Dutch court clears doctor in landmark euthanasia trial

Dutch court clears doctor in landmark euthanasia trial
This Monday Aug. 26, 2019 file photo shows the outside of The Hague District Court. The Dutch court on Wednesday Sept. 11, 2019 acquitted a doctor in a landmark trial that prosecutors and physicians hope will help clarify how the country's 2002 euthanasia law can be applied to people with severe dementia. (AP Photo/Aleks Furtula)

A Dutch doctor was acquitted Wednesday in a landmark trial that prosecutors and physicians hope will help clarify how the country's 2002 euthanasia law can be applied to people with severe dementia.

The doctor, who was not named in court, was cleared of any wrongdoing in carrying out three years ago on a 74-year-old woman. The patient was given fatal doses of drugs despite some indications she might have changed her mind since declaring in writing that she wanted euthanasia.

The court ruled that in rare cases of euthanasia that were being performed on patients with severe dementia—and who had earlier made a written request for euthanasia—the doctor "did not have to verify the current desire to die."

Judges at The Hague District Court ruled that the doctor met all criteria for carrying out euthanasia under the Dutch law legalizing mercy killing by physicians. Applause broke out among the dozens of people who attended the hearing.

The doctor was accused of not acting with due care because, prosecutors alleged, she made insufficient efforts to find out whether the patient still wanted to die. To carry out the euthanasia, the physician drugged the patient's coffee without her knowledge and then had family members restrain the woman while delivering the fatal injection.

Prosecution spokeswoman Sanne van der Harg said prosecutors would carefully study the judgment before deciding whether to appeal.

Steven Pleiter of the Euthanasia Expertise Center welcomed the verdict.

"It feels good for people in the Netherlands that this is a clear view of the judges and court that it is possible to give euthanasia to a person who is not mentally competent any longer," he said.

Under Dutch law, people are eligible for euthanasia if they make a considered, voluntary request for it and if their suffering is hopelessly "unbearable." Patients can draw up a written request for euthanasia to be performed sometime in the future, in an advance directive, which should specify the conditions determining when they want to be euthanized. Doctors must also seek the advice of at least one other independent physician before killing the patient.

Euthanasia cases among people with advanced dementia are extremely rare; there have been fewer than 20 cases since the procedure was legalized in 2002.

Dutch court clears doctor in landmark euthanasia trial
This is a Tuesday, April 10, 2001, file of thousands of protesters as they demonstrate outside Dutch government buildings at The Hague, Netherlands, as the Upper House of Parliament voted to legalize euthanasia. A Dutch court on Wednesday Sept. 11, 2019 acquitted a doctor in a landmark trial that prosecutors and physicians hope will help clarify how the country's 2002 euthanasia law can be applied to people with severe dementia. (AP Photo/Serge Ligtenberg, File)

"The most important issue we have to judge as doctors is whether there's unbearable suffering for the patient," said Dr. Rene Heman, president of the Royal Dutch Medical Association.

He said the organization is working on guidelines for how doctors should handle euthanasia cases in people with advanced dementia.

"As a doctor, you need to make sure people don't change their minds," he said.

Dutch investigators began scrutinizing the case last September, marking the first time a doctor was criminally investigated for euthanasia.

The 74-year-old woman had renewed her living will about a year before she died, writing that she wanted to be euthanized "whenever I think the time is right." Later, the patient said several times in response to being asked if she wanted to die: "But not just now, it's not so bad yet!" according to a report from the Dutch regional euthanasia review committee.

In announcing the verdict, the court said the patient no longer recognized her own reflection in the mirror.

Suzanne van de Vathorst, an associate professor who specializes in ethics and end-of- at Erasmus University, said euthanizing patients with severe dementia puts a considerable burden on doctors.

"There's a living, breathing person in front of you who is not aware that you're performing euthanasia," she said. "This is a very difficult thing to do and we cannot oblige doctors to do this."

The Netherlands is one of five countries that allow doctors to kill patients at their request, and one of two, along with Belgium, that grant the procedure for people with mental illness.

The trial of a Belgian psychiatrist charged with improperly euthanizing a woman with autism is set to be heard later this year.


Explore further

Landmark euthanasia trial opens in the Netherlands

© 2019 The Associated Press. All rights reserved.

Citation: Dutch court clears doctor in landmark euthanasia trial (2019, September 11) retrieved 16 September 2019 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2019-09-dutch-court-doctor-landmark-euthanasia.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
1062 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments

Sep 11, 2019
When you have to sneak in a sedative and hold someone down to give them the fatal dose, that is murder.

Sep 11, 2019
"the physician drugged the patient's coffee without her knowledge and then had family members restrain the woman while delivering the fatal injection"

That was plainly murder. Europeans and particularly the Dutch have lost all semblance of morals.

Begium has turned the Hippocratic Oath on its head.

"First do lethal harm against the patient absent her knowledge and against her will..."

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more