Gene tests can provide health clues—and needless worry

July 19, 2018 by Malcolm Ritter
Gene tests can provide health clues -- and needless worry
Kendra Snyder, right, talks with patrons at Checkers Bar & Grill in Mount Union, Pa., on Monday, July 16, 2018. At age 12, Snyder passed out from a condition where her heart was missing over 1,000 beats every day. She had heart surgery for it when she turned 20, and doctors said the problem seemed to be fixed. Her cardiologist wanted to know whether her condition was inherited or not, so genetic tests where done. In March, Kendra was told her testing was inconclusive. She realized she shouldn't stress over it, because doing so would reduce her quality of life. (AP Photo/Keith Srakocic)

Last year, Katie Burns got a phone call that shows what can happen in medicine when information runs ahead of knowledge.

Burns learned that a genetic test of her fetus had turned up an abnormality. It appeared in a gene that, when it fails to work properly, causes heart defects, mental disability and other problems. But nobody knew whether the specific abnormality detected by the test would cause trouble.

"I was pretty distraught," says Burns, a photographer in Charlotte, North Carolina. "I had a baby who was kicking. I could feel him moving inside of me. But at the same time I had this ache in my chest. What was his life going to be for him?"

It took two months to get more reliable information, and Burns says she wasn't really sure of the answer until after she gave birth in October to a healthy boy.

Her experience is a glimpse into a surprising paradox of modern-day genetics: Scientists have made huge leaps in rapidly decoding people's DNA, but they sometimes don't know what their findings mean. They can even get fooled.

That can come to a head when medical professionals have people tested for genetic variants that cause or promote a disease, usually because they show symptoms or an illness runs in their family. The testing often focuses on relatively rare disorders, caused by a single gene.

Medicine is getting into genetic testing in a big way. One recent estimate found nearly 75,000 health-related DNA tests being marketed by American labs to , mostly for single-gene disorders, with the total growing rapidly. And this year, the Pennsylvania-based Geisinger health system began offering free genetic testing to its patients as a standard part of its disease prevention efforts, along with things like mammograms and cholesterol checks.

Americans are interested in what their genes say about their health. Poll results released Thursday by The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research found that 60 percent would want to know if they carried a associated with even an incurable disease.

But DNA test results can be puzzling. Katie Burns' fetus had what experts call a "variant of uncertain significance," or a VUS. Many are known: One standard database contains almost 193,000 variants categorized as a VUS, more than twice the number of listed variants known to cause disease.

Each variant may be seen in only one or a handful of patients. But as a group, many thousands of them are being reported to patients, said Heidi Rehm of Boston's Massachusetts General Hospital and the Broad Institute in Cambridge, Massachusetts.

The rates vary by disease. In seeking genes to explain a patient's hearing loss, for example, around half of tests will find only a VUS, she said. A child with symptoms that suggest developmental delay or a related disorder might get a test that examines 200 genes, she said. With such a wide net cast, the chances of a VUS are nearly 100 percent, she said.

That can cause more than worry, said Otis Brawley, chief medical and scientific officer for the American Cancer Society. He tells of women who got breasts removed after learning they had a VUS in a gene linked to breast cancer—only to learn years later that further research showed the variants were harmless.

How can this be? How can scientists not know whether a DNA abnormality is dangerous?

To understand that, it helps to know a bit about DNA.

In each of us, the genetic code is like a text with 3 billion letters. Some of those letters spell words—genes—that carry out specific jobs. If a gene has one or more letters that aren't the ones found in the generic "spelling" of human DNA, they are called variants.

Some variants lead to disease. But each of us carries many variants, and most are harmless. You can't tell their effect just by looking at them. And just because a variant is rare, that doesn't mean it's harmful.

Scientists do have ways to determine if a variant is risky or not, but they often don't have enough information to make the call. That's what happened to Katie Burns.

She had the genetic test done because of an unusual finding on a fetal ultrasound scan. The VUS prompted her genetic counselor to suggest testing both her and her husband to see if they had the variant. The counselor also brought up the possibility of an abortion.

"Termination was off the table," Burns said.

Kendra Snyder poses for a portrait before leaving for work from her home in Newton Hamilton, Pa., on Monday, July 16, 2018. At age 12, Snyder passed out from a condition where her heart was missing over 1,000 beats every day. She had heart surgery for it when she turned 20, and doctors said the problem seemed to be fixed. Her cardiologist wanted to know whether her condition was inherited or not, so genetic tests where done. In March, Kendra was told her testing was inconclusive. She realized she shouldn't stress over it, because doing so would reduce her quality of life. (AP Photo/Keith Srakocic)

Instead, Burns scoured the internet. In a searchable database of genetic variants called Clinvar, she saw that Rehm's laboratory had encountered the variant found in her fetus, and classified it as a VUS.

Burns contacted Rehm, who provided some reassurance. In the years since the 2013 classification as VUS, the variant had turned up in three members of the general public, and Rehm told Burns she suspected that either she or her husband would be found to have the variant. That would give further evidence that it's harmless.

When Burns later learned that the variant appeared in her healthy husband, "a lot of stress kind of eased off."

And in October, her son was born without any trace of the disease.

So how should a person react to a VUS? Genetic counselors say it should be considered along with the person's other medical information, but not used as the sole reason for a major decision like breast removal.

That message has not gotten through to some doctors, said Dr. Allison Kurian of Stanford University. She recently surveyed surgeons about tests that examined the BRCA1 and BRCA2 genes, in which certain mutations can greatly increase the risk of breast cancer. Many surgeons said they'd treat a patient with a VUS the same way as if she had a known disease-promoting mutation.

"That is not a correct recommendation," Kurian said. "Those two things are different. ... We need to have expert genetic counseling more closely integrated into the care of breast cancer patients."

Kendra Snyder, of Newton Hamilton, Pennsylvania, recalls being told by her genetic counselor "just to live your normal life" after VUS results this year. She had taken the test because of a heart condition.

"I was a little upset," she said. "I was hoping I'd have more conclusive answers as to why my heart is like this."

But upon reflection, she said, she realized she shouldn't stress over it, because doing so would reduce her quality of life. As for the VUS finding, "it's there, but I'm not really panicking and thinking much about it."

As scientists find more people with a VUS and carry out lab studies, they hope to distinguish the truly risky ones from those that are harmless. With large population databases that have recently become available, they can determine if a VUS is more common in the general population than the rare disease it might cause—a sign that it's harmless. And combining results from different test labs, such as those submitting information to the Clinvar database, can help.

Meanwhile, any worried parent who consults Clinvar about the genetic variant found in Katie Burns' baby will find a bit of comfort.

In November, after hearing the good news from the Burns family, Rehm updated the database to note that her lab no longer considered it a VUS.

The new classification: "Likely benign."

Explore further: What's a 'variant of uncertain significance?'

Related Stories

What's a 'variant of uncertain significance?'

May 4, 2018
Seven words someone taking a genetic test doesn't want to hear:

Gene editing technology may improve accuracy of predicting individuals' heart disease risk

June 18, 2018
Scientists may now be able to predict whether carrying a specific genetic variant increases a person's risk for disease using gene editing and stem cell technologies, according to new research in the American Heart Association's ...

New breast cancer targets

May 4, 2018
Genome-wide association studies (GWAS) have identified more than 150 genetic variations associated with increased risk for breast cancer. Most of these variants are not located in protein-coding gene regions but are assumed ...

Study solves mystery of genetic-test results for patient with suspected heart condition

June 26, 2018
Although DNA testing is becoming increasingly quick, cheap and easy to perform, the results are sometimes ambiguous: Gene mutations called "variants of uncertain significance" can create uncertainty about a patient's risk ...

A new era for genetic interpretation

May 27, 2015
Millions of genetic variants have been discovered over the last 25 years, but interpreting the clinical impact of the differences in a person's genome remains a major bottleneck in genomic medicine. In a paper published in ...

Researchers identify gene variant that protects against Alzheimer's disease

November 30, 2017
Research published Wednesday in Genome Medicine details a novel and promising approach in the effort to treat Alzheimer's disease.

Recommended for you

Critical role of DHA on foetal brain development revealed

August 17, 2018
Duke-NUS researchers have found evidence that a natural form of Docosahexaenoic Acid (DHA) made by the liver called Lyso-Phosphatidyl-Choline (LPC-DHA), is critical for normal foetal and infant brain development, and that ...

Gene silencing critical for normal breast development

August 17, 2018
Researchers have discovered that normal breast development relies on a genetic 'brake', a protein complex that keeps swathes of genes silenced.

New algorithm could improve diagnosis of rare diseases

August 17, 2018
Today, diagnosing rare genetic diseases requires a slow process of educated guesswork. Gill Bejerano, Ph.D., associate professor of developmental biology and of computer science at Stanford, is working to speed it up.

Officials remove special rules for gene therapy experiments

August 16, 2018
U.S. health officials are eliminating special regulations for gene therapy experiments, saying that what was once exotic science is quickly becoming an established form of medical care with no extraordinary risks.

Genetic link discovered between circadian rhythms and mood disorders

August 15, 2018
Circadian rhythms are regular 24-hour variations in behaviour and activity that control many aspects of our lives, from hormone levels to sleeping and eating habits.

Ovarian cancer genetics unravelled

August 14, 2018
Patterns of genetic mutation in ovarian cancer are helping make sense of the disease, and could be used to personalise treatment in future.

0 comments

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.