Doubt cast over face mask benefit

Doubt cast over face mask benefit
Credit: Heriot-Watt University

Face masks are a common sight in some of the world's most polluted cities but a recent study has cast fresh doubt over their effectiveness.

An international team of researchers led by Professor John Cherrie from Heriot-Watt and the Institute of Occupational Medicine, found significant variations in the quality of the depending on where they are purchased.

Although masks sold for workplace use generally must meet rigorous standards, the study, published in the journal Occupational and Environmental Medicine, discovered there are few controls on masks marketed to consumers and little information on which product will offer the best protection.

Professor Cherrie explains: "If it's important for you to protect yourself or your family with masks, choose the best one you can and look for one marketed to workplaces.

"Don't opt for the cheapest option, choose the one that's most likely to do the best job."

The study assessed a selection of masks in Beijing as part of a larger project funded by the Research Councils UK. It also looked at in the Chinese capital and its impact on health.

A total of nine different masks were bought from shops in Beijing that claimed to protect against fine particle pollution known as PM2.5, which includes soot, droplets and other smaller than 2.5 microns in diameter.

These tiny particles are components of vehicle exhaust and industrial emissions and can penetrate deep into the lungs and bloodstream.

Researchers first tested the filtration efficiency of each mask by drawing airborne diesel exhaust through a section of the material for 30 minutes and measuring the particulate matter and black carbon concentrations on both sides. They also tested four masks on 10 volunteers who were exposed to diesel exhaust in a lab while performing tasks such as talking, sitting, bending over and walking in place.

Professor Cherrie continues: "The findings of the filtration test were extremely interesting.

"They showed the average particle and carbon penetration ranged from 0.26 percent to 29 percent, depending on the material used for the mask.

"But when it came to the volunteers, the average leakage ranged from as low and three percent to 68 percent while during sedentary tasks this ranged from seven percent to 66 percent in active movements.

"Only one mask had an average leakage below 10 percent on both active and sedentary tests."

The researchers are now exploring whether people tend to wear only on high pollution days. They also want to know if the proportion of particles removed by the mask is enough to provide health benefits, and how long people must wear a mask to see those benefits.

Air pollution causes an estimated 1.6 million premature deaths in China each year.


Explore further

Can facemasks reduce the negative health impacts of air pollution?

More information: John W Cherrie et al. Effectiveness of face masks used to protect Beijing residents against particulate air pollution, Occupational and Environmental Medicine (2018). DOI: 10.1136/oemed-2017-104765
Citation: Doubt cast over face mask benefit (2018, May 4) retrieved 23 September 2019 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2018-05-mask-benefit.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
50 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

May 04, 2018
This write up is near useless. It doesn't describe the construction differences the provide the best functionality

May 05, 2018
This write up is near useless. It doesn't describe the construction differences the provide the best functionality
This 'write up' is a press release designed to introduce you to a subject. There's a link at the bottom which takes you to the actual paper, which you're obviously too lazy to read before dropping worthless comments?

May 05, 2018
Thanks otto, For telling him off. Dropping worthless comments is my job!

Actually while madden;y brief, this article did give important clues about WHERE to shop for facemasks. Depending on if your need is industrial or medical.

For industrial, shop the sites supplying welding shops or furniture makers. If medical, go to the sites selling to hospitals, laboratories, sanitation or other Public Health facilities.

NOT retail to consumers! All to many of those sites are purveyors of over-priced substandard products. Usually dumped on Indian Reservations or peddled overseas as "Foreign Aid".

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more