Tough gun laws keep more hands off the trigger: study

March 5, 2018 by Dennis Thompson, Healthday Reporter

Debate over the value of tough state gun control laws has reached a fever pitch following last month's deadly shooting of 17 people at a Florida high school.

Now, results from a new study indicate that such laws are potentially so effective they can prevent firearm-related murders on a regional basis, with the benefits extending into other nearby states that have more lax laws on the books.

States with strong firearm laws have overall lower rates of gun-related murder and suicide, according to the county-by-county analysis.

But counties in states with weak gun laws also appear to gain some protection from gun violence if they are located next to states with stronger laws, researchers reported.

"We found that in states with relatively lenient laws, if the surrounding states had stricter laws we found a lower firearm homicide rate," said study author Dr. Elinore Kaufman, a trauma surgeon at New York-Presbyterian Weill Cornell Medical Center in New York City. "This indicates there might be a protective effect that extends across state lines."

Firearms now account for more than 50 percent of suicides and two-thirds of homicides in the United States, the researchers said in background notes.

Despite this, are enacted mainly at the state level, and varying laws across a region could complicate an individual state's efforts to tackle the issue of gun violence, the researchers said.

Kaufman and her colleagues analyzed gun laws across the continental United States, and assigned each county a state-level and interstate-level score reflecting the strictness of firearms laws.

The state-level score focused solely on gun laws in that state, while the interstate score took into account the gun laws of states near each county.

"Our concept was that state borders are permeable," Kaufman said. "We need to look beyond them when we're looking at the effect of firearms laws. Guns, like any other consumer good or product, can move across state lines quite easily."

The policy scale assessed firearms law strength based on six categories—gun dealer regulation; background checks for private sales; license requirements to purchase or own guns; "junk gun" regulations that limit or ban sales of cheap handguns; reporting requirements for lost or stolen guns, and restrictions on the number of gun purchases a person can make within a given time frame.

The researchers then compared the relative effectiveness of state gun control laws against data from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on firearm suicide and homicide deaths for just over 3,000 counties in the lower 48 states.

The investigators found a clear relationship between gun control and firearm suicide rates. States with weak gun laws had gun-related suicide rates as much as 43 percent higher than states with strong laws.

Individual counties did not appear to gain any suicide-prevention benefit from being located near a state with strong gun laws, the researchers reported.

But when it came to murder, the effects of one state's strong gun legislation appear to ripple across the surrounding region.

The presence of nearby states with tough gun laws cut by half the relative firearm-related murder rate of counties located in states with weak gun control laws, the researchers found.

Counties near states with strong gun laws had an 18 percent higher relative rate of firearm murders, compared with a 38 percent higher relative rate for counties nestled in a region with lax , the results showed.

The study was published online March 5 in the journal JAMA Internal Medicine.

"It tells us that there's a suggestion that having a little more fierce regulation may assist in minimizing and gun-related suicide," said Dr. Stephen Cohn, trauma medical director for Staten Island University Hospital in New York City.

Strong gun control laws might reduce the general availability of firearms across a region, Kaufman said.

"We need to look beyond state borders when we're looking at the effect of firearms laws," she concluded.

On top of the gun control laws considered in this study, also should consider age restrictions on firearm use and ownership, said Dr. Rex Archer, director of health for the City of Kansas City, Mo.

"We know from brain development with impulse control, it's really not until after age 25 that you should be having a gun unless you're under supervision," Archer said. "Until you're older than that, the brain in humans just hasn't gotten to that point of being able to control impulses and not react on something without thinking about the long-term consequences."

Explore further: More permissive concealed-carry laws linked to higher homicide rates

More information: Elinore J. Kaufman et al. State Firearm Laws and Interstate Firearm Deaths From Homicide and Suicide in the United States, JAMA Internal Medicine (2018). DOI: 10.1001/jamainternmed.2018.0190

Related Stories

More permissive concealed-carry laws linked to higher homicide rates

October 20, 2017
Easier access to concealed firearms is associated with significantly higher rates of handgun-related homicide, according to a new study led by a Boston University School of Public Health researcher.

Study identifies three state laws that 'substantially reduce' gun deaths

March 10, 2016
Gun-related deaths in the U.S. could be reduced by more than 80 percent if three laws implemented in some states were extended nationally, an analysis led by Boston University researchers shows. In a study published in The ...

Do more gun laws mean fewer gun deaths?

March 6, 2013
(HealthDay)—States with the strongest gun laws have fewer gun-related suicides and murders, a new study suggests.

Gun laws requiring domestic abusers to surrender firearms could save lives

September 18, 2017
The mass shooting in Plano, Texas, this month was the deadliest of 2017. It also fit a pattern: The shooter had targeted his estranged wife and her friends and family—and had a history of intimate partner violence (IPV).

County smoking bans in bars, restaurants cut asthma-related hospitalizations

November 8, 2017
Expanding smoke-free laws in bars or restaurants may be more impactful in preventing asthma-related hospitalizations than smoke-free laws in non-hospitality workplaces, according to a Georgia State University study published ...

Broader gun restrictions lead to fewer intimate partner homicides

November 29, 2017
State laws that restrict gun ownership among domestic abusers and others with violent histories appear to significantly reduce intimate partner homicides, indicates a groundbreaking national study led by a Michigan State ...

Recommended for you

Tai chi as good as or better than aerobic exercise for managing chronic pain

March 21, 2018
The ancient martial art of tai chi has similar or greater benefits than aerobic exercise for people with the chronic pain condition fibromyalgia, finds a trial published by The BMJ today.

Study: Poor health is a less common cause of bankruptcy than commonly thought, but it brings other economic woes

March 21, 2018
A team of researchers led by an MIT economist has found that medical expenses account for roughly 4 percent of bankruptcy filings among nonelderly adults in the U.S.

Medical expansion has improved health—with one exception

March 21, 2018
While Americans debate the rising cost of health care, a new study of 30 countries over 27 years found that medical expansion has improved overall health - with one major exception.

Study finds bad sleep habits start early in school-age children

March 21, 2018
Bad sleep habits in children begin earlier than many experts assume. That's the takeaway from a new study led by McGill University researchers. The findings suggest that official sleep guidelines for young school children ...

Forgetting details, getting the gist may prompt false memories in older adults

March 21, 2018
Older adults often complain about forgetting, but Penn State psychologists suggest that another problem may be misremembering.

Research study encourages hospitals to reduce number of paper documents created

March 20, 2018
After collecting nearly 600 kilograms of papers from recycling bins at five Toronto hospitals, researchers at St. Michael's Hospital found 2,687 documents containing personal health or other information that should instead ...

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Mar 05, 2018
But does it lower the overall homicide rate? Studies show it doesn't.


Even if it did, the point is moot. In the United States, gun ownership is a protected right. When you make access to guns more difficult for law-abiding citizens, you reduce their ability to protect themselves from criminals who have no qualms about getting guns illegally. Police almost never arrive in time to stop a homicide. But people with guns can stop an armed perpetrator (and they do every year). An unarmed target can't; he's just the next statistic.

After a (statistically rare) mass shooting, gun-control advocates always pimp the suffering victims for their political purposes and the gullible never consider how their proposals would have prevented the tragedy that just happened (they wouldn't have). It's disgusting.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.