State medical licensing boards' practices may hurt physician mental health

June 14, 2017
Do US Medical Licensing Applications Treat Mental and Physical Illness Equivalently? Credit: Michigan Medicine

Sharing a history of mental health issues with an employer is difficult for anyone.

It's that much harder if reporting an old or well-controlled condition could lead to restrictions on your professional license—as some physicians well know.

A new study found state medical boards ask physicians much more extensive and intrusive questions about conditions than for physical health conditions. Despite national concern about suicide and well-being, research shows that even if physicians struggle with depression, they are reluctant to disclose and seek treatment because it could have serious consequences when they apply for their medical license.

Katherine J. Gold, M.D., M.S.W., M.S., assistant professor in the University of Michigan's Department of Family Medicine, recently led a study published in the Society of Teachers of Family Medicine that examined how state medical licensing boards across the 50 states and Washington, D.C., evaluated mental illnesses compared to physical illnesses or substance use on state licensing forms.

What she found is cause for alarm.

"The differences were really quite striking," says Gold. "States were significantly more likely to ask if physicians had been diagnosed, treated or hospitalized for mental health or substance abuse verses for disorders, often asking about many years in the past."

Many of the questions violated the Americans with Disabilities Act as well, the study finds.

"The problem is that states don't ask, 'Do you have a problem right now that affects your ability to provide good care for patients?'" Gold explains. "(Instead) they ask broad questions that intrude on physician privacy and prevent doctors from seeking care, but don't necessarily pick up on impaired physicians."

A similar number of states asked about both physical and mental health, but the content and nature of the questions varied. Physical health questions tended to be much more lenient and vague while questions about mental health and substance abuse were much more specific, and at times, even intrusive, Gold says.

Fear and female physicians

Last year Gold led a survey that asked 2,100 female physicians who were also mothers about their mental health history and treatment.

Nearly half said they believed they met the definition for a mental illness at some point in their career, but had not sought treatment. Two-thirds reported that fear of stigma, including fear of reporting to state medical boards, drove them to keep their worries quiet.

Only 6 percent who had ever been diagnosed had reported it to their state licensing board, as most felt their condition didn't affect the care they gave.

"I actually had a physician email me a month ago, and she was really worried because she had postpartum depression several years ago," says Gold. "[She] reported this to her state medical board and shared all of her treatment records but was still fearful that they would limit her license, despite the fact that there were no problems with her work and she was now doing much better. She was really terrified."

How state licensing boards respond to disclosures made by physicians about their mental health cannot be predicted and varies state by state, says Gold.

"It completely depends on the board," she says. "It could range from the board saying, 'Just send us a letter from your doctor, to send us all of your medical records from all of your treatment, to come before the board and give us your defense as to why you are fit to practice,' or even calling for ongoing monitoring and license restrictions."

Physician and patient safety

There is minimal data examining the impact of physician mental health on patient outcomes, Gold says. But conclusions can be drawn about how this issue affects doctors.

"Asking about prior problems or mental health diagnoses make it less safe for physicians because it creates an enormous pressure not to seek mental health treatment," says Gold.

"It affects physician identity. If you've trained for all these years as a physician and then you can't practice because back 10 years ago you had postpartum depression, that's really threatening. A lot of people just don't get help, and if they do get help, it's often off the books or informal help, which is not ideal."

Because of attention on the issue from the American Medical Association, there has been a sharp uptick in media focus on physician burnout and mental health, as well as the willingness of some doctors to tell their stories, and reporting on physician suicides.

A number of hospitals nationwide, including Michigan Medicine, are implementing programs to help residents and physicians individually improve their overall wellness and resilience.

Although health systems should promote healthy lifestyles for doctors, more comprehensive and system-level changes should occur as well, Gold says.

"We're not going to improve physician health until we can take away some of the barriers to seeking help," she says. "We know that reporting this level of detail to state licensing boards is a huge barrier for physicians because of self-stigma and fears about their license and not being able to practice."

As a first step to make changes, Gold suggests making sure all questions about mental on state medical licensing applications comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act. She also says questions should only ask about current conditions causing impairment. This ensures physicians aren't punished for disclosing an issue in their past that they've correctly addressed.

Gold also indicates the Federation of State Medical Boards must take action.

"I think that's where change has to come from. It has to come from the group that is advising the state medical boards," she says. "They don't have regulatory authority over the boards, but certainly they can recommend best practices for the states."

Explore further: Fear of stigma or sanction keeps many doctors from revealing mental health issues, anonymous survey finds

Related Stories

Fear of stigma or sanction keeps many doctors from revealing mental health issues, anonymous survey finds

September 22, 2016
Even as doctors across America encourage their patients to share concerns about depression, anxiety and other concerns, so they can get help from modern treatments, a new study suggests the doctors may be less likely to seek ...

Job stress and mental health problems contribute to higher rates of physician suicide

November 12, 2012
Doctors who commit suicide appear to be under-treated for mental health problems, despite their seemingly good access to health care, a new University of Michigan study shows.

Interstate medical licensure compact formed

June 4, 2015
(HealthDay)—Nine states have enacted the Interstate Medical Licensure Compact law, with the seventh state's enactment triggering formation of a commission to administer a process for physicians seeking licensure in multiple ...

Rural primary care physicians offer insight into rural women's health care

February 5, 2014
Women living in rural communities are less likely than urban-dwelling women to receive sufficient mental health care, in large part due to limited access to services and societal stigma, according to medicine and public health ...

Do programs to help doctors with substance abuse treat them fairly?

October 21, 2016
If a doctor has a substance abuse issue (or is suspected of having one) or needs mental health care, he or she is often referred to something called a Physician Health Program (PHP). In principle, these programs are intended ...

Screening for mental health issues in a pediatric ED

October 1, 2015
In a study to be published on Oct. 1 by the journal Pediatric Emergency Care, investigators at Children's Hospital Los Angeles piloted a brief mental health screening tool to be used with patients accessing the emergency ...

Recommended for you

Americans misinformed about smoking

August 22, 2017
After voluminous research studies, numerous lawsuits and millions of deaths linked to cigarettes, it might seem likely that Americans now properly understand the risks of smoking.

Women who sexually abuse children are just as harmful to their victims as male abusers

August 21, 2017
"That she might seduce a helpless child into sexplay is unthinkable, and even if she did so, what harm can be done without a penis?"

To reduce postoperative pain, consider sleep—and caffeine

August 18, 2017
Sleep is essential for good mental and physical health, and chronic insufficient sleep increases the risk for several chronic health problems.

Despite benefits, half of parents against later school start times

August 18, 2017
Leading pediatrics and sleep associations agree: Teens shouldn't start school so early.

Doctors exploring how to prescribe income security

August 18, 2017
Physicians at St. Michael's Hospital are studying how full-time income support workers hired by health-care clinics can help vulnerable patients or those living in poverty improve their finances and their health.

In a nutshell: Walnuts activate brain region involved in appetite control

August 17, 2017
Packed with nutrients linked to better health, walnuts are also thought to discourage overeating by promoting feelings of fullness. Now, in a new brain imaging study, researchers at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center (BIDMC) ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.