Crash diets are highly effective – new evidence

September 27, 2018 by Nerys M Astbury, The Conversation
Credit: Voyagerix/

If you've ever tried to lose weight, you've probably heard that crash dieting isn't the best way to go about it. Although you may lose lots of weight initially, you won't be able to keep the weight off and may even end up being heavier than you were before. But our latest research suggests that this isn't always the case.

Most are aware that being overweight is bad for their health, so it's not surprising that about half of the UK population is trying to lose at any given time. But many people struggle to stick to traditional diets long enough to achieve results.

Some people opt for a quicker, more drastic solution: crash dieting. These diets, otherwise known as total diet replacement (TDR) programmes, involve drastically reducing calorie intake to between 800-1,200 calories per day. (The usual calorie intake for a woman is 2,000 calories, and for a man it's 2,500 calories.) People on these diets consume nothing but specially formulated soups, shakes and bars for up to 12 weeks.

Although lots of retailers sell these TDR products, they are more effective when combined with support and encouragement from a dietitian or trained counsellor. This professional support helps dieters develop the skills to stick with the programme and keep the weight off once the programme is complete.

However, in the UK, GPs don't tend to refer people who are looking to lose weight to these programmes. This is because NICE, the agency that evaluates treatments for the NHS, doesn't recommend TDR programmes, perhaps because there wasn't enough evidence to support TDR when NICE published their guidance. But recent studies suggest that it may be time for NICE to reevaluate the evidence.

Time to reevaluate crash diets

For our study, which is published in the BMJ, we recruited 278 obese patients. Half were randomly assigned to a 12-week TDR programme, while the other half were assigned to see the practice nurse for advice on how to lose weight ("usual care").

After one year, those assigned to receive the TDR programme lost an average of 11kg, while those in the usual care lost an average of 3kg. Using a tool that helps GPs estimate a patient's risk of having a heart attack or stroke in the next ten years, the people in the TDR group had significantly reduced their risk score.

The TDR group also had significantly greater improvements in blood glucose control than the usual care group. Perhaps most important of all, participants in the TDR group reported bigger increases in quality of life than people in the usual care group.

More people in the TDR group reported side effects, but the number of more serious side effects was similar across groups. Side effects that were more common in the TDR group than in the usual care group included constipation, headache, fatigue and dizziness.

This new evidence suggests that TDR is a safe and effective way to lose a large amount of weight. For now, though, TDR programmes are not available on the NHS. Those interested in losing weight using TDR have to pay for it themselves, which means that many people who could benefit from this treatment may be unable to access it.

Explore further: Are fasting diets effective and safe for losing weight?

Related Stories

Are fasting diets effective and safe for losing weight?

August 17, 2018
Although traditional reduced-calorie diets are a science-based way to lose weight, intermittent fasting is a good alternative that studies suggest is just as beneficial.

Say no to yo-yo dieting

September 7, 2018
(HealthDay)—New to weight loss or tired of yo-yo dieting? Learning "stability skills" first may lead to greater long-term weight loss success.

Readjusting calorie consumption as you lose weight

January 12, 2018
(HealthDay)—If you find that your weekly weight loss is slowing down, maybe it's time to readjust your calorie intake.

A low energy diet leaves people feeling full and eating fewer calories

May 10, 2018
People who followed a diet of low energy density food such as vegetables, lean meat and rice were more likely to feel full than those who tried to restrict their calorie intake, according to research.

Counting your way to weight loss

April 24, 2017
(HealthDay)—The concept of counting calories to lose weight is based on a pound of fat being equal to 3,500 calories, so that cutting 500 calories a day means you should lose about one pound a week.

Lonely and prolonged struggle for people with severe obesity

June 20, 2018
The majority of people with severe obesity have a lonely and prolonged struggle with their weight. In one study spanning more than 10 years, 83 percent report that they constantly strive to lose weight or prevent weight gain.

Recommended for you

Father's nicotine use can cause cognitive problems in children and grandchildren

October 16, 2018
A father's exposure to nicotine may cause cognitive deficits in his children and even grandchildren, according to a study in mice publishing on October 16 in the open-access journal PLOS Biology by Pradeep Bhide of Florida ...

Study finds evidence of intergenerational transmission of trauma among ex-POWs from the Civil War

October 16, 2018
A trio of researchers affiliated with the National Bureau of Economic Research has found evidence that suggests men who were traumatized while POWs during the U.S. Civil War transmitted that trauma to their offspring—many ...

Age at which women experience their first period is linked to their sons' age at puberty

October 12, 2018
The age at which young women experience their first menstrual bleeding is linked to the age at which their sons start puberty, according to the largest study to investigate this association in both sons and daughters.

First ever meta-analysis on Indian lead exposure reveals link to devastating intellectual disability in children

October 12, 2018
New Macquarie University research has revealed the devastating disease burden associated with elevated blood lead levels in India. The results of the first ever meta-analysis of Indian blood lead levels found the burden of ...

The long-term effects of maternal high-fat diets

October 12, 2018
If a mother eats a high-fat diet, this can have a negative effect on the health of her offspring—right down to her great-grandchildren. This is the conclusion drawn by researchers at ETH Zurich from a study with mice.

Sit-stand office desks cut daily sitting time and appear to boost job performance

October 11, 2018
Sit-stand workstations that allow employees to stand, as well as sit, while working on a computer reduce daily sitting time and appear to have a positive impact on job performance and psychological health, finds a trial published ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.