BMJ investigation examines bitter dispute over e-cigarettes in the public health community

June 24, 2015

An investigation published by The BMJ today reveals how the controversial concept of "harm reduction", embraced enthusiastically by the tobacco industry, has sharply divided the public health community.

On one side of the increasingly bitter dispute are those who believe it is time to work with the industry in support of products such as e-cigarettes.

Those in the other camp, however, not only contest the claimed benefits of the new products but also fear harm reduction is a cynical and superficial smokescreen for an industry that has every intention of maintaining global sales of smoked for as long as possible.

As cigarettes continue to kill six million people each year, journalist Jonathan Gornall asks who is right?

Simon Capewell, professor of public health and policy at Liverpool University's Institute of Psychology, Health and Society, and others argue that e-cigarettes help to glamorise and renormalise smoking. Worse, he says, they are being used by the industry "as a trojan horse to get inside ministries of health. They are saying 'This is all about harm minimisation, we're part of the solution, we're no longer the problem.'"

However, Deborah Arnott, chief executive of the UK charity Action on Smoking and Health (ASH), dismisses such fears, saying there is no evidence so far that e-cigarettes are a gateway into smoking for young people. "The risk is that smokers who could potentially use these an an alternative to smoking are being discouraged, and that's not a good thing," she argues.

Gornall describes how, in 2014, the tension "boiled over into a pitched battle of words" in the run up to the World Health Organization's Framework Convention on Tobacco Control.

Some 56 specialists in nicotine science and wrote to Margaret Chan, director general of WHO, urging her to support harm reduction and insisting it was "part of the solution, not part of the problem." But 129 opposing experts swiftly responded, warning WHO and other public bodies not to "buy into the tobacco industry's well-documented strategy of presenting itself as a partner."

One of the organisers of the Chan letter was Gerry Stimson, a former director at Imperial College London and a member of the group producing NICE guidance on tobacco harm reduction.

Stimson has made no secret of his relations with the tobacco industry and told The BMJ that e-cigarettes and other nicotine delivery systems had "huge potential ... to help shift people away from smoking." But "the quandary for many public health experts ... is that the solution might well lie with the much reviled tobacco industry."

Karl Fagerstrom, a Swedish clinical psychologist who has also accepted industry money, said he considered products such as e-cigarettes could have a role in reducing the harm caused by smoking and accused some in public health of losing sight of the true objective.

Another signatory to the Chan letter was John Britton, an epidemiologist who heads the UK Centre for Tobacco and Alcohol Studies, and also sat on the NICE guideline group. "I'm no apologist for or friend of the tobacco industry," he told The BMJ, but if an alternative means of delivering nicotine comes along "it's inconceivable that will not get involved and seek to exploit it, and that's a risk that has to be managed."

For Martin McKee, professor of European public health at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, there is no doubt that tobacco companies are entering the e-cigarette market "solely so they can say they are part of the solution." But there was, he said, still no evidence that e-cigarettes were effective in helping people to quit smoking.

British American Tobacco (BAT) is now poised to market Voke, the first licensed medicinal nicotine product from a tobacco company.

ASH has welcomed the decision, saying Voke "... will allow smokers to choose a product which meets the high standards of medicines regulation and could be provided on prescription to help them stop smoking."

But regardless of their true value in the battle against tobacco harm, and the ferocious row they have triggered in the public health community, are all such products anything other than a sideshow, designed to make the look good as cigarettes continue to kill half the people who use them, asks Gornall?

He notes that while BAT says it is "committed to developing and promoting a range of next generation tobacco and nicotine products," its 2014 annual report clearly states that tobacco remains "at the core of our business and will continue to provide us with opportunities for growth."

Explore further: Research shows most children do not regularly use e-cigarettes

More information: Why e-cigarettes are dividing the public health community, The BMJ, www.bmj.com/cgi/doi/10.1136/bmj.h3317

Related Stories

Research shows most children do not regularly use e-cigarettes

June 15, 2015
Children aged 11 to 16 who have never smoked do not regularly use e-cigarettes, according to new Cancer Research UK data being presented today (Friday) at the UK Nicotine and Smoking Cessation Conference  and will be published ...

Teen use of e-cigarettes, hookahs way up: survey

June 23, 2015
(HealthDay)—Although fewer American children are smoking cigarettes, the use of controversial e-cigarettes has more than doubled in just three years, a federal survey reports.

Youth just as likely to try e-cigarettes as smoking

May 4, 2015
Young people are just as likely to try electronic cigarettes as smoking, according to a new report from the Propel Centre for Population Health Impact at the University of Waterloo.

House bill aims for less e-cigarette regulation

June 19, 2015
House Republicans are pushing to ease proposed government regulations for companies that sell e-cigarettes and other new tobacco products, a move that Democrats charge could lead to unsafe products on the market.

Expert argues against smokescreen on e-cigarette research

June 5, 2015
A leading Australian substance abuse expert is pleading for moderation in policies on e-cigarettes.

Health experts defend e-cigarettes despite concerns (Update)

March 20, 2015
Health experts at an anti-tobacco conference in Abu Dhabi defended e-cigarettes on Friday, dismissing widespread concerns that the devices could lure adolescents into nicotine addiction.

Recommended for you

Hormone therapy in the menopause transition did not increase stroke risk

November 24, 2017
Postmenopausal hormone therapy is not associated with increased risk of stroke, provided that it is started early, according to a report from Karolinska Institutet published in the journal PLOS Medicine.

When traveling on public transport, you may want to cover your ears

November 22, 2017
The noise levels commuters are exposed to while using public transport or while biking, could induce hearing loss if experienced repeatedly and over long periods of time, according to a study published in the open access ...

Different types of alcohol elicit different emotional responses

November 22, 2017
Different types of alcohol elicit different emotional responses, but spirits are most frequently associated with feelings of aggression, suggests research published in the online journal BMJ Open.

Air pollution linked to poorer quality sperm

November 22, 2017
Air pollution, particularly levels of fine particulate matter (PM2.5), is associated with poorer quality sperm, suggests research published online in Occupational & Environmental Medicine.

Sunrise and sunset guide daily activities of city-dwellers

November 21, 2017
Despite artificial lightning and social conventions, the dynamics of daylight still influence the daily activities of people living in modern, urban environments, according to new research published in PLOS Computational ...

Older men need more protein to maintain muscles

November 21, 2017
The amount of protein recommended by international guidelines is not sufficient to maintain muscle size and strength in older men, according to a new study.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

sk8terboy1963
not rated yet Jun 25, 2015
I quit a 35 year 2 pack a day habit by switching to vaping. It saved my life. I was convinced that nothing could ever take the place of my cigarettes. I was dead wrong. I literally quit overnight by vaping. It has been 18 months since I had a tobacco cigarette. I don't even have a desire for it. Vaping is the greatest smoking cessation system out there. It is cost effective and can be tailored to suit anyone's needs. I started at 18 milligrams of nicotine and I'm at zero now. My monthly cost to vape is one fifth of what I was spending on tobacco. My sense of smell and taste have returned. I feel better than I have felt in years. All of the negative press and attention is bought and paid for propaganda put out by Big Tobacco. They are losing billions in revenue. Smoking is dead. Vaping IS the future. And the future is NOW.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.