Teetotalism in midlife makes you more likely to develop dementia? What the research actually says

August 6, 2018 by Tony Rao, The Conversation
The proof isn’t so clear, after all. Credit: Budimir Jevtic/Shutterstock

Imagine if someone told you that not drinking alcohol makes you more likely to develop dementia. That's certainly a bold statement to make, but it is one that some media reports have put forward, leaving the public wondering whether taking up drinking alcohol will somehow be better for their brains.

A recent article in the British Medical Journal has rekindled the scientific argument over the relationship between abstaining from and developing dementia. The study involved 9,000 civil servants working in London, all of whom were aged between 35 and 55 when the study began between 1985 and 1988. When the study ended in 1993, their average age was 50. The participants' medical records were analysed to identify diagnoses of dementia—more than 23 years, on average, after the study had finished. The results found that abstinence in was associated with a 45% higher risk of developing dementia, compared with people who consumed between one and 14 units of alcohol per week.

The findings for those who drank above the recommended 14 units a week were perhaps less surprising. For every seven unit per week increase above 14 units there was a significant 17% increase in the risk of dementia. The study concluded: "These results suggest that abstention and are associated with an increased risk of dementia, although the underlying mechanisms are likely to be different in the two groups."

A confounded nuisance

So what are we to make of this research? In studies such as this, one of the many pitfalls of exploring the association between an exposure variable (alcohol) and the outcome variable (dementia) is the presence of confounders. Confounders are a statistician's worse nightmare – they are variables that may justifiably be associated with both the exposure and outcome variable.

In this study, abstainers with higher levels of illnesses such as heart disease, diabetes and obesity were those at highest risk of dementia. It may be that having a physical illness is the reason that these people abstained from alcohol. These same physical illnesses may also be the reason for developing dementia. In this way, physical illness unrelated to alcohol consumption could be a confounder for both abstinence and dementia. Drinking may just be a red herring.

The other big problem with studies that explore how teetotalism and dementia are connected is the age range covered. The study started looking at habits at a minimum age of 35 and finished when the average age was 50. But what about people who drank heavily in their younger years or above the age of 55? This is particularly important, as it is likely that a large proportion of the study group will have been part of the "baby boomer" generation. This generation has seen the highest rise in rates of alcohol misuse over the past 15 years – a period of time which is well outside the study's range.

We should also be aware that between one-quarter and two-thirds of older people start drinking more than the recommended 14 unit limit for the first time after the age of 60. These drinking patterns at ages before and after the study period could well have influenced the results. Those identified as teetotal during the study period may well have started drinking later in life

Another spirit level

More than 50 years ago, the late Griffiths Edwards, a professor of addictions psychiatry stated: "It would be too optimistic to suppose that the relative under-representation of subjects in the older age groups … is just explained by older people having generally got the treatment they required or having reverted to normal drinking … it seems likely that this finding is in part a hint of the diminished life expectancy of the alcoholic."

Humans have a longer lifespan these days, so there are more people living into their 70s and beyond – which has also provided the opportunity to look at alcohol and dementia in more detail. By examining the differences between alcohol-related dementia and more common forms, such as Alzheimer's Disease, we begin to see that they are different in many ways. For example, the problems with word-finding seen in Alzheimer's Disease is rarely seen in alcohol-related dementia, which also presents much earlier with changes in behaviour.

Researchers need to be sure that they are defining alcohol-related dementia more accurately for these kinds of studies to be definitive. If not, it is highly likely that they are looking at other dementias with other risk factors, such as high blood pressure or diabetes.

Alcohol is a drug that harms increasing numbers of – and we need to get the facts right about how it affects the brain. Maybe we can't handle the truth about drinking. All it takes is the mere flicker of hope as to the benefits of being teetotal to fan the flames of misinformation.

For those that do drink alcohol, people drinking above lower risk limits has, once again, been given a salutary warning. It is one that we should continue to heed – but we also need to get the message out there that alcohol-related needs to be rediscovered and investigated again.

Explore further: Both long term abstinence and heavy drinking may increase dementia risk

Related Stories

Both long term abstinence and heavy drinking may increase dementia risk

August 1, 2018
People who abstain from alcohol or consume more than 14 units a week during middle age (midlife) are at increased risk of developing dementia, finds a study in The BMJ today.

Largest study of its kind finds alcohol use biggest risk factor for dementia

February 21, 2018
Alcohol use disorders are the most important preventable risk factors for the onset of all types of dementia, especially early-onset dementia. This according to a nationwide observational study, published in The Lancet Public ...

Study examines sickness absence from work among abstainers, low-risk drinkers and at-risk drinkers

June 6, 2018
In a recent study, people who reported not drinking any alcohol over several years were absent from work due to illness more often than low-risk drinkers. The findings are published in Addiction.

Moderate drinking linked to reduced risk of death in early stage Alzheimer's disease

December 10, 2015
Drinking 2 to 3 units of alcohol every day is linked to a reduced risk of death among people with early stage Alzheimer's disease, finds research published in the online journal BMJ Open.

Experts urge review of alcohol consumption guidelines

April 13, 2018
Thresholds for safer alcohol use might need lowering, University of Queensland drug and alcohol experts have cautioned.

Recommended for you

Teens get more sleep with later school start time, researchers find

December 12, 2018
When Seattle Public Schools announced that it would reorganize school start times across the district for the fall of 2016, the massive undertaking took more than a year to deploy. Elementary schools started earlier, while ...

Large restaurant portions a global problem, study finds

December 12, 2018
A new multi-country study finds that large, high-calorie portion sizes in fast food and full service restaurants is not a problem unique to the United States. An international team of researchers found that 94 percent of ...

Receiving genetic information can change risk

December 11, 2018
Millions of people in the United States alone have submitted their DNA for analysis and received information that not only predicts their risk for disease but, it turns out, in some cases might also have influenced that risk, ...

Yes please to yoghurt and cheese: The new improved Mediterranean diet

December 11, 2018
Thousands of Australians can take heart as new research from the University of South Australia shows a dairy-enhanced Mediterranean diet will significantly increase health outcomes for those at risk of cardiovascular disease ...

Effect of oral alfacalcidol on clinical outcomes in patients without secondary hyperparathyroidism

December 11, 2018
Treatment with active vitamin D did not decrease cardiovascular events in kidney patients undergoing hemodialysis, according to a research group in Japan. They have reported their research results in the December 11 issue ...

Licence to Swill: James Bond's drinking over six decades

December 10, 2018
He may be licensed to kill but fictional British secret service agent James Bond has a severe alcohol use disorder, according to an analysis of his drinking behaviour published in the Medical Journal of Australia's Christmas ...


Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

not rated yet Aug 06, 2018
Correlation does not show causation. People who drink small amounts of alcohol are more likely to be wealthier, disciplined, and having regular habits. Maybe.

The causative connection was not established.
rabid rabbit
not rated yet Aug 07, 2018
Don't forget about the social connection to alcohol. People often drink when socializing. So moderate drinkers might have more friends and a more active social life which studies have shown to reduce the risk of dementia.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.