New therapy more effective than cognitive behavioral therapy for depression

group therapy
Credit: CC0 Public Domain

A new therapy developed at The University of Manchester is better at treating depression than cognitive behavioral therapy—or CBT—seen as the gold standard by psychologists and health providers.

The study, published in Frontiers in Psychology, is the first full-scale randomized trial of metacognitive therapy (MCT), developed by Professor Adrian wells at Manchester, compared with CBT.

In the trial conducted in Copenhagen, CBT led to 52% recovery at the end of treatment while MCT led to 74% of patients recovered.

At six-month follow-up, 56% of patients receiving CBT were recovered; the figure was 74% in those who received MCT.

The findings could have major implications for the treatment of depression, which have remained unchanged for 40 years: only about 50% of people respond and a third recover at follow-up, according to published reviews.

Professor Wells said: "CBT has been the therapy of choice for many years in treating patients with - with varying degrees of success.

"We don't know for sure why MCT might be more effective, but it is a method that has a solid scientific basis, grounded in the latest cognitive psychology. We're very excited about the results.

"The focus of the two treatments is different: MCT aims to change basic mental regulation processes that have become biased, whilst CBT aims to modify thought content and is based much more on clinical observation."

The patients in the trial were allocated to receive up to 24 sessions of CBT or 24 sessions of MCT; 174 patients were randomized to either CBT or MCT with 89 assigned to CBT and 85 assigned to MCT.

Treatment was delivered face to face with trained clinical psychologists. The average number of sessions delivered were 6.7 for CBT and 5.5 for MCT.

MCT training is offered by the metacognitive institute UK to health specialists, and consist of eight two-day workshops combined with supervision of clinical cases.

It takes a similar amount of time to train someone in CBT.

Professor Wells added: "We think MCT may cost less than CBT but no formal analyses have been run on this to date. However MCT appears to give results more quickly so fewer sessions may be required.

"We do think MCT may be easier to use because it has a core set of principles that can be applied to many types of disorders and does not depend on reality-testing of different negative thoughts.

"Instead it helps patients to reduce the process of repetitive negative thinking and worrying."


Explore further

Breaking thought patterns increases chances of recovering from depression

More information: Adrian Wells. Breaking the Cybernetic Code: Understanding and Treating the Human Metacognitive Control System to Enhance Mental Health, Frontiers in Psychology (2019). DOI: 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02621
Journal information: Frontiers in Psychology

Citation: New therapy more effective than cognitive behavioral therapy for depression (2020, May 13) retrieved 29 May 2020 from https://medicalxpress.com/news/2020-05-therapy-effective-cognitive-behavioral-depression.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.
2194 shares

Feedback to editors

User comments