Training vs. Torture: Psychology students don't receive crucial ethics, human rights education

August 7, 2014, Harvard Medical School

U.S. graduate students in psychology receive very little instruction in military medical ethics and are largely unaware of their duties under the Geneva Conventions, despite the longstanding ties between the American Psychological Association and the military, and despite the fact that psychologists were the architects of the "enhanced interrogation" programs used at Abu Ghraib, Guantanamo and elsewhere, which many leading ethicists and legal scholars have described as torture.

These findings, from a study led by Harvard Medical School researchers at Cambridge Health Alliance and several other Boston-area institutions, are published in the International Journal of Health Services.

"Psychologists need to know about these matters to ensure they don't inadvertently become pawns of the U.S. military establishment and also to hold their colleagues who have committed crimes in the name of patriotism accountable for their actions," said J. Wesley Boyd, HMS assistant clinical professor of psychiatry at Cambridge Health Alliance. Boyd is lead author of the study.

"The abuses at Abu Ghraib and Guantanamo galvanized much of the world against the United States," Boyd said. "The fact that Guantanamo is still open and continues to flout international law—most recently by force-feeding detainees—will likely go down as one of our country's most egregious ethical lapses."

The researchers surveyed 185 students at 20 different graduate programs in clinical psychology. They found that 74 percent of students had received less than one hour of instruction about military and 97 percent had received five hours of instruction or less.

Only 37 percent of the students correctly said that the Geneva Conventions apply irrespective of whether war has formally been declared. Forty-three percent did not know that the Geneva Conventions state that physicians should "treat the sickest first, regardless of nationality," and 50 percent did not know that the Geneva Conventions prohibit ever threatening or demeaning prisoners, or depriving them of food or water for any length of time. These lapses are likely a result of the lack of education, the researchers said.

The researchers also found that 48 percent of the students could not state when they would be required to disobey an unethical order from a superior. Confusion on this matter may stem, the authors believe, from two contradictory, co-existing policy documents backed by the APA: a 2005 presidential task force report that in essence allows psychologists to use the so-called Nuremberg defense, the argument that a person was merely following orders in carrying out an unethical act (which was repealed last year), and a 2008 APA policy referendum affirming that psychologists must strictly adhere to international human rights conventions.

Only 5 percent of the students were aware that, beginning in 1987, Congress authorized the Health Care Personnel Delivery System (HCPDS), which established a specific process for drafting psychologists and other health care personnel in time of military need. If they desired, Congress and the president could activate the HCPDS and begin drafting civilian psychologists for military service in a matter of weeks.

The authors argue that given the existence of the HCPDS and the extensive involvement of psychologists in every aspect of recent U.S. military interrogations and torture, all clinical need to be knowledgeable about the Geneva Conventions and military medical ethics. They also urge further scientific study of these matters.

Explore further: Doctors complicit in torture at CIA, military prisons: study

Related Stories

Doctors complicit in torture at CIA, military prisons: study

November 4, 2013
Doctors and nurses tasked with monitoring the health of terror suspects were complicit in abuses committed at prisons run by the Pentagon and the CIA, an independent report said Monday.

Identifying patients with military service can improve health outcomes

July 11, 2014
UAB Medicine has partnered with Joining Forces, a government initiative that supports members of the military and their families by promoting various employment, education and wellness initiatives, in an effort to better ...

Study reveals medical students believe health policy education is improving

July 24, 2014
Students graduating from U.S. medical schools in 2012 feel they've received a better education in health policy issues than graduates surveyed in 2008, according to a multi-center study led by the Perelman School of Medicine ...

Greater odds of adverse childhood experiences in those with military service

July 23, 2014
Men and women who have served in the military have a higher prevalence of adverse childhood events (ACEs), suggesting that enlistment may be a way to escape adversity for some.

Signpost for health services: Teenagers go from school psychologist to family doctor

June 10, 2014
After initially visiting a school psychologist, adolescents in the United States with a mental disorder often go to seek care from their pediatricians or family doctors. Fewer of them continue their treatment directly with ...

Recommended for you

Modulating molecules: Study shows oxytocin helps the brain to modulate social signals

January 17, 2018
Between sights, sounds, smells and other senses, the brain is flooded with stimuli on a moment-to-moment basis. How can it sort through the flood of information to decide what is important and what can be relegated to the ...

Baby brains help infants figure it out before they try it out

January 17, 2018
Babies often amaze their parents when they seemingly learn new skills overnight—how to walk, for example. But their brains were probably prepping for those tasks long before their first steps occurred, according to researchers.

Reducing sessions of trauma-focused psychotherapy does not affect effectiveness

January 17, 2018
Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) patients treated with as few as five sessions of trauma-focused psychotherapy find it equally effective as receiving 12 sessions.

How past intentions influence generosity toward the future

January 17, 2018
Over time, it really is the thought that counts – provided we know what that thought was, suggests new research from Duke University's Fuqua School of Business.

Tracking the impact of early abuse and neglect

January 17, 2018
Children who experience abuse and neglect early in life are more likely to have problems in social relationships and underachieve academically as adults.

Study: No evidence to support link between violent video games and behaviour

January 16, 2018
Researchers at the University of York have found no evidence to support the theory that video games make players more violent.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.