The truth about teenage girls, consent and contraceptive implants

June 14, 2018 by Angela Smith And Julia Parkhouse, The Conversation
Seeking advice. Credit: Monkey Business Images/Shutterstock

For years now newspapers have been reporting that girls as young as 12 are being given contraceptive implants without parental consent. In April, an article in the Daily Mail reported that more than 10,500 underage girls had been given the implants on the NHS in the past two years, quoting statistics from NHS Digital.

These implants – which are put in the upper arm and release the hormone progesterone to prevent an egg being released – are an effective contraception if used in accordance with proper guidance. Though they will not protect against , the implants are intended to reduce the UK's high teenage pregnancy rate (18,076 babies were born to mothers under 18 in 2016).

All teenagers are able to access a variety of NHS sexual health services to discuss and receive contraception. While contraceptive implants are often given by doctors and nurses, in some instances the implants are inserted at school by trained healthcare professionals after an initial consultation with the child, but without parental awareness or agreement. This practice is based on the principles of patient consent and confidentiality.

This has the potential to result in legal challenges, but only if the specific guidance set out in UK court judgements is not adhered to. Ultimately, if harm is caused to a patient and adequate consent has not been given by a patient this could lead to an allegation of negligence.

The law on teenage consent

Guidance on the law of obtaining informed consent applies to children under 16 years is based on two judgements: the 1986 case of Gillick v West Norfolk and Wisbech Area Health Authority, and the more recent case of Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board (2015).

Gillick's case was heard by the House of Lords, which decided that provided a child under 16-years-old was assessed as "Gillick competent" then they were entitled to agree to medical treatment (in this instance contraception) without parental knowledge or agreement. This has since been extended and is now widely accepted in all aspects of child consent matters.

The truth about teenage girls, consent and contraceptive implants
The contraceptive implant. Credit: Michael Kraus/Shutterstock

There is no specific age for a child to be deemed Gillick competent and it is possible for a child to be competent to agree to one procedure but not another. But a child's consent has to take into account their age, their level of understanding, the circumstances in which they are in, and the relevant procedure being discussed. If a child is unable to demonstrate full understanding of the procedure any consent given would be deemed invalid.

Competence and consent

This raises the issue of how much information should be provided to so that they can weigh up benefits and risks. In Montgomery, the Supreme Court held that patients should be advised of "material risks". This was defined by Lords Kerr and Reed as whether "a reasonable person in the patient's position would be likely to attach significance to the risk, or the doctor is or should reasonably be aware that the particular patient would be likely to attach significance to it".

Looking specifically at the practice of providing in schools – and complying with the law described above – there are a number of important issues. First, it is likely that, unlike a GP who has known a child for several years, will have a very limited knowledge of the patient. Equally, having a short consultation to discuss this sensitive and invasive procedure may not be enough to establish Gillick competence. It is vital that children seeking contraception are given all the relevant information prior to the procedure taking place, and that they have time to independently research and reflect on whether they actually want the inserted.

They should also be given the name of an appropriate person to contact so they can discuss the implications and weigh up the benefits and risks of the procedure. However, if a healthcare professional is only providing an NHS leaflet or web link, then the amount of information can be overwhelming for a to take and understand by themselves.

The legal approach here is a crude attempt to reduce teenage pregnancy. But not all girls and women take contraception just to reduce the chances of getting pregnant, many take the pill to regulate their periods, for example. In fact, many girls under the age of 16 may not yet have considered engaging in sexual activity. And in some instances – especially those at the lower end of the age limit – will not yet be in a regular menstrual cycle.

The issue is not that implants should not be fitted, but that they should be fitted in accordance with young women and girls having been given information and advice on the procedure, which then allows them to give adequate time and thought so that they can then decide whether or not to give an informed consent which ultimately should be respected.

Explore further: Why the age of sexual consent continues to be a worldwide challenge

Related Stories

Why the age of sexual consent continues to be a worldwide challenge

April 4, 2018
France is considering changing its legal age of consent so that sex before the age of 15 is automatically considered rape after recent child sex cases raised serious concerns. At the moment, prosecutors have to prove that ...

Infection is most common complication of facial implants

January 24, 2018
(HealthDay)—The most common complications of facial implants include infection, implant migration, and extrusion, according to a study published online Jan. 18 in JAMA Facial Plastic Surgery.

Experts weigh risks of epilepsy drug in pregnancy, as EU considers safety recommendations

April 18, 2018
As the European Commission considers whether to introduce a partial ban on use of the epilepsy drug valproate in pregnancy over risks to unborn babies, researchers in The BMJ discuss the arguments and the implications for ...

Surgeons prepared to treat abnormalities discovered during surgery absent patient consent

February 2, 2018
New Zealand surgeons are often prepared to treat an abnormality discovered during an elective surgical procedure in the absence of patient consent, especially if the patient's health is threatened and the risk of the additional ...

Barriers to contraception for indigenous Maori teenage mothers

March 31, 2016
A new study from the University of Otago, Wellington, has found that there are health system barriers for young Māori mothers when trying to access timely contraception.

Pediatricians endorse IUDs, implants for teen birth control

September 29, 2014
(HealthDay)—Long-acting contraceptive devices should be the first choice of birth control for teenage girls, new recommendations from the American Academy of Pediatrics state.

Recommended for you

Self-lubricating latex could boost condom use: study

October 17, 2018
A perpetually unctuous, self-lubricating latex developed by a team of scientists in Boston could boost the use of condoms, they reported Wednesday in the journal Royal Society Open Science.

How healthy will we be in 2040?

October 17, 2018
A new scientific study of forecasts and alternative scenarios for life expectancy and major causes of death in 2040 shows all countries are likely to experience at least a slight increase in lifespans. In contrast, one scenario ...

Study finds evidence of intergenerational transmission of trauma among ex-POWs from the Civil War

October 16, 2018
A trio of researchers affiliated with the National Bureau of Economic Research has found evidence that suggests men who were traumatized while POWs during the U.S. Civil War transmitted that trauma to their offspring—many ...

Father's nicotine use can cause cognitive problems in children and grandchildren

October 16, 2018
A father's exposure to nicotine may cause cognitive deficits in his children and even grandchildren, according to a study in mice publishing on October 16 in the open-access journal PLOS Biology by Pradeep Bhide of Florida ...

Many supplements contain unapproved, dangerous ingredients: study

October 13, 2018
(HealthDay)—U.S. health officials have issued more than 700 warnings during the last decade about the sale of dietary supplements that contain unapproved and potentially dangerous drug ingredients, new research reveals.

Age at which women experience their first period is linked to their sons' age at puberty

October 12, 2018
The age at which young women experience their first menstrual bleeding is linked to the age at which their sons start puberty, according to the largest study to investigate this association in both sons and daughters.


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.