Don't believe the Daily Express, it takes a lot more than carrots to beat cancer

June 24, 2014 by Victoria Forster, The Conversation
Miracle diet suggestions from the Daily Express. Credit: D_Hollingsworth/Twitter

Another story about how some food holds the cure for cancer is making headlines in the Daily Express. This time the saviour is the humble carrot. But it isn't its first time in the limelight. In March, the Daily Mail claimed that eating carrots is a way to avoid prostate cancer. But, as is the case more often than not, the scientific study published in the European Journal of Nutrition reveals that there is little data to make the claim whether the purported effect was specific to carrots more than any other vegetable.

Many studies suggest that consumption of fruit and vegetables is associated with a reduced risk of a variety of cancers. But the charity organisation Cancer Research UK stresses, "the link between diet and cancer is complex and difficult to unravel". That is an important caveat. There is little chance that the key to preventing one of the world's deadliest diseases has been on our dinner plates the whole time.

What does the lab say

The lead researcher of the new study, Dr. Kirsten Brandt at Newcastle University, has been studying naturally occurring chemicals found in certain vegetables, called polyacetylenes, for many years. They have been shown to kill leukaemia cells in the laboratory. And a compound which can be easily extracted from something as common and cheap as carrots is bound to arouse interest.

This, however, is only the first step in testing any potential new anti-cancer chemicals. In their study, Brandt and her colleagues also used a mouse model – as proxy for humans – which has a genetic mutation that increases the chances of developing intestinal cancer. Mice fed a diet, where a fifth of the food was powdered carrot, had fewer and smaller tumours than mice who were fed a normal diet.

The scientists will now look to see if this tumour-preventing effect is also seen in people by doing a small-scale study involving 20 participants. This, if successful, will have to be followed up by even larger scale trials, before carrots can be considered beneficial in cancer prevention.

Sarah Warner, a PhD student in Brandt's research group, described her project to me. "I'm going to be looking at whether a portion of carrots consumed per day can affect the risk of someone developing a chronic disease by looking at DNA damage and biomarkers related to intestinal cancer," she said.

All cancers are a result of damaged DNA. So commonly consumed foods that reduce this damage could be a significant step in preventing cancer, especially in individuals who have a genetic predisposition to the disease. But the current results do not imply that they "hold the key to beating cancer".

What is perhaps more interesting is that the preparation of the carrots influences how much polyacetylene actually gets from the food into our bodies. "I'll be investigating how best to prepare the carrots, so that when people eat it they get the most polyacetylenes," she said.

There is no miracle cure, of course

Because of the chemical composition of the polyacetylenes, she predicts that cooking them in fat may cause more to be lost into the fat than preparing the carrots in water by boiling or steaming. As with any plant, carrots are a combination of hundreds of different chemicals, including beta-carotene which has been well described to aid vision in the dark. Dissecting exactly which chemicals in plants are responsible for observed health benefits is notoriously tricky.

"We may be able to figure this out as white carrots are rich in polyacetylenes, but don't contain beta-carotene like orange carrots do," Warner said.

Sarah hopes that contrasting these two varieties of carrots may allow the research team to pinpoint the chemicals that are responsible for their early cancer-protective findings, and make sure that by looking at polyacetylenes, they are focusing their research on the right chemicals.

Will purified polyacetylene tablets be the next health food trend raved about in celebrity magazines? "Probably not, because polyacetylenes are quite toxic in high concentrations. In the small quantities found in , we think they may be beneficial. If it was to be used more like a drug, we would have to be really careful to get the dose right," Warner said.

While this piece of research is interesting and it may lead to great advances in the fight against cancer, the researchers are not making that claim just yet. But in their desperation to sensationalise headlines, newspapers such as the Daily Mail and the Daily Express end up running stories that contradict each other – sometimes the same foodstuff can apparently cause and prevent . These stories erode the public's trust in health journalism. When reporting such stories, it would be better to focus on the scientific method and the incremental development than to make bold, hollow claims.

Explore further: Natural plant compounds may assist chemotherapy

Related Stories

Natural plant compounds may assist chemotherapy

March 27, 2014
Researchers at Plant & Food Research have identified plant compounds present in carrots and parsley that may one day support more effective delivery of chemotherapy treatments.

Creative ways to get children to eat vegetables

April 29, 2014
(Medical Xpress)—Can you imagine a young child eating spinach, carrots, broccoli, cauliflower, brussels sprouts or even asparagus? Yes, it can happen. "But how?" you ask.

Colorful fruits, vegetables may be key to cancer-fighting diet

November 26, 2012
(HealthDay)—Many cancer-fighting fruits and vegetables are at their nutritional peak in the fall, and it's a good time to incorporate them into your diet, a nutritional expert advises.

Attractive names sustain increased vegetable intake in schools

September 17, 2012
The age-old parental struggle of convincing youngsters to eat their fruits and vegetables has some new allies: Power Punch Broccoli, X-Ray Vision Carrots—and a host of catchy names for entrees in school cafeterias. Cornell ...

Recommended for you

How cancer metastasis happens: Researchers reveal a key mechanism

January 18, 2018
Cancer metastasis, the migration of cells from a primary tumor to form distant tumors in the body, can be triggered by a chronic leakage of DNA within tumor cells, according to a team led by Weill Cornell Medicine and Memorial ...

Modular gene enhancer promotes leukemia and regulates effectiveness of chemotherapy

January 18, 2018
Every day, billions of new blood cells are generated in the bone marrow. The gene Myc is known to play an important role in this process, and is also known to play a role in cancer. Scientists from the German Cancer Research ...

These foods may up your odds for colon cancer

January 18, 2018
(HealthDay)—Chowing down on red meat, white bread and sugar-laden drinks might increase your long-term risk of colon cancer, a new study suggests.

The pill lowers ovarian cancer risk, even for smokers

January 18, 2018
(HealthDay)—It's known that use of the birth control pill is tied to lower odds for ovarian cancer, but new research shows the benefit extends to smokers or women who are obese.

Researchers develop swallowable test to detect pre-cancerous Barrett's esophagus

January 17, 2018
Investigators at Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine and University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center have developed a simple, swallowable test for early detection of Barrett's esophagus that offers promise ...

Scientists zoom in to watch DNA code being read

January 17, 2018
Scientists have unveiled incredible images of how the DNA code is read and interpreted—revealing new detail about one of the fundamental processes of life.


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

1 / 5 (1) Jun 24, 2014 need immense quantities marijuana, too...
not rated yet Jun 25, 2014
So you're saying "Trust in Big Pharma"?
not rated yet Jun 25, 2014
There is no miracle cure, of course

And there never will be. Because it's big business, that rakes in a lot of money from desperate people.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.