German MPs voice concern about prenatal genetic tests

October 12, 2018

More than 100 German lawmakers voiced concern on Friday about prenatal tests for genetic disorders such as Down Syndrome that they say lead to more abortions.

They urged an ethics debate in parliament as it considers making such tests more widespread by obliging all to cover them.

The cross-party group of MPs, including some ministers and party leaders, called for a wider discussion as medical science is on the cusp of testing for a far wider range of genetic conditions.

"The advances in genetic diagnostics are forcing society to confront the question of how we want to deal with the findings it produces," said Rudolf Henke of the Christian Democrats (CDU).

The initiative in the more than 700-seat Bundestag was joined by about 100 lawmakers from parties including the CDU, Social Democrats (SPD), pro-business FDP, far-left Die Linke and Greens.

Prenatal tests for Down Syndrome, or trisomy 21, have been available since 2012 in Germany, but most parents-to-be currently pay for them out of their own pockets.

The chairman of the German Ethics Council, Peter Dabrock, argued that parents-to-be have the right to information about the state of health of their unborn child.

The group of lawmakers, however, argued that such tests lead to more abortions of embryos considered to have defects and stigmatise people with Down Syndrome and their parents.

"People with Down Syndrome are neither more nor less happy than other people," said the SPD's Dagmar Schmidt, arguing that they suffer not from the condition but from social exclusion.

"Parents of children with trisomy 21 should never run the risk of having to justify their baby's birth," she said.

The initiative comes as a wider debate flares again, with Pope Francis this week comparing the termination of pregnancies to hiring a "contract killer".

A German court on Friday upheld a March ruling confirming a ban for medical practitioners to advertise that they carry out abortions.

Gynaecologist Kristina Haenel had appealed against the controversial law after being fined for spelling out on her practice's website that she performs abortions.

The procedure is permitted in Germany but only under strictly regulated circumstances, and is usually not covered by insurance companies.

The court in its ruling suggested that lawmakers, not the judiciary, deal with the issue and told Haenel that she should consider the verdict "a special honour in the struggle for a better law".

Explore further: Argentina president urges Congress to start abortion debate

Related Stories

Argentina president urges Congress to start abortion debate

March 1, 2018
Argentina's conservative President Mauricio Macri said Thursday that Congress should launch a debate on broader legalization of abortion, though he said he opposes it.

Non-invasive prenatal diagnosis can reliably detect trisomy 21

July 5, 2018
Until a few years ago, invasive testing was the only way to diagnose trisomies, such as the Down syndrome, before birth. These invasive tests, for example amniocentesis, have a risk of causing miscarriage. Therefore, they ...

European court urged not to accredit Down's syndrome tests

June 28, 2012
Groups supporting people with Down's syndrome on Thursday called on the European Court of Human Rights not to recognise the right to tests that would detect the condition before birth.

German parliament OKs genetic embryo tests

July 7, 2011
(AP) -- After an emotional debate, German lawmakers voted Thursday to allow a procedure that looks for genetic disorders in embryos before they are implanted in the womb.

Fetal DNA sequencing potentially could reduce need for invasive prenatal diagnostic procedures

August 2, 2018
Sequencing the fetal DNA that circulates in a pregnant woman's blood holds promise for modern genomic medicine, according to a review article by Diana W. Bianchi, M.D., a senior researcher and institute director at the National ...

Illinois governor agrees to allow Medicaid for abortions

September 28, 2017
Illinois Gov. Bruce Rauner says he'll sign legislation that would provide state health insurance and Medicaid coverage for abortions.

Recommended for you

Juul e-cigarettes pose addiction risk for young users, study finds

October 19, 2018
Teens and young adults who use Juul brand e-cigarettes are failing to recognize the product's addictive potential, despite using it more often than their peers who smoke conventional cigarettes, according to a new study by ...

Self-lubricating latex could boost condom use: study

October 17, 2018
A perpetually unctuous, self-lubricating latex developed by a team of scientists in Boston could boost the use of condoms, they reported Wednesday in the journal Royal Society Open Science.

Engineered enzyme eliminates nicotine addiction in preclinical tests

October 17, 2018
Scientists at Scripps Research have successfully tested a potential new smoking-cessation treatment in rodents.

Nutrition has a greater impact on bone strength than exercise

October 17, 2018
One question that scientists and fitness experts alike would love to answer is whether exercise or nutrition has a bigger positive impact on bone strength.

How healthy will we be in 2040?

October 17, 2018
A new scientific study of forecasts and alternative scenarios for life expectancy and major causes of death in 2040 shows all countries are likely to experience at least a slight increase in lifespans. In contrast, one scenario ...

Adequate consumption of 'longevity' vitamins could prolong healthy aging, nutrition scientist says

October 16, 2018
A detailed new review of nutritional science argues that most American diets are deficient in a key class of vitamins and minerals that play previously unrecognized roles in promoting longevity and in staving off chronic ...


Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.