child when the fault is their own. I hated it.
Uncle Ira
1 / 5 (1) May 01, 2014
As a person raised in a family which practiced spanking, I guess I can give personal insight.

You are the good proof it don't work at all sometimes.

Spanking produces confusion and resentment.

So that where you got that from. I was wondering that me.

While the Bible says, "He who spares the rod hates his child," I don't believe it was referring to such unimportant mistakes.

Ol Ira hopes that is not right me too. I sure would hate to have to give up hating and rodding you Cher.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.