Research busts myth about weight

February 13, 2014
Credit: Jason Rogers

(Medical Xpress)—Australian National University-led research has busted the myth that overweight people live longer than people with a lower body mass index (BMI).

The research examined the way in which data were analysed in a range of studies, some of which had suggested that can actually live longer and others which had suggested the contrary.

The new study published in the peer-reviewed online journal PLOS ONE provides direct evidence as to why some studies can come up with apparently different results.

"The results are in. The clear truth is that people who are overweight or obese have a higher risk of premature death," said lead author Dr Grace Joshy, from the ANU National Centre for Epidemiology and Population Health (NCEPH).

"It is a pretty simple truth, especially given the clear evidence that the risks of cardiovascular disease and cancer, Australia's biggest killers, are higher for those who are overweight or obese."

The ANU-led study looked at factors such as the width of the BMI categories used and pre-existing illness, to examine why some studies suggested a link between being overweight and longer life expectancy.

Dr Joshy said the studies suggesting that overweight people live longer did not take into account other major health factors.

"These studies failed to take into account the fact that many people with a healthy weight can still be quite unhealthy as they might smoke, or be trim because they are actually sick," she said.

Professor Emily Banks of NCEPH and the Sax Institute, who was a senior author on the study, said that the studies that produced the misleading positive findings about being overweight had compared the risk of death in overweight and to the risk in a large "mixed bag" of thinner people.

"Overweight people looked good by comparison, but when you account for illness and look in detail at how the risk of death varies gradually with BMI, you find that the best BMI to be is relatively lean, at around 22.5-24.9," Professor Banks said.

She said the ANU-led research aimed to clear up public confusion about the health impact of being overweight.

"Although this is difficult news for Australia, where around 63 percent of adults are overweight or obese, it does give us reliable evidence on how to stay healthy in the long term and shows that now is not the time to relax our efforts in the fight against overweight and obesity."

Explore further: No evidence of survival advantage for type 2 diabetes patients who are overweight or obese

More information: Joshy G, Korda RJ, Bauman A, Van Der Ploeg HP, Chey T, et al. (2014) "Investigation of Methodological Factors Potentially Underlying the Apparently Paradoxical Findings on Body Mass Index and All-Cause Mortality." PLoS ONE 9(2): e88641. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0088641

Related Stories

Rising body mass index increases heart risk

October 24, 2013

Research at the Australian National University has found increased body mass index (BMI) significantly increases the risk of heart disease – regardless of exercise level, smoking status and whether or not someone has diabetes.

Study dispels 'obesity paradox' idea for diabetics

January 15, 2014

The "obesity paradox"—the controversial notion that being overweight might actually be healthier for some people with diabetes—seems to be a myth, researchers report. A major study finds there is no survival advantage ...

Kindergarten weight strong indicator of childhood obesity

January 29, 2014

A recent study by researchers from Emory's Rollins School of Public Health suggests that development of new childhood obesity cases, or incidence, is largely established by kindergarten. The study showed that overweight kindergarteners ...

Recommended for you

Yo-yo dieting might cause extra weight gain

December 5, 2016

Repeated dieting may lead to weight gain because the brain interprets the diets as short famines and urges the person to store more fat for future shortages, new research by the universities of Exeter and Bristol suggests.

New target receptor discovered in the fight against obesity

November 25, 2016

The team of scientists from King's College London and Imperial College London tested a high-fat diet, containing a fermentable carbohydrate, and a control diet on mice and looked at the effect on food intake of those with ...

Does where you live affect what you weigh?

November 21, 2016

Adult obesity rates in the United States have reached epidemic proportions, with one in four people considered obese. Yet, obesity rates vary considerably across states and counties.

1 comment

Adjust slider to filter visible comments by rank

Display comments: newest first

PeterD
not rated yet Feb 14, 2014
About time "scientists" figured this out.

Please sign in to add a comment. Registration is free, and takes less than a minute. Read more

Click here to reset your password.
Sign in to get notified via email when new comments are made.