Jocks beat bookworms on brain test

Russell Wilson of the Seattle Seahawks escapes the tackle of Kroy Biermann of the Atlanta Falcons during an NFC Divisional playoff Game at Georgia Dome in Atlanta, Georgia on January 13, 2013. Professional athletes learn quicker than university students to unravel complex visual data, said a study Thursday that challenges the age-old brains-vs-brawn cliche.

English Premier League soccer players, NHL hockey players, France's Top 14 club rugby players, and even elite amateur athletes have better developed cognitive functions than the average university student, according to a perception study undertaken by Professor Jocelyn Faubert of the University of Montreal's School of Optometry.

The study demonstrates a possible outcome of the increased cortical thickness that has been found in areas of trained athletes' brains. It also offers researchers new avenues for exploring the treatment of people who have issues with attention, such as the elderly.

" were asked to describe a series of simulated objects moving through three dimensions. Although the context had nothing to do with any specific sport, we found that professional athletes were able to process the visual scenes much better than who were in turn better than the students," Faubert explained. The cognitive requirements for correctly interpreting the abstract moving scenes parallel situations such as driving, crossing the street or, case in point, performing sport. "It would appear that athletes are able to hyper-focus their attention to enhance learning, which is key to their abilities."

The researcher worked with 102 professional players from the groups mentioned above, 173 elite amateur athletes – who were recruited from the NCAA American university sports program and a European Olympic training centre, and 33 non-athlete university students. The participants undertook the "3D-MOT" task fifteen times to evaluate several skills that scientists believe are critical to visual perceptual and when viewing complex scenes: distribution of attention between a number of moving targets amongst distracters, large field of vision, maximum speed of objects that one is able to follow, and the ability to perceive depth. The scene is "neutral", meaning that sport specific familiarity such as play knowledge or experience will not influence the score as the movements and interactions are totally random. The 3D-MOT task was in fact developed by Professor Faubert and can be evaluated by using a graphical simulation machine he invented, known as the Neurotracker, and it has been used by teams such as Manchester United and teams in the NFL and NHL.

The tests revealed that the professional athletes were able to learn how to track fast moving objects at a much superior rate than the other groups, although all three groups improved their score over the 15 training sessions. "Clearly, mental processing and learning skills are key to the excellent performance of the professional athletes. However, it is unclear whether this superior learning ability is unique to , and moreover whether these are innate skills that led them to be selected by these teams, or whether these skills have been acquired through extensive training," Faubert said. "It will therefore be interesting to see how individuals of all athletic abilities improve their perception score as they train with this system."

The study has been published in the journal Scientific Reports.

Related Stories

The ace perceptual skills of tennis pros

Jun 11, 2008

Tennis Grand Slam season is upon us once again with the French Open already over, and Wimbledon hot on its heels later in the month. Past studies have shown that tennis players outperform non-players at anticipating which ...

Strobe eyewear training may improve visual abilities

May 19, 2011

Strobe-like eyewear designed to train the vision of athletes may have positive effects in some cases, according to tests run by a team of Duke University psychologists who specialize in visual perception.

Recommended for you

Fear, safety and the role of sleep in human PTSD

15 minutes ago

The effectiveness of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) treatment may hinge significantly upon sleep quality, report researchers at the University of California, San Diego School of Medicine and Veterans ...

Collaborative care improves depression in teens

18 hours ago

How best to care for the many adolescents who have depression? In a collaborative care intervention, a care manager continually reached out to teens—delivering and following up on treatment in a primary-care setting (the ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

neversaidit
not rated yet Jan 31, 2013
is this daily mail? did i accidentally got redirected?
a misleading, sensationalist title, a misrepresented study.
"distribution of attention between a number of moving targets amongst distracters, large field of vision, maximum speed of objects that one is able to follow, and the ability to perceive depth."
this study clearly tests something that athletes should be better than "average joe", either by training or earlier selection. while technically "cognitive",it's not one that "bookworms" need to care much about.
Shakescene21
not rated yet Jan 31, 2013
You're right Neversaidit.
These skills will help you be a better wide receiver or goalie, but they won't help you understand calculus or appreciate Shakespeare.
be4r
1 / 5 (1) Jan 31, 2013
Yeah, that title would imply they sat them down with a series of differential equations to solve, or even just a standard IQ test. You mean to tell me the athletes performed better at a function that is a central pillar to their proper functioning in their job? You don't say...
kochevnik
not rated yet Jan 31, 2013
This test emphasizes kinetic and episodic memory. These functions are in the brainstem and midbrain. No higher brain function such as language, predication. metaphor or abstract thinking are required.

Were this a true intelligence test, FPS video games and chasing frisbees like a dog would be the epitome of genius
Eikka
5 / 5 (2) Jan 31, 2013
The nerd doth protest too much, methinks.
ODesign
5 / 5 (1) Feb 03, 2013
As a Nerd Speaking for the apposing team (counsel) I'd like to say. . .

This makes sense and seems valid. At some point in life developing eye hand coordination and tracking objects is critical in all child development. The ability to train and develop superior eye hand coordination and visual tracking might be a good indicator ability to visualize in general. It's no accident that professional memory magicians use an imaginary place or physical setting such as a house or even possibly a football field to remember many things correctly. So by that reasoning wouldn't this ability to hyperfocus also apply to general memory and learning crossover. It's kind of like the way playing chess is supposed to make one smarter.

Also, there's a selection bias to be aware of that anyone who makes it up to the ranks of the best performers in any area are going to be smart. It might be more fair to compare professional sports athletes with the top 1% of practicing scientists.