How a blind artist has challenged our understanding of colour

March 23, 2018 by Simon Hayhoe, The Conversation
Credit: Shutterstock

For centuries, people who were born blind have been the intellectual curios of philosophers studying consciousness. This is particularly true for those exploring the way our consciousness is effected by our bodies, especially our eyes, which Leonardo da Vinci described as the "window of the soul".

One interesting fallacy is the belief that people born blind have no real idea of . In the 17th century, for instance, the philosopher John Locke thought parts of the world were peculiar to the individual senses. These parts could be seen in the lack of understanding of people who were blind or deaf. Similarly, David Hume believed that when the senses weren't stimulated by individual energies, such as light or sound, then no ideas could ever be formed.

Even in the 20th century, it was commonly believed that people born blind were unable to have a true understanding of the world around them. For instance, in 1950 the psychologist Geza Revesz wrote: "[No] one born blind is able to become aware of the diversity of nature and to apprehend all the rich and various appearances of objects." Philosopher Thomas Nagel felt that had only the most shallow understanding of colour in comparison to those with sight.

Up until the 21st century, we had little idea about how we could test our beliefs about visual concepts. But then scientists became aware of a Turkish artist named Esref Armagan. Born totally blind, Armagan has no direct visual experience. Yet he paints and draws using not only colour, but also shadow, light and perspective in his unique imaginative scenes.

So how did Armagan learn about colour? The answer seems to be through a creative understanding of visual elements through language and his remaining perceptions.

The artist has strong memories of what he was told about the visual world by his father. Armagan was often taken to this father's engineering workshop as a child, and would ask questions about his surrounding environment.

Crucially, he also had opportunities to use this knowledge. Being an engineer, his father owned a scribe – a sharp tool for scratching, cutting and drilling points on metal – and Armagan used it to etch images on a card board.

Armagan's father would guide his blind son's hand over the engraved lines and describe what he saw. The young artist then practised making lines to represent visual edges and shading, which he showed to family members who provided feedback and more verbal descriptions.

Having mastered visual ideas such as edges and shade, the teenage Armagan began drawing in colour, and continued to seek comments and feedback from those around him. He described this process to my former student Ruth Cole as one of learning by repetition: "By asking and showing – over and over again."

Eventually, he switched his medium of choice to paint, recalling: "I started with coloured pencils and then switched to oil paints. But they took a long time to dry so I finally discovered acrylics."

Interestingly, Armagan does not paint with watercolours, because he builds layers of paint on board and paper with his fingers, letting each layer dry before he adds another. This technique allows Armagan to sense the various colours and shades he's creating as a substitute for seeing his new image.

A new artistic perspective

He has achieved a visual understanding through constant examination and discussion, supplemented through touch (he likens the colour red with the feel of something hot) and hearing (he compares the dimming of sound as it becomes distant with his use of visual perspective). He says: "I have created my painting in my head, including colours, before I ever start to paint. It is strictly memorisation."

Armagan's case challenges centuries of beliefs about colour. What's more, given the accurate descriptions provided by sighted family and friends, his work shows that it is possible for people born blind to understand, describe and create visual pieces of art.

Perhaps researchers should now be finding examples to demonstrate how people can achieve what is thought to be unachievable, rather than focusing on theorising disability. If we can manage this, we may well further our understanding of what the human imagination is truly capable of – instead of having a poor idea of its limitations.

Explore further: Blind people have brain map for 'visual' observations too

Related Stories

Blind people have brain map for 'visual' observations too

May 17, 2017
Is what you're looking at an object, a face, or a tree? When processing visual input, our brain uses different areas to recognize faces, body parts, scenes, and objects. Scientists at KU Leuven (University of Leuven), Belgium, ...

Colour blindness statistically affects every male football team

September 7, 2017
Every male football team statistically contains at least one colour-blind player, with many more watching from home or at the match.

Blind in the mind—why some people can't see pictures in their imagination

November 30, 2017
Imagine an apple floating in front of you. Now see if you can rotate it around in your mind. Look at it from the top, bottom – does it have any blemishes? How clearly can you see it?

Recommended for you

Injection improves vision in a form of childhood blindness

December 17, 2018
A new treatment for patients with a form of congenital retinal blindness has shown success in improving vision, according to results published today in Nature Medicine led by researchers at the Scheie Eye Institute in the ...

Researchers report vision-based neurotransmitter events for the first time

November 27, 2018
How does vision work, and what happens in the brain during the process? As simple as this question may sound, it has yet to be scientifically clarified. Dr. Valentin Riedl of the Technical University of Munich (TUM) and his ...

Minimally invasive retinal detachment has better outcomes, clinical trial findings

November 26, 2018
A minimally invasive treatment for retinal detachment gives patients sharper vision, less distortion and reduced side-effects, according to the findings of a randomized controlled trial performed at St. Michael's Hospital ...

Scientists combine technologies to view the retina in unprecedented detail

November 14, 2018
By combining two imaging modalities—adaptive optics and angiography—investigators at the National Eye Institute (NEI) can see live neurons, epithelial cells, and blood vessels deep in the eye's light-sensing retina. Resolving ...

Eyepatch with dissolvable needles used to treat eye disease

November 12, 2018
A team of researchers affiliated with several institutions in Singapore has developed an eyepatch with dissolvable needles for use in treating eye diseases. In their paper published in the journal Nature Communications, the ...

Calcifications in the eye increase risk for progression to advanced AMD by more than six times

November 8, 2018
Calcified nodules in the retina are associated with progression to late stages of age-related macular degeneration (AMD). Experts from Queen's University Belfast, working in partnership with the University of Alabama of Birmingham ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

dudester
5 / 5 (1) Mar 26, 2018
"exploring the way our consciousness is effected by our bodies"

The body can "affect" consciousness, perhaps, but only the mind can "effect" consciousness.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.