Health prospects of children in care look worse than for anyone else

August 31, 2017 by Alex Mcmahon And David Conway, The Conversation
Nearly one in 100 children are in care. Credit: santypan

When the state gets involved in the welfare of children or young people under 18, we call them "looked after." They might live with foster parents, in a children's home, with friends or relatives, or even with their own family under a compulsory home supervision order.

Nearly 95,000 British youngsters live in such arrangements, which is not far off one in 100. We know that their life chances are not as good as they should be. In the words of the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children: "As a result of their experiences both before and during care, looked after children are at greater risk than their peers."

The media and authorities have tended to focus on how the education system fails this group. Their health has only more recently been identified as a priority, at least by the Scottish government, though it has been considered impossible to build up a meaningful statistical picture because of the way the different relevant departments collate the data.

We have managed to do this, however. We have focused on dental data of looked after children in Scotland, but the results are likely to be the tip of a very worrying iceberg. They are likely to prompt much wider research into the general health of this group of children, both in Scotland but also across the UK and beyond.

The findings

Our new paper, just published in the Archives of Disease in Childhood journal, has found that there are stark differences between the dental health of children in care and those who are not. We compared 622,280 children in the general population with 10,924 who are looked after, which is the majority of the approximately 15,000 in Scotland. The dental treatment needs of children, particularly for urgent work or for extractions under general anaesthetic, are important because they could be considered an early marker for poor physical health later in life.

We found that children in care have twice as many urgent dental health needs as the general child population. Children in care, including those in foster and residential care, have double the rates of urgent dental treatment, and are half as likely to attend dental services as children in general. Children in care are twice as likely to have a tooth extraction under general anaesthetic.

Our key findings also included:

  • 49 percent of children in care do not attend the dentist regularly, in comparison with 38 percent of all children.
  • 67 percent of five year olds in care have dental needs compared with 36 percent of all children.
  • 23 percent of five year olds in care have urgent dental needs including severe dental decay or dental abscesses, compared with 10 percent of all children.
  • 75 percent of 11 year olds in care have dental needs compared with 58 percent of all children.
  • 7 percent of 11 year olds in care have urgent dental needs compared with 2 percent of all children.
  • 9 percent of children in care have had a tooth extraction under compared with 5 percent of all children.

These differences coudn't be explained by the standard measurable socioeconomic factors – children in care have considerably worse dental issues than other children in a similar socioeconomic group. And this is in a context where children in UK's poorest areas are ten times more likely to be looked after.

We also identified variations between different categories of looked after children. Children in foster care had the best , while those with the worst are the ones who remain in the family home with children's panel and social work support.

We don't yet know whether the poor figures for looked after children are the result of the family background that led them into care in the first place or because the state is failing to look after them once they are in the system. Neither could we get any information on pre-school children because of the nature of the data.

Next steps

We are keen to do follow-up work to better understand the barriers and facilitators into dental services, since the findings also suggest that such services are either failing these children or they are just not using them. But to do this work, and for much other work into the health prospects of looked after children to become possible, it is going to need even further joined-up work between health and social care services to compare data.

Different areas of the UK are merging and social care to various degrees. If social services and NHS services were to use a single identifier number for clients, it would make it easier to understand what is going on.

For the time being, these findings are a stark reminder to us all of the need to focus our efforts to ensure the most vulnerable are properly cared for. It looks as though we have a problem: before we can solve it, we are going to need to be able to look at the full picture.

Explore further: What outcomes are associated with early preventive dental care among Medicaid-enrolled children in Alabama

Related Stories

What outcomes are associated with early preventive dental care among Medicaid-enrolled children in Alabama

February 27, 2017
Preventive dental care provided by a dentist for children before the age of 2 enrolled in Medicaid in Alabama was associated with more frequent subsequent treatment for tooth decay, more visits and more spending on dental ...

When families lack insurance, kids' dental woes rise

April 10, 2017
(HealthDay)—American children without dental insurance are far less likely to receive necessary care for their teeth than kids with coverage, a new survey finds.

Research explores lasting effects of early preventive dental care in Medicaid-enrolled children

March 13, 2017
Research out of the University of Alabama at Birmingham School of Public Health suggests preventive dental care provided by a dentist for children before the age of 2 enrolled in Medicaid in Alabama may lead to more care ...

Children's oral health disparities persist despite equal dental care access

December 14, 2016
Oral health of children who receive dental care through Medicaid lags behind their privately insured peers, even though the children receive the same amount of dental care, according to a study from the Columbia University ...

CDC urges dental sealants for all low-income children

October 19, 2016
(HealthDay)—Treatments that seal a child's back teeth can prevent most cavities, but many children—particularly those living in poverty—don't get them, according to research published in the Oct. 18 early-release issue ...

Dental school, foster care agency partnership improves child health, aids student training

October 21, 2012
A partnership between a New York City dental school and a local foster care agency has provided consistent dental care to more than 650 children, and may serve as a model for other dental school program curriculums. The success ...

Recommended for you

Molecules in spit may be able to diagnose and predict length of concussions

November 20, 2017
Diagnosing a concussion can sometimes be a guessing game, but clues taken from small molecules in saliva may be able to help diagnose and predict the duration of concussions in children, according to Penn State College of ...

Breastfed babies are less likely to have eczema as teenagers, study shows

November 13, 2017
Babies whose mothers had received support to breastfeed exclusively for a sustained period from birth have a 54% lower risk of eczema at the age of 16, a new study led by researchers from King's College London, Harvard University, ...

Obesity during pregnancy may lead directly to fetal overgrowth, study suggests

November 13, 2017
Obesity during pregnancy—independent of its health consequences such as diabetes—may account for the higher risk of giving birth to an atypically large infant, according to researchers at the National Institutes of Health. ...

Working to reduce brain injury in newborns

November 10, 2017
Research-clinicians at Children's National Health System led the first study to identify a promising treatment to reduce or prevent brain injury in newborns who have suffered hypoxia-ischemia, a serious complication in which ...

Why do some kids die under dental anesthesia?

November 9, 2017
Anesthesiologists call for more research into child deaths caused by dental anesthesia in an article published online by the journal Pediatrics.

Probability calculations—even babies can master it

November 3, 2017
One important feature of the brain is its ability to make generalisations based on sparse data. By learning regularities in our environment it can manage to guide our actions. As adults, we have therefore a vague understanding ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.