'Right to try' seeks traction in US (Update)

March 13, 2018
Doctors and groups representing patients with rare diseases say the law would create false hope and would change nothing in reality

Faced with certain death, what do patients have to lose by trying experimental drugs that have not been approved for the market?

It could be a child with a rare form of muscular dystrophy. A young woman ravaged by colon cancer. Or a grandfather trapped in the slow decline of Lou Gehrig's disease.

Drugs that are already on the market—if they exist—no longer work for them. They want to take part in a clinical trial but can't, either because they are too sick, too young, too old or too far away.

It is this desperate population that lawmakers—both Democrat and Republican in 38 of the 50 US states—have been trying to help by adopting "right to try" laws for experimental treatments that may be given outside of clinical trials.

The cause is so popular that President Donald Trump and Vice President Mike Pence have put all their weight behind it.

The Senate has passed a measure on establishing a national "right to try" law, but the House of Representatives voted Tuesday not to move forward with its own version.

Republican leaders in the lower chamber said they would try again—and see the measure passed.

Doctors and groups representing patients with rare diseases, however, say a law would create false hope and would change nothing in reality.

Today, doctors can already ask pharmaceutical companies to give them an experimental drug for compassionate use, as long as it has passed the initial safety steps in clinical trials that show it is not toxic or life-threatening.

It's unclear how many drug companies comply, but the US Food and Drug Administration approves such requests in 99 percent of cases, usually in a matter of days.

Every year, about a thousand patients take advantage of this "expanded access" program offered by the FDA.

"People have been helped, yes, but it is unusual," Arthur Caplan, director of medical ethics at New York University's School of Medicine, told AFP.

"Most drugs fail in research," he said.

Pharma hesitant

The proposed law would not actually create a "right," since drug companies and research labs would remain the only ones to decide whether or not to share their treatments.

The difference is that the FDA would no longer have authority to approve or deny, but would simply be notified, particularly in case of serious adverse events.

"Pence, Trump talk about the right to try, but we already have the right to try," said Caplan.

"What they're creating is a right to beg, but we already have that. People do ask companies all the time."

The National Organization for Rare Disorders (NORD) said they are opposed because "the legislation still creates an unnecessary, less-safe alternative pathway that will not increase access to investigational therapies for our patients," said Paul Melmeyer, NORD director of federal policy.

Not to mention the fact that "a drug can make you die more miserably and can certainly make you die quicker," added Caplan.

Opponents and backers of the idea do agree on one thing—not enough is being done by companies that are in a position to help.

Small laboratories, which drive therapeutic innovation, often don't have the means to manage individual requests for drugs in addition to their work in clinical trials.

When it comes to big pharma, they often fear that the death of a patient, even a very sick one, would lead to bad headlines, or a crackdown on the drug by health authorities.

The proposed law aims to encourage companies to participate by giving them legal immunity and stipulating that the FDA could not block any medication from the market if a patient outside a clinical trial dies trying it.

"We're trying to give companies a level of clarity and certainty that they can help someone under the Right to Try program, and the FDA is not going to shut their trial down if that person dies," said Starlee Coleman, senior policy advisor at the Goldwater Institute, a libertarian think-tank that has driven the "right to try" idea.

She pointed out that the French system is more advanced than the US when it comes to exceptional uses of medications that are not yet on the market.

According to the latest report from France's National Agency for Medication Safety (ANSM), nearly 20,000 patients took advantage of individual authorization in 2016 in France, more than 20 times that in the United States.

Explore further: 'Right-to-try' laws: A patient's best last chance or false hope?

Related Stories

'Right-to-try' laws: A patient's best last chance or false hope?

April 6, 2017
(HealthDay)—The Trump administration may have failed in its initial effort to repeal the Affordable Care Act, but some activists hope White House support will prove valuable in changing another piece of federal health care ...

Dying patients want easier access to experimental drugs. Experts say that's bad medicine

March 29, 2017
Former firefighter Mike DeBartoli is a man desperate to rescue himself. He suffers from amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, the degenerative nerve disorder better known as Lou Gehrig's disease, which usually kills within five ...

J&J seeks bioethics advice on compassionate use of drugs

May 7, 2015
Dying patients sometimes seek emergency access to experimental medicines, desperate for a last-chance treatment even if there's little proof it could help. Now drug giant Johnson & Johnson is taking an unusual step, turning ...

'Right to try' laws make safety and efficacy secondary to speedy access

May 19, 2016
State "right to try" laws can give terminally ill patients early access to experimental drugs and medical devices, but they arguably make safety and efficacy secondary to speedy access, according to a new report by science ...

FDA eases paperwork to help some patients get experimental drugs

June 10, 2016
The Food and Drug Administration removed an obstacle from of its "compassionate use" policy this month, eliminating some paperwork that physicians must do to obtain experimental drugs for some patients with immediately life-threatening ...

US states move to expand experimental drug use (Update)

May 17, 2014
Nick Auden didn't live to see the legislation, but the case of the Colorado melanoma patient who died while seeking access to an experimental drug helped inspire a first-of-its kind law.

Recommended for you

Opioids given too easily to children: study

July 16, 2018
(HealthDay)—Many children are prescribed powerful opioid painkillers they don't really need, putting them and those around them at risk, a new study shows.

Study reveals opioid patients face multiple barriers to treatment

July 12, 2018
In areas of the country disproportionately affected by the opioid crisis, treatment programs are less likely to accept patients paying through insurance of any type or accept pregnant women, a new Vanderbilt study found.

Report details possible conflict of interest issues for FDA advisors

July 6, 2018
Charles Piller, a contributing correspondent for the journal Science, has published a Feature piece in the journal detailing what he describes as possible conflicts of interest issues by people who serve as advisors to the ...

Opioid epidemic responses overlook gender

July 5, 2018
Yale health experts warn that current efforts to confront the growth of opioid addiction and overdose deaths must better incorporate an understanding of how women fit into this epidemic.

Study finds no strong evidence that cannabis reduces chronic pain

July 4, 2018
A four-year study suggests medicinal cannabis is not as effective at relieving chronic non-cancer pain as commonly assumed.

Expanding primary care buprenorphine treatment could curb opioid overdose crisis

July 4, 2018
Expanding the availability of medication treatment for opioid use disorder in primary care settings would be a major step toward reducing overdose deaths, write two physicians specializing in addiction medicine and health ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.