Spontaneous humor relieves stress in cancer patients

December 6, 2017, Lancaster University
Spontaneous humor relieves stress in cancer patients
Drawings taken from Lancaster University’s ‘Metaphor Menu’, a collection of examples of different ways in which people described their experiences with cancer . Credit: Lancaster University

Analysis led by Lancaster University researchers suggests that spontaneous humour is used and appreciated by people with cancer and can be a helpful way of dealing with distressing, taboo or embarrassing circumstances.

People can use humorous metaphors (figures of speech) to empower themselves by undermining the illness, mocking it and distancing themselves from it.

In "Metaphor, Cancer and the End of Life," Elena Semino, Andrew Hardie, Sheila Payne and Paul Rayson, from Lancaster University, and Zsófia Demjén from University College London, present the methodology, findings and implications of a large-scale corpus-based study of the metaphors used to talk about and the end of life (including care at the end of life) in the UK.

"We studied an for people with cancer and found that some contributors regularly joke about what is happening to them," says Professor Elena Semino, who led the research team.

"For example, the cancer is referred to as "Mr C," a colostomy bag as "Baggy' and an oncologist as 'the Wizard of Onc'".

Co-author Dr Zsófia Demjén adds: "Making fun of cancer helps some people on the online forum cope with serious, threatening and unpredictable circumstances, and to bond with one another."

The whole study presents what is the largest-scale study to date of in the experience of cancer and (care at) the end of life.

It focuses on metaphor as a central linguistic and cognitive tool frequently used to talk and think about sensitive and subjective experiences, such as illness, emotions, death, and dying. It can both help and hinder communication and well-being, depending on how it is used.

The study examines particularly the metaphorical language used by members of three different groups in healthcare:

  • People diagnosed with advanced cancer
  • Unpaid looking after someone who has cancer
  • Healthcare professionals

The team adopted corpus linguistics – a branch of linguistics that uses computer-aided methods to study a variety of linguistic phenomena in large digital collections of texts known as 'corpora' (singular, 'corpus'), to examine the metaphors used by the three groups to talk about cancer and the end of life.

The team built a 1.5-million-word corpus consisting of interviews with and online forum posts by people from each of the three groups.

They then used a combination of qualitative analysis and corpus linguistic methods to present a range of findings that have implications for: metaphor theory and analysis; corpus linguistic and computational approaches to metaphor; and training and practice in cancer care and hospice, palliative and end-of-life care.

The study shows the metaphors most commonly used by members of the three participant groups, and points out both differences and similarities across the groups.

It reveals the possible effects and functions of different patterns of metaphor use, such as, to engender a sense of community amongst cancer patients communicating in a peer-to-peer online forum.

It argues that there are no inherently 'good' or 'bad' metaphors in communication about illness, but that different uses of metaphor may be more or less (dis)empowering, depending on how they are used at different points in time and how they reflect and reinforce different emotions, self-perceptions and degrees of agency and control.

The study has implications for how healthcare professionals can engage with the metaphors used by patients and family carers in clinical contexts, and generally for how to employ metaphors sensitively and effectively in healthcare communications.

Professor Elena Semino: "By exploring systematically the metaphors used by patients, family carers and healthcare professionals in the context of cancer and the end of life, we hope to increase healthcare professionals' awareness of their own and others' uses of language, so that they can adopt more sensitive and effective communication strategies with patients and their families.

Top ten metaphors revealed in the study:

  • Animals: Used primarily by patients and carers writing online. Both groups describe cancer negatively as a 'beast." Animal metaphors are also used by both patients and carers to describe themselves in self-deprecatory terms, usually because of attitudes or behaviours that are part of the experience of illness. Several patients use 'chicken' metaphorically to suggest that they perceive themselves as the opposite of the conventional notion of the 'brave' cancer patient, and are like a scared animal in car headlights.
  • Sports and Games: Both patients and used the opposition between a 'sprint' and a 'marathon' metaphorically to suggest that, like a marathon, cancer requires sustained effort, determination and resilience over a long period of time. A doctor writing online suggests the 'marathon vs. sprint' metaphor is a good way to prepare someone to care for a person with a terminal illness. There are references to 'winners' and 'gold medallists."
  • Religion and the Supernatural: Metaphors drawing from religion and the supernatural are more frequent in online forum contributions by patients than by the two other participant groups. Both patients and carers online describe distressing situations as being in 'hell' and situations of uncertainty and lack of activity (e.g. waiting for appointments or results) as being in 'limbo." Others talk about the 'green eyed monster' and tumours as 'dragons."
  • Restraint: Both patients and carers talk about the consequences of cancer in their lives in terms of being physically restrained in a particular location. This applies particularly to the inability to leave their homes so the house becomes a 'trap' or they are 'trapped' in a nightmare
  • Openness: The members of all three groups use Openness metaphors to describe the ability and willingness to talk honestly and explicitly about emotions, a cancer diagnosis, and/or the imminence of death
  • Obstacles: The member of all three groups talk - quite conventionally - about different kinds of difficulties as 'obstacles' and 'hurdles."
  • Wholeness: Metaphors to do with wholeness, and particularly loss of wholeness, are primarily used by patients and carers writing online to talk about the consequences of illness or bereavement for their own mental states, self-perceptions and sense of identity.
  • Machines: These include a number of highly conventional metaphorical expressions for people's mental lives, such as 'coping mechanism' or 'switching off' from worries. "Roller coaster' and 'treadmill' are common.
  • Violence and Journey: The project team previously identified that Violence and Journey metaphors were the most commonly used in the data. While there is evidence that violence metaphors can be harmful for , the study showed that both violence and journey metaphors can be empowering or disempowering, depending on how they are used.

Explore further: May I take your metaphor? – how we talk about cancer

Related Stories

May I take your metaphor? – how we talk about cancer

September 29, 2015
"The war on cancer rages on". "It's the start of a long journey". "I feel like I'm on a carousel that won't let me get off". "I'm on the road to recovery". "She lost the fight". "We will beat cancer sooner."

War metaphors for cancer hurt certain prevention behaviors

December 15, 2014
It's not unusual for people to use war metaphors such as "fight" and "battle" when trying to motivate patients with cancer.

'Mind reading' thanks to metaphors

March 12, 2015
Observe whether two people use metaphors in conversation with each other if you want to guess how close they are as friends. Or sharpen your ability to tune into other people's emotional or mental states by observing the ...

How to talk to someone with cancer

October 13, 2017
(HealthDay)—For people diagnosed with cancer, communication with family members plays a vital role in their health and well-being, according to an expert from San Diego State University.

Recommended for you

Function of neutrophils during tumor progression unraveled

October 15, 2018
Researchers at The Wistar Institute have characterized the function of neutrophils, a type of white blood cells, during early stages of tumor progression, showing that they migrate from the bone marrow to distant sites and ...

Delving where few others have gone, leukemia researchers open new path

October 15, 2018
A Wilmot Cancer Institute study uncovers how a single gene could be at fault in acute myeloid leukemia (AML), one of the deadliest cancers. The breakthrough gives researchers renewed hope that a gene-targeted therapy could ...

3-D mammography detected 34% more breast cancers in screening

October 15, 2018
In traditional mammography screening, all breast tissue is captured in a single image. Breast tomosynthesis, on the other hand, is three-dimensional and works according to the same principle as what is known as tomography. ...

More clues revealed in link between normal breast changes and invasive breast cancer

October 15, 2018
A research team, led by investigators from Georgetown Lombardi Comprehensive Cancer Center, details how a natural and dramatic process—changes in mammary glands to accommodate breastfeeding—uses a molecular process believed ...

Cancer stem cells use 'normal' genes in abnormal ways

October 12, 2018
CDK1 is a "normal" protein—its presence drives cells through the cycle of replication. And MHC Class I molecules are "normal" as well—they present bits of proteins on the surfaces of cells for examination by the immune ...

Obesity linked to increased risk of early-onset colorectal cancer

October 12, 2018
Women who are overweight or obese have up to twice the risk of developing colorectal cancer before age 50 as women who have what is considered a normal body mass index (BMI), according to new research led by Washington University ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.