Legal challenge could scuttle prescription drug initiative

October 11, 2017 by James Nord

A court challenge to the attorney general's explanation of a ballot measure that would cap the price state agencies could pay for prescription drugs could scuttle the initiative even if backers gather enough support to put it on the 2018 ballot, a key proponent said this week.

Industry groups have appealed to the South Dakota Supreme Court after a state judge rejected their challenge to Attorney General Marty Jackley's explanation. It's a move to derail a measure that would save taxpayer dollars and pressure drug companies to lower prices, supporter Rick Weiland told The Associated Press.

"These are tactics by the pharmaceutical industry in this country that doesn't want to see any effort anywhere, you know, that would affect their bottom line," Weiland said. "It's really, at the end of the day, all about money—big money."

Backers aim to gather thousands of signatures on petitions featuring Jackley's explanation ahead of next month's deadline to get on the 2018 ballot. But the appeal from South Dakota Biotech and Washington-based Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America, or PhRMA, is likely to stretch past the signature submission deadline.

Attorney General spokeswoman Sara Rabern said in an email that if Jackley's explanation is found to be inadequate, it's likely that the petition sheets carrying the inadequate explanation would not be valid.

"What's the recourse?" Weiland said, noting it would be too late to gather new signatures.

Jackley said after a judge last month denied the trade groups' request to have the explanation rewritten that he worked to provide a "fair, clear and simple" summary of the proposal. The groups had argued that the falls short because it doesn't mention language giving supporters legal standing if the initiative is challenged in court.

"I think we would like to have the voters be educated about what the measure actually does and what it says, and that's why we filed the legal challenge," PhRMA spokeswoman Priscilla VanderVeer said. "If a campaign has to be executed to do that, if the measure ends up on the ballot, then that will happen."

The plan—adapted from an Ohio initiative that's on the ballot this year—would prohibit state agencies from paying more than the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs for .

A spokeswoman for South Dakota Gov. Dennis Daugaard said in an email that the state spent more than $63 million last budget year on prescription drugs, with the majority of that for state health plan members and Medicaid recipients. Weiland said supporters would provide a fiscal analysis of the measure once it's qualified for the ballot, but claimed it would save taxpayers "tens of millions of dollars."

VanderVeer said the proposal is unworkable and would face "huge" implementation challenges.

South Dakota supporters must submit nearly 14,000 valid signatures to the secretary of state by Nov. 6, 2017, to get on the in 2018. Weiland has said the goal is to collect 20,000 names.

Similar measures have been placed on California and Ohio ballots. California's was voted down last year after the spent more than $100 million to oppose it. Ohio's measure will go before voters this November.

Explore further: Colorado voters to consider suicide drugs for terminally ill

Related Stories

Colorado voters to consider suicide drugs for terminally ill

August 15, 2016
Colorado voters this fall will decide whether terminally ill people should be allowed to receive prescriptions for drugs to end their own lives.

Arkansas court rejects challenge to medical marijuana plan

September 22, 2016
The Arkansas Supreme Court on Thursday rejected an attempt to block votes from being counted on an effort to legalize medical marijuana in the state, but two other challenges to the November ballot measures remain pending ...

Arkansas court disqualifies 2nd medical marijuana proposal

October 27, 2016
The Arkansas Supreme Court on Thursday disqualified a medical marijuana proposal from the ballot less than two weeks before the election and with thousands of votes already cast, but voters will still be able to consider ...

Arkansas court says voters can decide medical marijuana plan

October 13, 2016
Arkansas voters will have their say on at least one medical marijuana proposal this November, the state Supreme Court ruled Thursday.

Recommended for you

Study analyzes numbers, trends in health care data breaches nationwide

September 25, 2018
Health plans—entities that cover the costs of medical care—accounted for the greatest number of patient records breached over the past seven years, according to an analysis of U.S. health care data conducted by two Massachusetts ...

Genes may control how tough it is to stop drinking

September 25, 2018
(HealthDay)—When they give up booze, some alcoholics have more severe withdrawal symptoms than others. This discrepancy may come down to genetics, researchers say.

Why industry influence on research agendas must be addressed

September 25, 2018
Industry influence on the research agenda—and the tactics employed by tobacco, pharmaceutical, food, mining, chemical and alcohol companies to drive questions away from those most relevant to public health—is the focus ...

New study finds concurrent use of prescription drugs and dietary supplements could pose health risks

September 25, 2018
A new University of Hertfordshire study found that using certain over-the-counter herbal medicines and dietary supplements alongside prescription drugs could pose serious health risks, especially amongst older adults.

It's not just for kids—even adults appear to benefit from a regular bedtime

September 21, 2018
Sufficient sleep has been proven to help keep the body healthy and the mind sharp. But it's not just an issue of logging at least seven hours of Z's.

Most nations falling short of UN targets to cut premature deaths from chronic diseases

September 21, 2018
People in the UK, US and China have a higher risk of dying early from conditions like cancer, heart disease and stroke than people in Italy, France, South Korea and Australia.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.