Male brains 'overwhelmed' in multitasking test: study

January 25, 2017
brain
White matter fiber architecture of the brain. Credit: Human Connectome Project.

Are women really better at multi-tasking? A study Wednesday said a tricky brain-teaser throws off men's walking gait but leaves most women unfazed, reopening an age-old debate about mental gender differences.

On a treadmill, men—and over 60—started swinging their right arm less while grappling with a complicated language test, researchers found.

Language function and right arm swing are both thought to be controlled mainly by the brain's left hemisphere.

"Women under 60 seemed to be resistant to this effect, as they were able to perform the verbal task with no change in arm swing," said study co-author Tim Killeen, a neuroscientist from the University Hospital Balgrist in Switzerland.

"In men and , the verbal task appears to overwhelm the left brain to the extent that the movement of the arm on the right is reduced."

The "unexpected" findings were published in the journal Royal Society Open Science.

"We were surprised to find such a consistent gender difference in how two relatively simple behaviours—cognitive control and arm swing—interact with one another," Killeen told AFP.

The team had set out to study how people walk under different conditions, aiming to build a database of "normal" gait profiles for treating people with walking disorders.

They used infrared cameras to record the treadmill walking patterns of 83 healthy people, aged 18 to 80.

The participants were asked to walk—first normally, and then while performing a verbal task called the Stroop test.

Developed in the 1930s, the test involves printing the name of a colour—such as "red", "green" or "blue"—in a non-matching colour, then asking a person to say the colour of the ink, not the word itself.

Better at language?

This is difficult, explained Killeen, as the human brain "sees" both the written word and the colour of the ink, and must reconcile the two.

During normal walking, the left and right arms swung approximately equally.

"When we added the verbal task, we observed that in men of all ages and women over 60, this symmetry broke down, with a reduction in right arm swing while the left arm carried on swinging normally," said Killeen.

Does this prove women are better multi-taskers?

"Ha ha! I think this shows that younger women may be able to resist interference of these two fairly specific behaviours," she said.

Whether this might apply to other compound activities—such as driving and talking or walking and texting—has yet to be shown.

It is also unclear whether a woman's ability to take the verbal brain teaser in her stride confers any advantage over men, said Killeen.

The fact that women over 60 lose the capacity may provide a clue as to its origin, the researchers said.

Brain receptors of the female hormone oestrogen may get a bigger boost in , who have more of it.

"Alternatively, women are often shown to have somewhat better verbal skills than men" and may find the Stroop test easier, Killeen said by email.

"However, this does not explain why older women revert to the 'male pattern' after 60."

Previous studies have disagreed on whether women are actually better than men at doing more than one thing at the same time.

"This may be a paradigm for investigating this further—maybe someone can finally settle this age-old question!" said Killeen.

Explore further: Women with early memory problems have better verbal memory than men

More information: Increasing cognitive load attenuates right arm swing in healthy human walking, Royal Society Open Science, rsos.royalsocietypublishing.or … /10.1098/rsos.160993

Related Stories

Women with early memory problems have better verbal memory than men

October 6, 2016
A team of researchers from the US has reported that women with early memory problems called mild cognitive impairment (MCI) show better verbal memory then men despite similar changes having occurred in the brain. The findings ...

Why men find switching tasks more difficult

November 18, 2016
It has long been known to science that women find it easier than men to switch between tasks. But how exactly their brains function differently in such situations has so far been unclear. Recent research reveals that male ...

Who has the better memory—men or women?

November 9, 2016
In the battle of the sexes, women have long claimed that they can remember things better and longer than men can. A new study proves that middle-aged women outperform age-matched men on all memory measures, although memory ...

Women's cognitive decline begins earlier than previously believed

January 20, 2017
UCLA researchers have found that mental sharpness in women begins to decline as early as their 50s. The study, which followed the same group of healthy women for 10 years after menopause, found that their average decline ...

Genes and the environment equally affect language-related brain activity

December 29, 2016
Osaka University-led researchers examine brain activity in monozygotic and dizygotic Japanese twins and show that environmental and genetic influences affect language-related brain activities in left frontal area of the brain.

Memory changes may occur in women decades earlier than previously thought

September 28, 2016
Many women report forgetfulness and changes in memory as they transition to menopause. But studies that target participants who are 65 and older do not account for cognitive changes that may take place decades earlier in ...

Recommended for you

Navigation and spatial memory—new brain region identified to be involved

August 16, 2017
Navigation in mammals including humans and rodents depends on specialized neural networks that encode the animal's location and trajectory in the environment, serving essentially as a GPS, findings that led to the 2014 Nobel ...

Prematurity leaves distinctive molecular signature in infants' cerebellum

August 15, 2017
Premature birth, which affects one in 10 U.S. babies, is associated with altered metabolite profiles in the infants' cerebellum, the part of the brain that controls coordination and balance, a team led by Children's National ...

What neuroscience can tell us about the Google diversity memo

August 15, 2017
Everybody seems to have an opinion about Google's recent sacking of its malware software engineer James Damore for circulating a memo arguing that women and men are suitable for different roles because they are intrinsically ...

Which research results in mice will help humans with multiple sclerosis? Now there's a way to tell

August 15, 2017
People with multiple sclerosis (MS) know all too well the frustration of hearing that success in treating the disease in mice had little or no effect in humans.

Cooling helmet, supplement show potential as concussion healers

August 15, 2017
A brain cooling device and an oral supplement made from pine bark extract both have potential to expedite concussion recovery, according to two new studies by Penn State researchers.

Granulins are brain treasure, not trash

August 14, 2017
Emory University School of Medicine researchers have developed tools that enable them to detect small proteins called granulins for the first time inside cells. Granulins are of interest to neuroscientists because mutations ...

3 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

Kron
3 / 5 (2) Jan 25, 2017
The article says nothing about who got the brain teaser correct, or how much importance each participant placed on the teaser. If you allocate all your brain power on a certain task you have no brain power for anything else. How certain can we be that the women under 60 just didn't care that much about whether they got the colours correct?

I don't believe the experiment was set up correctly. I believe the variable (multitasking ability), was not isolated enough for the test to hold any true scientific merit.

Perhaps a follow-up study which better controls the variables is in order, possibly with the assistance of an EEG machine to map electrical activity in the brains during the experiment.

I highly doubt that there are any inherent differences in the ability to multitask across the sexes. I think these test results are due to men and women over 60 taking the brain teaser more seriously, and therefore focusing more on the questions than walking.
Kron
5 / 5 (1) Jan 25, 2017
I think a much better test would be to have them walk then surprise them by throwing a ball at them. This shocked state would much better exhibit multitasking potential. Could they react to the ball in stride? Could they process the multiple variables simultaneously (ie multitask)? Could they continue to walk and calculate the projectiles trajectory and catch or swat the ball away to protect themselves from being hit?
Vidyaguy
not rated yet Jan 25, 2017
More junk science to go with fake news. The politically-correct harpies are ever-questing for soft "research" that can satisfy their need for confirmation bias.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.