Researchers find humans process echo location and echo suppression differently

by Bob Yirka report
This image shows brain activity associated with echolocation in the blind. Credit: Alan thistle / Wikipedia

(Medical Xpress)—A trio of German researchers has found that human beings listening to sounds that have a corresponding echo, process the sounds differently depending on whether they are using echo location or echo suppression. In their paper published in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, the team describes experiments with volunteers they undertook to understand how humans process echo sounds and results obtained in analyzing their observations.

Echo location is where a person or animal emits a sound and then listens for the echo as the sound is bounced back to them. By noting the time lag and change in volume and tone of the bounced sound, echo locaters are able "see" objects that are around them, and in some cases to distinguish between them. Scientists have known for years that humans, especially those that lose their sight, have some degree of echo location abilities. What's not been clear is how people process echoes when they can see what is going on around them, versus when they cannot. To find out more, the research team enlisted the assistance of several sighted volunteers.

In the first experiment, the volunteers were fitted with headphones and asked to discriminate between sounds that appeared to come from a specific source and then an echo which was made to sound as if had come from a different direction. The team called this a "listening" experiment.

In the second experiment, the researchers fitted the volunteers with both and a microphone. The volunteers were asked to make a clicking noise—which was caused to sound like it was being bounced off of an object providing an echo—and then to discriminate between the original sound and the echo produced. The team called this an "echolocation" experiment.

In analyzing how the volunteers responded to the two experiments, the researchers found that in the listening experiment, the volunteers tended to ignore the echo sound altogether, choosing to focus on the original sound and the direction from which it was coming. In the echolocation experiment, the volunteers noted both the they made themselves and the echo that was produced. This suggests, they say, that humans automatically suppress a directional response to sounds when they are able to see the world around them. When making the sounds themselves, however, their brains focuses on both sounds and in so doing, is able to recognize the difference in tone, volume and direction, allowing for creating a mental map to recognize objects that cannot be seen visually.

More information: Echolocation versus echo suppression in humans, Published 28 August 2013 DOI: 10.1098/rspb.2013.1428

Abstract
Several studies have shown that blind humans can gather spatial information through echolocation. However, when localizing sound sources, the precedence effect suppresses spatial information of echoes, and thereby conflicts with effective echolocation. This study investigates the interaction of echolocation and echo suppression in terms of discrimination suppression in virtual acoustic space. In the 'Listening' experiment, sighted subjects discriminated between positions of a single sound source, the leading or the lagging of two sources, respectively. In the 'Echolocation' experiment, the sources were replaced by reflectors. Here, the same subjects evaluated echoes generated in real time from self-produced vocalizations and thereby discriminated between positions of a single reflector, the leading or the lagging of two reflectors, respectively. Two key results were observed. First, sighted subjects can learn to discriminate positions of reflective surfaces echo-acoustically with accuracy comparable to sound source discrimination. Second, in the Listening experiment, the presence of the leading source affected discrimination of lagging sources much more than vice versa. In the Echolocation experiment, however, the presence of both the lead and the lag strongly affected discrimination. These data show that the classically described asymmetry in the perception of leading and lagging sounds is strongly diminished in an echolocation task. Additional control experiments showed that the effect is owing to both the direct sound of the vocalization that precedes the echoes and owing to the fact that the subjects actively vocalize in the echolocation task.

Press release

Related Stories

How bats stay on target despite the clutter (w/ Video)

Jul 28, 2011

In a paper published this week in Science, researchers at Brown University and from the Republic of Georgia have learned how bats can home in on a target, while nearly instantaneously taking account of and ...

Recommended for you

New research supporting stroke rehabilitation

14 hours ago

Using world-leading research methods, the team of Dr David Wright and Prof Paul Holmes, working with Dr Jacqueline Williams from the Victoria University in Melbourne, studied activity in an area of the brain ...

Team finds an off switch for pain

19 hours ago

In research published in the medical journal Brain, Saint Louis University researcher Daniela Salvemini, Ph.D. and colleagues within SLU, the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and other academic institutions have d ...

User comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

chienfu
not rated yet Aug 30, 2013
Echolocation is an amazing capability which is dreadfully under-utilized in the blind mobility field. I think that raising awareness of it in this form will help to make it more of a household term and eliminate some of the psychological barriers to entry for the blind. Thank you for publishing this.
I am personally a sighted person and have been practicing echolocation for quite some time. I recently published a book called the Beginner's Guide to Echolocation which will, like this article, dispel some of the mystery shrouding this very powerful tool.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.