Kidney patients are the most complex patients

This image shows a cross section of a kidney. Credit: Holly Fischer/Wikipedia

A study published in JAMA Network Open shows nephrologists treat the most complex patients. As ERA-EDTA president Professor Carmine Zoccali explains, kidney patients are highly vulnerable and need special care, but nephrology is a neglected discipline in many European healthcare systems. According to the ERA-EDTA, it is time for better financial funding of nephrology as well as more efforts to raise awareness of kidney disease in the population.

The complexity of varies substantially between medical specialties. This is one of the findings of a Canadian retrospective population-based , involving more than 2.5 million participants. Another important finding is that nephrologists treat the most complex patients.

In this , complexity was defined by nine markers:

  1. the number of comorbidities
  2. the presence of mental illness
  3. the number of types of physicians involved
  4. the number of physicians involved
  5. the number of prescribed medications
  6. the number of emergency department visits
  7. the rate of adverse clinical outcomes (death, hospitalisation)
  8. the risk of being placed in long-term care
  9. the risk of death due to all causes.

Over the follow-up period of one year 21,792 patients (0.8%) died and 217,920 (8%) were hospitalised.

The study showed that kidney patients had the highest number of comorbidities, the highest number of pills to take and the highest risk of placement in a long-term facility and the highest risk of mortality. They were second (after patients with infectious disease) when it came to number of physicians and the number of types of physicians they saw as well as the average length of their hospital stays.

As the authors point out, payment to healthcare facilities is frequently based on patient volume rather than on patient complexity. In their view, policymakers should account more for the complexity and invest more in the treatment of vulnerable patients.

"This is a very important conclusion," explains ERA-EDTA President Carmine Zoccali. "The study showed that are the most complex and vulnerable patients, but in many European health systems, nephrology is neglected compared with other medical disciplines. This does not only involve financial funding and infrastructure, but also the image and reputation of nephrology and the public awareness for kidney diseases. Against the background of this study┬┤s findings, we have to increase our efforts to raise awareness about how to prevent chronic ."

More information: Marcello Tonelli et al, Comparison of the Complexity of Patients Seen by Different Medical Subspecialists in a Universal Health Care System, JAMA Network Open (2018). DOI: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2018.4852

Journal information: JAMA Network Open

Provided by ERA-EDTA
Citation: Kidney patients are the most complex patients (2018, December 28) retrieved 23 March 2023 from
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Chronic kidney disease outcomes can be improved by expanding specialist care


Feedback to editors