No evidence that alcohol causes depression, study finds

September 12, 2013
alcohol

(Medical Xpress)—There is no truth to the long-held belief that alcohol causes depression, clinical neuroscientists from The University of Western Australia have concluded.

Professor Osvaldo Almeida, of UWA's School of Psychiatry and Clinical Neurosciences, said that until now everyone had assumed that alcohol caused people to become depressed, particularly if consumed at excessive levels.

"Even one of the diagnoses we have for depressive disorders - Substance Induced Mood Disorder - is a diagnosis where alcohol plays a role," Professor Almeida said. "However, because of the observational nature of the association between alcohol and depression, and the risk of confounding and bias that comes with , it is difficult to be entirely certain that the relationship is causal.

"For example, people who drink too much may also smoke, have poor diets and other diseases that could explain the excess number of people with depression among ."

Professor Almeida and fellow researchers with the long-running Health in Men Study (HIMS) decided to search for a causal link via physiological pathways instead: specifically the genetic polymorphism, or mutation, most closely associated with alcohol metabolism.

"We now know that certain genetic variations affect the amount of alcohol people consume," Professor Almeida said. "There is one particular that affects the enzyme responsible for the metabolism of alcohol. This variation produces an enzyme that is up to 80 times less competent at breaking down alcohol. Consequently, people who carry this variation are much less tolerant to alcohol. In fact, there is now evidence that alcohol-related disorders are very uncommon in this group.

"Now, if alcohol causes depression, then a genetic variation that reduces alcohol use and alcohol-related disorders, should reduce the risk of depression. The great advantage of looking at the gene is that this association is not confounded by any other factors - people are born like that."

The researchers analysed the triangular association between the genetic mutation, alcohol and depression in 3873 elderly male participants of the HIMS study, using data collected over three to eight years.

"We found (as expected) that this particular genetic variant was associated with reduced alcohol use, but it had no association with depression whatsoever," Professor Almeida said.

"The conclusion is that alcohol use neither causes nor prevents depression in older men. Our results also debunk the view that mild to moderate alcohol consumption may reduce the risk of depression."

He said the association observed between alcohol and depression was likely explained by other factors, but not by alcohol itself.

"It doesn't mean alcohol is entirely safe and people can consume it in whatever way they like. We know that alcohol when consumed in excess does create a lot of health problems - but what we now know is that one of those problems is not depression."

HIMS is a longitudinal study of 12,201 men aged 65-83 when recruited in 1996. The HIMS research team, largely made up of UWA researchers, has so far published more than 100 papers on a wide range of men's health and ageing issues.

A paper on the study - The triangular association of ADH1B genetic polymorphism, consumption and the risk of in older men - was published this week in the journal Molecular Psychiatry, part of the Nature group.

Explore further: Higher emergency admissions for depressed older men

More information: www.nature.com/mp/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/mp2013117a.html

Related Stories

Higher emergency admissions for depressed older men

December 10, 2012

(Medical Xpress)—Depressed older men are twice as likely as those not suffering depression to be admitted to hospital, according to a study published today in the Canadian Medical Association Journal.

Alcohol abusers' depression often related to drinking

February 12, 2013

For problem drinkers, bouts of depressive symptoms are often the direct result of their heavy alcohol intake, according to a study in the March issue of the Journal of Studies on Alcohol and Drugs.

A wine a day associated with lower risk of depression

August 30, 2013

Drinking wine in moderation may be associated with a lower risk of developing depression, according to research published in Biomed Central's open access journal BMC Medicine. The reported findings by the PREDIMED research ...

Exercise key to a longer, happier life

September 5, 2013

(Medical Xpress)—Sustained physical activity can add years to life and substantially improve the quality of those years, according to the latest results of a long-term study into more than 12,000 elderly Western Australian ...

Recommended for you

Neuron responsible for alcoholism found

September 2, 2015

Scientists have pinpointed a population of neurons in the brain that influences whether one drink leads to two, which could ultimately lead to a cure for alcoholism and other addictions.

Scientists see motor neurons 'walking' in real time

September 2, 2015

When you're taking a walk around the block, your body is mostly on autopilot—you don't have to consciously think about alternating which leg you step with or which muscles it takes to lift a foot and put it back down. That's ...

Neural basis of multitasking identified

September 1, 2015

What makes someone better at switching between different tasks? Looking for the mechanisms behind cognitive flexibility, researchers at the University of Pennsylvania and Germany's Central Institute of Mental Health in Mannheim ...

Deciphering the olfactory receptor code

August 31, 2015

In animals, numerous behaviors are governed by the olfactory perception of their surrounding world. Whether originating in the nose of a mammal or the antennas of an insect, perception results from the combined activation ...

4 comments

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

verkle
2.5 / 5 (13) Sep 12, 2013
It is the other way around. Many depressed people turn to alcohol. Thus the correlation. I would totally agree that alcohol does not create depression. However, when depressed people turn to alcohol, it could lead to further problems.

Alcohol will temporarily relieve some of the symptoms of depression, just like taking anti-depressant medications. But it won't solve problems.

RobertKarlStonjek
1.5 / 5 (6) Sep 13, 2013
They should have asked some psychiatrists.

And not forgetting that the most depressed individuals never reach old age (the cohort was old men)...
RobertKarlStonjek
1 / 5 (5) Sep 13, 2013
From my Psychiatry and Clinical Psychology Group:
"Excessive alcohol reduces health, causes regret, effects the achievement of life goals, destroys relationships etc etc, all of these cause or aggravate depression.

The fact that the chemical has no direct causative effect is irrelevant. It is the behavioural effect that it has.

Saying that alcohol has no effect because of chemical reasoning is like saying that CBT has no effect because the mechanics of hearing a voice does not alter mood or that knowledge alone does not cause nor elevate depression.

It is the behaviour that CBT and alcohol effect that causes the effect. In both cases, the observed effects are secondary, not primary."
https://www.faceb...esearch/
Sinister1811
1 / 5 (2) Sep 16, 2013
From personal experience, alcohol helps with depression. Antidepressants do nothing, neither does exercise. It's when the effects wear off that it comes back again.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.