Health­care system becoming more trans­ac­tional and imper­sonal

by Greg St. Martin

The U.S. healthcare system today is increasingly embracing technologies and innovations that value speed, efficiency, and cost reduction. Northeastern University sociologist Timothy Hoff says it's being assumed that this trend is leading to a more patient-centric system.

But it's not: according to Hoff, we're creating a healthcare system that is much more transactional and impersonal, rather than one focused on maximizing relationship quality and values such as trust.

"You could argue the system feels more disconnected and personally alienating than ever before," says Hoff, an associate professor of management and organizational development, healthcare systems, and health policy, with joint appointments in the D'Amore-McKim School of Business and the School of Public Policy and Urban Affairs.

Hoff's research focuses primarily on the human connection in healthcare—that is, the relationships and social bonds patients and build together. He is part of the Northeastern University Center for Health Policy and Healthcare Research, which fosters interdisciplinary research and education pertaining to health policy and healthcare delivery.

From virtual care technologies to mobile health apps, healthcare today looks much different than it did 10 or even five years ago. And Hoff says these innovations aren't the problem—it's that our healthcare systems, both in the U.S. and elsewhere around the globe, are relying too heavily on them, and not as much on building a strong provider-patient relationship. He says this flies in the face of what he's learned from talking to patients and healthcare professionals, both of whom value that relationship and become dissatisfied when it falls short.

"Technology such as electronic health records and mobile health apps can further the depths of an already solid provider-patient bond, but it can't replace it," he says. "On its own, it deemphasizes the value of human contact and relationship-building, both of which produce lots of beneficial things for patient care."

Hoff recently published a research article in Milbank Quarterly, the world's leading health policy journal, for which he interviewed healthcare professionals delivering patient-centered medical home care to older adults and analyzed how these experiences shaped the staff's thinking, learning, and future actions in implementing such care. He found that there isn't a one-size-fits-all approach to making medical home implementation work and suggested that assessments of and rewards for this type of care should include more recognition of the value of its social and relational components. The medical home model, he said, is a key innovation of U.S. health reform.

This work leads into Hoff's forthcoming study focused on examining the changing nature of the patient-physician relationship through a social psychological lens. For 18 months, he expects to interview current and retired doctors, nurses, pharmacists, and educators about their patient-care experiences, with questions focusing primarily on aspects of the patient-provider relationship.

He likens the study to an archeological dig, hoping to capture a baseline of data about what the provider-patient relationship used to be like, what it looks like now, and how it is evolving. The findings, he says, could inform both healthcare policy and management.

This all comes as the U.S. rolls out the Obama administration's Affordable Care Act. Hoff says Americans' greater access to healthcare is a major step forward for the country, but he worries that despite this law's best intentions, it will provide greater access to a system that in his view increasingly sees patients as widgets and is under-resourced to provide good long-term, relational care.

How can the healthcare system get back on the right track? In Hoff's opinion, "It's about first committing to a set of goals focused on what we want the patient-provider relationship to be. Once we do that, the technologies and innovations get built to serve those goals. But we haven't clarified these goals yet. For example, the phrase 'patient-centric care' gets thrown around a lot, because it's assumed we all know what it means. But no one knows what it means. It's become a marketing pitch insurers, hospitals, and practices use to get business."

Otherwise, he warns, important parts of the system such as primary care will continue evolving into a highly unrewarding experience for everyone involved. "We'll have a in which will be able to show that you've had the same doctor for 15 years," he says, "but you'll probably never see that doctor and when you do, he or she will have no idea who you are."

Hoff's work focuses largely on primary care, though he sees similar trends occurring in the arena of specialty care. However, he points to two areas where we can learn something valuable: end-of-life care, in which patients and caretakers often develop deeper relationships and trust within short periods of time, and pediatric care, which he says can set a foundation to build continuity of care for a person's entire life.

Hoff also notes that patients are often identified as "consumers" in discussions of healthcare economics, pointing for example to New York Times columnist Paul Krugman's 2011 op-ed taking issue with this label. For his part, Hoff is focused less on the term itself and more on what it implies—that industry has a larger say than healthcare professionals in how to improve healthcare in America.

"I don't disagree at all with calling patients 'consumers,' as long as we understand that they're not the same as people shopping for smartphones," he says.

More information: "Medical Home Implementation: A Sensemaking Taxonomy of Hard and Soft Best Practices." TIMOTHY HOFF. Article first published online: 10 DEC 2013 Milbank Quarterly. Volume 91, Issue 4, pages 771–810, December 2013. DOI: 10.1111/1468-0009.12033

add to favorites email to friend print save as pdf

Related Stories

Patient isolation tied to dissatisfaction with care

Sep 18, 2013

Patient satisfaction has an increasing impact on hospitals' bottom lines, factoring into Medicare reimbursement of hospital care. A new study finds patients placed in Contact Precautions (Contact Isolation) were twice as ...

Recommended for you

Study highlights concern for homeless seniors

1 hour ago

A new study for the Greater Victoria Coalition to End Homelessness, co-authored by researchers at the University of Victoria and Simon Fraser University, has found that a disproportionate number of people chronically staying ...

Mateship key to boosting resilient youth

2 hours ago

Having a supportive friend who is connected to their family and greater community can be the critical factor that protects and promotes resilience in vulnerable Aboriginal youth, according to research from ...

Here's to wine, chocolate and a long, healthy life

4 hours ago

Jeanne Calment, who died in 1997 at the age of 122, remains the oldest person on record. One might assume that she led a faultless, healthy lifestyle. Not at all. Every year on her birthday, as her celebri ...

Experts discuss communications gap on vaccines

5 hours ago

The number of parents who refuse to vaccinate their children is on the rise, and with it the incidence of preventable diseases such as measles. The health community could reverse the trend by doing a better ...

User comments