Extra sunlight in late summer, early fall could help stave off flu, study finds

March 2, 2018 by George Diepenbrock, University of Kansas

People getting more rays of sunlight—and therefore vitamin D—in August and September could help reduce the severity of flu season, according to a National Bureau of Economic Research working paper co-authored by a University of Kansas economist.

The researchers' key finding is that a 10 percent increase in relative sunlight diminishes the September reading on the 10-point flu scale index by three points. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control & Prevention maintains the index.

That reduction would likely make a flu season significantly less severe overall, the researchers observe, because they found evidence that states experiencing sunnier months in August and September between 2008 and 2011 had fewer cases of influenza in those years.

"Relatively higher levels of sunlight given what you normally see in a state resulted in relatively lower levels of flu for that season in that state," said David Slusky, assistant professor of economics and the paper's co-author.

Slusky's co-author is Richard Zeckhauser, the Frank P. Ramsey Professor of Political Economy at the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University.

The current U.S. has been the worst in several years, according to the CDC, as factors such as the relatively low effectiveness of the have complicated prevention efforts. Beyond the risk of death—especially among children and the elderly—influenza causes significant discomfort to those it strikes, and it drastically saps economic productivity as adults and children are often required to miss several days of work and school, respectively.

Recent medical research has suggested that vitamin D supplementation protects against acute respiratory tract infections, which reinforces the researchers' findings about sunlight and the flu. Humans exposed to sunlight produce vitamin D directly, and supplements such as fish oil also serve as sources of vitamin D.

Vitamin D is fat-soluble and has a half-life between two weeks and two months. Unlike vitamin C, for example, which is water-soluble, vitamin D can stay in the body for longer periods of time. So the researchers were interested in calculating the sunlight an area received for the month of and the month before an influenza report.

The researchers examined the CDC's flu index, which aggregates data reports from individual state health departments and harmonizes the aggregate data onto the consistent 10-point scale. They combined this flu data with the North America Land Data Assimilation System's daily county-level sunlight data for 2003-2011.

Slusky said the paper points to a strong relationship between getting sunlight and the reduction in the number of . Slusky and Zeckhauser—along with Nils Wernerfelt, now a data scientist at Facebook—conducted an earlier study that found a relationship between pregnant women getting sunlight during their second trimester and their child's reduced chances of developing asthma.

Credit: University of Kansas

Discoveries of these types of potential health benefits raise a broader question about rethinking how medical professionals advise people to spend their time in the sunlight without sunscreen to get optimal amounts of vitamin D, Sluksy said.

"I was always taught as a child that sunlight had no benefit, that it was only bad. 'You can get a sunburn or skin cancer. Wear your hat and your sunscreen and stay inside all the time,'" Slusky said. "Now we know that not only vitamin D has health benefits, but also that there is seasonal-affective disorder and related depression, due to lack of sunlight. It's a much more complicated and nuanced relationship. Trying to weigh the cost and benefits appropriately is a broader conversation worth having."

Websites, for example, provide ways for people to calculate the minimum amount of —on their head, neck, arm and hands, without sunscreen—necessary to produce an effective allotment of vitamin D. The amount can vary significantly depending on latitude, weather, time of year and skin tone. In the summer it can be as short as a few minutes, whereas in the winter it can be over an hour, Slusky said.

Based on their geographic analysis, researchers also found suggestive evidence that the protective sunlight effect is strongest in states that have a middle level of population density. The authors attribute this finding to the phenomenon underlying the concept of herd immunity. When the individuals around you get protected against the virus, you cannot contract flu from them, and thus, you get protection, the researchers said.

"If you ride the subway every day in New York City, it doesn't matter that fewer people have the flu because you still have a great chance of coming into contact with a person who does," Slusky said. "If you have too much concentration, herd immunity does not help. With too dispersed a population, by contrast, contagion is minimal."

So, in that case, herd immunity provides little protection, he said.

"There is a middle range of states that are near the optimal amount of concentration such that sunlight is more protective against the flu than in states that are either very, very concentrated or states that are little concentrated," Slusky said.

The middle states that appeared to most benefit from extra sunlight in August and September were Georgia, Indiana, Kansas, Kentucky, Missouri, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Carolina, Tennessee, Arizona, Colorado, Michigan, Minnesota, Nebraska, Ohio, Texas, Utah and Wisconsin.

States that are more densely populated, such as California, Florida, New Jersey, New York and Pennsylvania, saw less benefit from added sunlight in those two months, and low-density states such as Maine, Vermont, Montana and Wyoming also saw less benefit overall.

The study has important implications for public health and the broader conversation of flu and disease prevention, especially in relation to vaccines and other behavioral habits, the researchers said.

"I wouldn't push for exposure and not get a flu shot," Slusky said. "I would do both."

Explore further: If you don't have asthma, maybe it's because Mom experienced a sunny second trimester, health economist finds

More information: Sunlight and Protection Against Influenza. www.nber.org/papers/w24340.pdf

Related Stories

If you don't have asthma, maybe it's because Mom experienced a sunny second trimester, health economist finds

March 30, 2016
The best way to reduce a child's chances of developing asthma might be making sure Mom had enough vitamin D during the second trimester, a new study from the University of Kansas shows.

Vitamin D research reveals bone health concerns

August 3, 2016
Adolescents are risking their bone health because they have low levels of vitamin D, new research with schoolchildren in Manchester has shown.

Season of conception may affect fetal brain growth

August 24, 2016
(HealthDay)—Children conceived during the winter are more likely to have learning disabilities, and a mother's exposure to sunlight may play a role, a new study suggests.

LED lights safer, more effective in producing Vitamin D3 than sunlight

September 13, 2017
Research published today in Scientific Reports showsthat light from RayVio's 293nm ultraviolet (UV) LED is more efficient than sunlight at producing vitamin D3 in skin samples. Tyler Kalajian and his research team, led by ...

Vitamin D deficiency, depression linked in international study

December 2, 2014
Vitamin D deficiency is not just harmful to physical health—it also might impact mental health, according to a team of researchers that has found a link between seasonal affective disorder, or SAD, and a lack of sunlight.

Sunlight and vitamin D levels higher for coastal populations

February 9, 2015
People living close to the coast in England have higher vitamin D levels than inland dwellers, according to a new study published in the journal Environment International.

Recommended for you

Living the high life: How altitude influences bone growth

June 19, 2018
High altitude is a particularly challenging environment—the terrain is physically challenging and the land has a relatively poor crop yield, so food can be sparse. Most importantly, oxygen levels are lower meaning that ...

Risks of cancer and mortality by average lifetime alcohol intake

June 19, 2018
The risk of mortality, and of developing a number of cancers, is lowest in light drinkers consuming an average of less than one drink per day across their lifetime, and the risk of some cancers increases with each additional ...

Bad habits that lead to cancer, chronic disease corrected by simple lifestyle intervention

June 19, 2018
Does this sound like someone you know? He or she spends too much time in front of screens, gets little exercise and eats a diet high in fat and low in fruits and vegetables.

Introduction of alcohol found to adversely impact fertility rates in hunter-gatherer community

June 19, 2018
Fernando Ramirez Rozzi, a research director with the French National Centre for Scientific Research has found that the introduction of alcohol to a Baka pygmy hunter-gatherer society caused fertility rates to fall. In his ...

Graphic warning labels linked to reduced sugary drink purchases

June 18, 2018
Warning labels that include photos linking sugary drink consumption with obesity, type 2 diabetes, and tooth decay, may reduce purchases of the drinks, according to a new study by researchers from Harvard T.H. Chan School ...

Greater levels of vitamin D associated with decreasing risk of breast cancer

June 15, 2018
Researchers at University of California San Diego School of Medicine suggest higher levels of vitamin D are associated with decreasing risk of breast cancer. Their epidemiological study is published in the June 15 online ...

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.