Two types of empathy elicit different health effects, psychologist shows

May 24, 2017 by Katherine Unger Baillie, University of Pennsylvania
Anneke Buffone. Credit: University of Pennsylvania

When a close friend shares bad news, our instinct is to help. But putting ourselves in a friend's shoes, imagining how we would feel if we were the one suffering, may have detrimental effects on our own health, according to a new study led by the University of Pennsylvania's Anneke E. K. Buffone. She is the lead research scientist of the World Well-Being Project in the School of Arts & Sciences' Positive Psychology Center.

The research, published in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, finds that our bodies respond differently depending on the perspective we take when helping someone who is suffering. Stepping into the perspective of the suffering person leads to a health-threatening physiological , while reflecting on how the suffering person might feel leads to a health-promoting response.

"This is the first time we have physical evidence that putting yourself in someone else's shoes is potentially harmful," said Buffone.

Buffone collaborated on the work with Michael Poulin, Shane DeLury, Lauren Ministero and Carrie Morrisson of the State University of New York at Buffalo and with Matt Scalco at Brown University.

Their study builds upon previous work that had shown that helping behaviors can, paradoxically, lead to both negative and positive health effects. Buffone and colleagues were hoping to tease apart the factors that might lead to the different outcomes.

To do so, they devised an experiment that would place participants in the role of "helper" to a person who was suffering. More than 200 college-age study subjects were hooked up to equipment that tracked a set of psychophysiological markers, such as blood pressure and heart rate as well as other cardiovascular measures that can be used to differentiate a threat response—a state of negative arousal—from a challenge response—a state of positive arousal.

Participants were provided with texts, which they were led to believe was written by their study partners. The personal story was intended to induce empathy by describing the troubled background of the alleged other student, describing struggling financially after a recent car accident while coping with the added pressure of having to care for a younger sibling after having lost the mother years prior. Study participants were asked to respond to the writers, through a videotaped message, offering helpful comments and advice.

To evoke the different types of empathy, the researchers divided participants into three groups, each of which was given slightly different instructions prior to reading the statements. The members of one group were told to read while imagining how they would feel if they had had the same experiences; the members of a second group was told to read the story while imagining how the writers would feel and the third were asked to remain objective and detached while reading the statements.

Buffone and colleagues discovered that the very act of helping induced a physiological change in all of the participants, but the quality of that change differed between the groups. The first group, imagining themselves as the suffering other student,s showed signs of the physiological fight-or-flight response, as though they themselves were responding to a threat. The members of the second group, imagining the feelings of the sufferers, showed a more invigorating arousal response, as if they were confronting a challenge that is eminently manageable.

"A classic analogy is taking an exam," said Buffone. "You either feel like you've got it or you feel like you don't. If you don't, you're going to be in that threat state; you encounter a question that throws you off, you get nervous, you get hot, you get sweaty and you can't think. If you feel like you've got this, you're calm,. Your heart may still be pounding and you may be writing fast, but you still feel confident.

"When we consider the situation with a little more distance, you're feeling concern, compassion and a desire to help, but you don't feel exactly what that other person is feeling."

The physiological threat response is associated with release of the . Chronic activation of this response could lead to a host of negative health effects, including cardiovascular problems.

The results may be particularly salient to those in care-giving positions, such as doctors and nurses, who may automatically take on the perspective of others.

"Empathy is very important, and for a lot of care givers probably is the reason they chose their field," Buffone said. "We don't have to teach our medical professionals to suppress that emotional response; we just have to try to help them have the right kind of response, thinking of others as opposed to thinking how they would feel in the same situation."

Buffone also notes that parents may want to refrain from the types of admonishments that encourage children to take on the perspective of others, for example, "How would you feel if Sally had hit you with her truck?"

Buffone and colleagues in Penn's World Well-Being Project are following up on their findings by analyzing the language people use on Facebook to identify the types of empathy they seem to be most employing, specifically looking at nurses.

"We'll actually be giving personalized feedback," Buffone said. "So, if someone seems to be using a lot of language associated with the 'bad' form of empathy, we might be able to help them make insights into how to avoid those thought patterns."

Explore further: Study shows 'walking a mile in their shoes' may be hazardous to your health

More information: Anneke E.K. Buffone et al, Don't walk in her shoes! Different forms of perspective taking affect stress physiology, Journal of Experimental Social Psychology (2017). DOI: 10.1016/j.jesp.2017.04.001

Related Stories

Study shows 'walking a mile in their shoes' may be hazardous to your health

May 11, 2017
When it comes to empathy, the idiom that suggests "walking a mile in their shoes" turns out to be problematic advice, according to new research published in the Journal of Experimental Psychology.

Exploring the connection between empathy, neurohormones and aggression

September 26, 2014
Empathy is typically seen as eliciting warmth and compassion—a generally positive state that makes people do good things to others. However, empathy may also motivate aggression on behalf of the vulnerable other. Researchers ...

Belief in God strengthened by imagining how life would be different

March 17, 2016
New research shows a person's belief in God is strengthened when thinking of "what might have been" especially in reflecting on a major life event that could have turned out poorly. Importantly, the study shows how believers ...

Researchers explore the relationship between empathy and aggression

November 5, 2014
Empathy is among humanity's defining characteristics. Understanding another person's plight can inspire gentle emotions and encourage nurturing behaviors.

Making people feel bad can be a strategy for helping them

May 24, 2017
People may try to make someone else feel negative emotions if they think experiencing those emotions will be beneficial in the long run, according to new research published in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association ...

Stress can increase empathy

April 11, 2017
Acute psychosocial stress leads to increased empathy and prosocial behavior. An international team of researchers led by Claus Lamm from the University of Vienna investigated the effects of stress on neural mechanisms and ...

Recommended for you

Internet therapy apps reduce depression symptoms, study finds

December 7, 2018
In a sweeping new study, Indiana University psychologists have found that a series of self-guided, internet-based therapy platforms effectively reduce depression.

Gender bias sways how we perceive competence in faces

December 7, 2018
Faces that are seen as competent are also perceived as more masculine, according to research published in Psychological Science, a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.

Targeted cognitive training benefits patients with severe schizophrenia

December 7, 2018
Schizophrenia is among the most difficult mental illnesses to treat, in part because it is characterized by a wide range of dysfunction, from hallucinations and mood disorders to cognitive impairment, especially verbal and ...

Pot withdrawal eased for dependent users

December 6, 2018
A new drug can help people diagnosed with cannabis use disorder reduce withdrawal symptoms and marijuana use, a new Yale-led study published Dec. 6 in the journal Lancet Psychiatry shows.

Link between neonatal vitamin D deficiency and schizophrenia confirmed

December 6, 2018
Newborns with vitamin D deficiency have an increased risk of schizophrenia later in life, a team of Australian and Danish researchers has reported.

Alterations in brain networks explain why some children are resilient to maltreatment

December 6, 2018
People who experience childhood maltreatment frequently have perturbations in their brain architecture, regardless of whether they develop psychiatric symptoms, but a study in Biological Psychiatry found additional alterations ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.